Queenstown's mayor and two councillors were warned that a deal to spread Wānaka's sewage sludge on farmland in Central Otago would degrade the land and could pose a reputational risk for the council.
Details of the council's five-year agreement with contractor SJ Allen Holdings were revealed in documents released under the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act and published by the council.
The documents show a council staff member told Mayor John Glover and councillors Gavin Bartlett and Cody Tucker that the contract would keep the council at "arm's length" from the risks.
Otago Regional Council granted non-notified resource consent in January allowing the district council to spread the sludge - a by-product of the wastewater treatment process - onto farmland near Lauder.
When Lauder locals discovered what was happening in September, there was an outcry over odour, dust, and potential effects on waterways.
Otago Regional Council has since been reviewing the consent, while Central Otago's mayor and councillors have written to their Queenstown counterparts asking them to reconsider the deal.
The documents show Glover, Bartlett and Tucker were first told about the potential arrangement in February, once SJ Allen had secured the regional council discharge consent.
Deal done under time pressure
The district council already had an arrangement with SJ Allen to truck Wānaka's sewage sludge to a landfill near Winton in Southland.
In the February letter, a staff member told Glover, Bartlett, and Tucker that the arrangement was becoming increasingly costly and that SJ Allen had come forward with an unsolicited alternative offer that could deliver a "magnitude of savings".
"SJ Allen approached us late last week advising that they had secured Resource Consent to dispose of wastewater sludge to land at a property located in Central Otago. They have offered to accept up to 2000 tonnes of material from our Wānaka WWTP [wastewater treatment plant] ...on the basis that we enter into a five-year commitment for this arrangement," the letter said.
The costs were redacted in the documents, but Glover previously told RNZ the arrangement saved the council about $1 million.
The staff member, whose name was redacted, said the district council would need to move quickly with a sunset clause in SJ Allen's conditional agreement to purchase the land at Lauder.
"Unfortunately, we are being put under some time pressure to advise SJ Allen of our interest in this offer," they said.
Otago Regional Council granted non-notified resource consent in January allowing the district council to spread the sludge onto farmland near Lauder.
Supplied
The staff member told Glover, Bartlett, and Tucker that the deal came with "real and perceived" risks.
They said there was a notable difference between taking sewage sludge to landfill and spreading it on farmland.
"Wastewater sludges include contaminants and the land will be subject to degradation as a result of the application of these materials. The resource consent will have considered these within the assessment of environmental effects, and we will be at arm's length from this due to the contractual arrangement," they wrote.
"Risks associated with contamination and consent compliance will sit with the consent holder, but should issues occur, these could lead to reputational damage for QLDC."
The council sent a final contract to SJ Allen in April.
Glover previously told RNZ his council had relied on the consent in good faith, but he was open to discussing alternative arrangements.
High E coli readings, less-than-minor adverse effects
The documents also reveal high levels of pathogens in the wastewater sludge, with E coli concentrations of 650,000 units per 100mL.
The material was being trucked straight from the plant without undergoing heat-drying, composting or microbial stabilisation, an Otago Regional Council report said.
That meant instead of being categorised as a biosolid, which could be beneficially used as a soil fertiliser or conditioner, it was considered raw sewage sludge.
Regional council planners considering the consent application wrote that spreading the sludge on Lauder farmland was a "relatively novel approach to disposing of the proposed waste" but determined that any adverse effects on the nearby environment including soil, groundwater, wetlands, air quality and human health would be less than minor.
The planners said potential odour or surface run-off would not extend beyond the property boundaries.
They noted that written approval had been provided by Kā Rūnaka via its company Aukaha Ltd.
The documents showed that sludge spreading would be restricted to a 50-hectare trial block for the first year.
The contract also included a clause stating that the waste would need to be diverted to the Southland landfill if winter weather or saturated soil made spreading unsafe.
The documents showed regional council staff did not visit the Lauder site before granting the consent.
"There was considered to be sufficient photographic evidence, plans and aerial mapping information of the site...the scale and the nature of the activity proposed means that a site visit was not required in this instance."
While SJ Allen had sought a 35-year consent, Otago Regional Council opted to grant a 15-year consent.
Otago Regional Council and Queenstown Lakes District Council have been contacted for comment.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira