An international law expert says it was undiplomatic of the US ambassador to criticise Auckland's mayor.

On Wednesday afternoon, Jared Novelly took to social media to label Wayne Brown a "boomer" and question his intelligence after Brown declared "democracy's had its day", following a trip to communist China.

Waikato University professor Al Gillespie said there was merit in the comments the ambassador made about Brown and his criticism was fair.

However, he said Novelly should not have done so in a public way, but should have instead made his annoyance clear through the usual diplomatic channels.

"When he speaks, he's speaking not just as an individual, he's speaking as a country and so what people feel is the weight of America in those comments. That that does not help the relationship between the countries when we start to get involved in each other's internal affairs.

"We (New Zealand) try very hard not to say undue things about other countries when New Zealand's got interests, that would be offensive, or interfere and we just need the same respect."

He says the US and Chinese ambassadors were increasingly willing to interfere in New Zealand's domestic affairs.

Gillespie said a recent example of how New Zealand took its diplomatic obligations seriously was the sacking of Phil Goff as New Zealand's High Commissioner to the United Kingdom, because of his comments about US President Donald Trump.

Brown needs to be more 'clued in'

Otago University China foreign policy expert Associate Professor Nicholas Khoo said Brown was ill-informed and didn't understand the complexities of international politics.

His comments were "problematic because they're simply inaccurate".

The US operated within a capitalist system just like China, he said, and it was odd and factually untrue to state otherwise.

While democracy had experienced "some issues" in recent years, he agreed with former UK wartime leader Winston Churchill's assessment: It was the worst system until you considered the alternatives.

Brown also suggested Five Eyes was a waste of time and New Zealand should sell its membership to Japan.

Khoo disagreed: "Mayor Brown is not particularly informed on these issues," which was concerning given his role as mayor of the largest city in the country and a person able to influence public opinion.

"So this is something for us to reflect on and perhaps even consider whether we need more basic understanding of the virtues of capitalism and democracy and also our security alignments."

He added that both democracy and capitalism had worked well for New Zealand and its allies.

Brown, who has been visiting China for 20 years, would have been on a business-related tour stage-managed by the Chinese government.

He should have his "eyes open" because it was obvious his comments would be used by the Chinese for propaganda purposes.

"He needs to be much more clued in and for someone who likes to think he's clued in with things it is surprising he's making these sorts of less than tactful comments and certainly were not reflecting the realities and complexities of international politics in the current era."

Associate Professor Khoo did not want to comment on the US ambassador's view that Brown had been captured by the Chinese government, except to point out that SIS reports had pointed out the concern over China's behaviour.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira