Expressing shock over a case where a metropolitan magistrate and a sessions judge in Chennai had denied bail in a case booked for bailable offences, the Madras High Court has reminded judicial officers in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry that they do not enjoy any such discretion.

Justice N. Ramesh held that even if the accused had mentioned a wrong provision of the law under which they had sought bail, it would be the duty of the judicial officers to find out whether the offences for which the petitioners had been arrested were bailable or not, and then take an appropriate decision.

“If the offences are bailable and the accused is prepared to give bail, he shall be released under Section 478(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS). The police officer, the magistrate, the court of session, or this court would have no discretion to refuse,” the judge wrote.

When bail can be denied

The judge made it clear that the gravity of an accusation, the stage of investigation, an awaited forensic report, antecedents of the petitioner, or the apprehension of absconding or tampering with evidence could be cited as grounds only for denying bail in non-bailable offences and not in cases related to bailable offences.

Further, while granting bail for bailable offences, “the court may fix the amount of the bond and decide whether sureties are required. It may not attach any other condition. An accused who is indigent, or who is unable to give a bail bond within a week of his arrest, must be released on his own bond,” the judge added.

Justice Ramesh further made it clear that a bail granted in respect of bailable offences could be cancelled only by the High Court if the conduct of the accused, after his release, was found to be prejudicial to a fair trial. He also said that if a person had violated the conditions of a bail bond in some case, then he could be denied bail in the next case even if the offences in the subsequent case were bailable.

The judge pointed out that the BNSS, as well as special legislations related to criminal offences, clearly specify the list of offences, such as those which carry a maximum punishment of three years, which were bailable, and those which were non-bailable.

He directed the High Court’s Registrar General Deepthi Arivunithi to circulate a copy of his order to all Principal District and Sessions Judges and the Chief Judicial Magistrates in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry so that it could be brought to the notice of judicial officers across the State and the Union Territory. A copy should also be sent to the Director of the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy, the judge said.

Case involving post against CM Vijay

The orders were passed while granting bail to P. Rajagopal of Thiruvanmiyur in Chennai, who was arrested by the Chennai Cyber Crime police on October 22, 2026, for having posted an obscene, abusive, and derogatory remark against Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay on the X handle of the accused on June 12, 2026.

The petitioner was booked under Sections 296(b) (using abusive words) of the BNSS and 67 of the Information Technology Act, 2000. However, there was nothing on record to show that the police had informed the accused that both the provisions were bailable, the judge said.

Consequently, the accused ended up filing a bail petition before a metropolitan magistrate in Saidapet under Section 480 of the BNSS, which deals with the grant of bail in non-bailable offences, instead of filing it under Section 478, which deals with the grant of bail in bailable offences.

The metropolitan magistrate, on October 27, 2026, dismissed the petitioner’s first bail petition “considering the grave nature of the offence” and the fact that the investigation was pending and that the petitioner’s involvement in any other cases had to be ascertained.

The magistrate also said that, if the accused was released on bail, there was every possibility of him absconding and tampering with the evidence. However, the judicial officer did not take note of the fact that both the penal provisions invoked against the petitioner were bailable.

Subsequently, the Principal Sessions Court in Chennai too dismissed the petitioner’s bail plea on November 2, 2026, considering “the gravity of the offence and the nascent stage of the investigation.” The sessions court had dismissed another bail plea too on November 5, 2026, on the ground that there was no change in the circumstances since the dismissal of the previous petition.

Holding that the judicial officers had erred in denying bail in a case booked for bailable offences and thereby forced the petitioner to remain in jail for several days, Justice Ramesh ordered his release forthwith on executing a bond for ₹25,000 along with two sureties for a like sum.

Source: The Hindu · Mohamed Imranullah S.

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇳 IN
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira