Migrant rights organisations have warned that proposed changes to naturalisation rules could make Ireland less attractive to workers, deepen inequality and create further barriers to citizenship.

The Oireachtas Committee on Justice heard that proposed changes to citizenship rules could leave some migrants waiting up to 11 or 12 years to reunite with family members, making it more difficult for workers who have made Ireland their home to become citizens.

Representatives of five migrant rights organisations raised concerns about the proposed legislation at the first meeting of the Joint Committee on the issue earlier this month.

They warned that the proposed changes risked creating further insecurity for migrants and that the proposed bill could undermine an ability to attract and retain workers here.

Campaigns Co-ordinator with the Migrant Rights Centre of Ireland (MRCI) Dave Gibney told the committee that the organisation had conducted a survey of approximately 900 people the previous week.

Of those surveyed, 86% said that having a realistic pathway to citizenship had influenced their decision to choose Ireland, while 55% said they would consider moving from Ireland if the proposed legislation became law.

Colm O'Gorman of The Open Community warned that the citizenship proposals could damage Ireland’s reputation as a destination for migrant workers.

He said Ireland was already struggling to compete under its existing employment migration framework, and the changes would make the country less attractive.

CEO of the Immigrant Council of Ireland (ICI) Teresa Buczkowska has lived in Ireland for 21 years.

She explained to the committee how frequent work-related travel had affected her eligibility for citizenship.

She said she had built her life in Ireland but was unable to qualify for citizenship because of the number of days she had spent abroad for work.

She questioned how the proposed legislation could affect people in similar circumstances.

Mr Gibney said workers were concerned about being excluded because of their financial circumstances, including receiving social welfare support or having outstanding debts.

The Social Democrats TD Gary Gannon pointed out that a nurse employed for 40 hours a week at the Mater Hospital in Dublin could face difficulties if she needed to live close to her workplace, in an area with some of the country’s highest rents.

He asked if the worker could be penalised in seeking citizenship if she needed housing assistance, but the organisations said this was not clear from the proposed legislation.

MRCI Director Neil Bruton said people could find themselves working in jobs at salary levels determined by the State yet still be deemed insufficiently wealthy to become citizens.

Ms Buczkowska said it was worth thinking about scenarios like domestic workers who may not earn enough to meet requirements, despite making an important contribution to the economy by caring for the children of working families.

Mr Gibney described the proposed family reunification requirements as harsh and cruel and suggested that they could result in families being separated for 11 or 12 years.

Independent Senator Lynn Ruane said minimum income requirements risked creating further class divisions.

She questioned whether the proposals would give people on higher incomes greater access to family reunification while excluding those on lower wages.

The Department said many other countries required applicants to demonstrate stable income and employment and to have no outstanding debts.

Minster for Justice Jim O'Callaghan
Minster for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has said previously that the proposed changes are 'reasonable'

It added that it had examined naturalisation requirements across 31 states and that Ireland was currently an outlier in not having language or civic requirements.

The committee also heard criticism of the existing immigration registration and renewal system, with representatives describing increasing delays and administrative difficulties.

Catherine Cosgrave of the Immigrant Council of Ireland said she had been required to make legal representations and threaten judicial review in cases where applications were stalled because of administrative problems on the State’s side rather than any failure by applicants.

She said applications had been accepted following such interventions.

Doras representatives also pointed out that problems with Irish Residence Permit (IRP) renewals had increased significantly over the past 12 to 18 months, creating considerable stress for migrants.

Sinn Féin Deputy and Committee Chair Matt Carthy said his constituency office had seen a dramatic increase in correspondence about permit renewals and related processes.

He said the proportion of queries relating to the issue had risen by around 20% in the last 18 months.

The Department rejected any suggestion that delays in processing applications were deliberate, acknowledging that backlogs could occur, but insisting there was no deliberate policy of delaying applications.

Nasc’s Kostas Kapantais said the digitalisation of the system had created particular problems.

He said technical issues and the volume of applications were contributing to employment difficulties, as employers sought evidence that workers had applied to renew their permission.

The Department suggested that people could instead apply for long-term residency.

However, Ms Cosgrave of the immigrant Council said Ireland’s long-term residency arrangements were inadequate.

She said Ireland had ranked poorly in an assessment carried out in 2011 because it did not have a statutory framework for long-term residency.

She called for much simpler procedures.

Fine Gael deputy Catherine Callaghan questioned whether there was any positive consequence to extending the citizenship residency requirement from five to eight years.

Ms Buczkowska said they had seen no evidence that the change would be beneficial.

Deputy Callaghan suggested that the longer period could establish a stronger connection with Ireland and noted that similar requirements existed in other countries.

However, Mr O’Gorman questioned why extending the period of reunification would necessarily strengthen migrants’ connection to the State.

He said the Government should consider whether the proposals would make Ireland more attractive or simply create additional barriers.

Source: RTÉ News · Ailbhe Conneely

At a glance

Topic
Politics
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira