November 18, 2026 — 8:00pm

Photo: Megan Herbert

To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@theage.com.au. Please include your home address and telephone number. No attachments, please include your letter in the body of the email. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.

Some “voting priorities have changed” as Annika Smethurst writes, but some things remain important (“Teal movement faces test in a changed political environment”, 18/11). Independents campaign on climate change action, integrity and equality, which are perennial.
Integrity is important to voters, as evidenced by the distrust of state Labor following corruption on the Big Build. Equity is very much an issue, given increasing inequality and disenchantment of people with the major parties as a result. Gender inequality particularly is important to women, given escalating rates of family violence. Climate change action is more important than ever, given emissions are likely to rise to 2.8 per cent by the end of the century.
Certainly people are not so focused on the latter, given their preoccupation with cost of living. The great strength of the community independent movement is that they are only responsible to their constituents, not third parties. They are only answerable to their own people. Sounds very different to other candidates and very compelling.
Jan Marshall, Brighton

Public does not have collective amnesia
Ben Carroll’s campaign thus far suggests that he is trying to run on his time as premier over the past four months rather than on the previous 11 years and eight months when he was a member of the government. Is he seriously expecting us all to have collective amnesia about the mismanagement of this state by two previous Labor premiers?
Ivan Glynn, Vermont

Trying to discern spin from promise
The Age editorial (18/11) focused on Victoria’s health system quoting statistics that illustrate what needs to be addressed urgently. The major parties are promising the recruitment of extra nurses and support staff, but don’t detail how recruitment will be achieved. Nor do they address the systematic failures of past administrations’ cuts.
With the general dissatisfaction of voters with politicians in the community these election promises should be interpreted as mere political spin.
Peter Roche, Carlton

The sausage sizzle was there long before voting
As Victorians head to polling places and the media starts waxing lyrical about ″⁣democracy sausages″⁣, let us remember that the schools, churches and community groups whose premises are used as polling places have long run fundraising stalls during elections. Homemade cakes and biscuits pre-date sausage sizzles at school polling places and in fact, ironically, it is because of the undemocratic state of funding of government schools that parents and the wider school community supporters need to run sausage sizzles and other such fundraising stalls.
Dianne Anderson, Bundoora

Debate behind a paywall not good for democracy
Very disappointing that the only way for voters to see the Victoria people’s forum debate was behind a paywall. There needs to be changes to legislation so that future debates are free to air so that all voters have an opportunity to be fully informed.
Dianne Lewis, Mt Martha

Climate change the unspoken issue
Climate change is apparently not a major issue in this election (“Teal movement faces test in a changed political environment”, 18/11), whereas cost of living, crime rates and fatigue are. People who are genuinely concerned about the cost of food, housing, insurances, crime, the condition of our roads etc., should be very concerned about addressing climate change. It will continue to exacerbate the costs for goods and services as it becomes harder to produce food, with more heat, floods and fires, more disgruntled people, more damage to infrastructure and all these issues will simply escalate as time goes on. We can’t drop the ball now.
Roger East, Balwyn North

THE FORUM

Creators under siege
″⁣Intelligence″⁣ that plunders the internet to steal information and other content that it does not own or understand (because it needs to ″⁣train″⁣ itself) sounds more like ″⁣intelligence″⁣ of the espionage type rather than intellectual.
AI supports scaling up, but that is the antithesis of the work and world of creators, whose livelihoods depend on their unique, personal creations. Given all it claims to do, there is no obstacle whatsoever to AI obtaining copyright clearance and paying due fees to the copyright owners: they just don’t want to, and so see fit to glorify their theft as something worthy while casting others’ rights as some kind of unwarranted obstacle to their operations. Pure spin, to win support from decision-makers, and a direct threat to the hard-won rights of creators, generally small and powerless, coming from a bullying, powerful force.
Emma Borghesi, Rye

Tend to nature
Our faunal emblem, the Leadbeater’s possum, would thank your correspondents for speaking up for nature – its lowland population has all but vanished from the wild (“Give nature its due”, 17/11, and “More to voters’ concerns than potholes”, 18/11). The Biodiversity Council reports that Victoria is the ″⁣nature poorest″⁣ state. We have the most percentage of land cleared and more than 2000 threatened species. Logging continues through loopholes, and hollow-bearing trees, homes for animals which take a century or more to form, are still being felled in the name of fire management. Whoever gets the keys to Spring Street should turn over a new leaf on nature.
Andrea Summits, Kew

Open the gates
I wonder whether people have any idea why ″⁣gate″⁣ is always tacked onto any political or sporting cover-up or scandal? Remember the PM’s ″⁣melon-gate″⁣ nonsense last month? Baby Boomers remember the attempt by then US president Richard Nixon to cover up the scandal at the Watergate hotel break-in which eventually led to his resignation in 1974. Momentous indeed. If we are going to use the term, we should know where it comes from.
Nick Toovey, Beaumaris

Pack it away
Some commentators thrive on describing changes like the proposed backpacker visa rules as backdowns (″⁣Deal close to sending British backpackers out to the bush″⁣, 17/11). Equally they could be called sensible adjustments after the federal government listened to, and took note of, constructive feedback. We unconsciously project our own sensibilities.
Kevin Burke, Sandringham

A horse’s death
The racing industry has both the resources and the responsibility to establish appropriate arrangements for the disposal of horses that die in its care. The death of So You Are has highlighted a much wider issue: the public rarely thinks about what happens to an animal’s body after death (“Body of Melbourne Cup runner found dumped in Sydney skip bin”, 18/11).
The public outrage over the discovery of his remains in a rubbish skip is understandable. A skip is associated with things discarded and unwanted. The symbolism is confronting, particularly for a horse so recently celebrated. But does the appearance of a disposal method necessarily reflect how the animal was valued or treated?
Horses are magnificent animals and deserve compassionate care throughout their lives and humane treatment when they die. But their bodies are large and difficult to manage. Burial and cremation are not always practical, and the recovery of animal byproducts has long been part of animal management.
Remains must be handled safely and appropriately, but perhaps our outrage also reflects an unwillingness to confront the practical realities of death.
We celebrate the living animal but rarely consider what happens next.
Protecting public sensibilities and ensuring animal welfare are not necessarily the same thing.
Catherine Ford, Frankston South

Disposable, despicable
The despicable treatment of the remains of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are repulsed and angered me. A noble beast treated like a disposable nappy.
The fact that there is no establishment in NSW to cremate such animals needs to be addressed urgently. The New Zealand racehorsing authorities seem to have had the heart to invest in such a facility. Surely the NSW racing industry is not short of the cash to provide such an establishment itself?
The Victorian state government should also review the regulations pertaining to the disposal of racehorses so they, and indeed all animals, are afforded the dignity they deserve on death.
A society’s moral worth can be gauged by how it treats its animals.
Jennifer Quigley, Balwyn

What evidence?
I read with concern that the NHMRC had decided to approve the provision of puberty blockers to gender-diverse children and adolescents, apparently disregarding recent medical scientific evidence (″⁣Fight brews on trans drug″⁣, 17/11).
In 2024, respected paediatrician Dr Hilary Cass published a review of the scientific and clinical evidence for the efficacy and safety of puberty blockers. She concluded that the evidence for benefit and safety was at best weak and expressed concerns about the safety of these powerful medications providing uncertain benefits with significant risks. She urged the adoption of a holistic approach whereby a complete assessment is performed, including screening for neurodivergence and psychological issues. This was also supported by the Commission On Human Medicines, which stated that puberty blockers posed an unacceptable safety risk for children and young people.
Following these reports and recommendations, the UK banned the prescription of puberty blockers to children under the age of 18. Several other countries, including Finland, Italy, Norway, Sweden, and in Australia Queensland and the Northern Territory have done likewise. Why then, has the NHMRC now decided to approve puberty blockers? What has changed? Is there new medical scientific evidence to support this decision?
Dr Leslie Chester, Brighton

Don’t forget the climate
Reading the news you’d think that voters are only concerned about short-term issues such as potholes. If so, have we forgotten our precarious co-existence with nature? Our civilisation can easily fall into a very large pothole if we don’t take care of this balance with nature.
The article ″⁣Greenhouse pollution down as global warming surges″⁣ (10/11) should remind us that climate change action should be an important priority when we vote.
Unfortunately, One Nation won’t even accept the science, while the Coalition is promising to encourage more gas and attempt to hinder renewable energy projects. Labor’s policies are better but their federal and interstate colleagues allow expansion of fossil fuel projects. This action is stunning as nations around the world cry ″⁣No more fossil fuels″⁣. At least the Greens, teals and some independents argue from the side to do something more realistic.
Michael Weadon, Ballarat

AI ripple effects
The increasing loss of jobs caused by AI replacing workers risks a major recession.
If people lose their jobs, they can’t buy products. If they can’t buy products, the efficiencies created by AI cannot be turned into profit. If there is no profit, the companies which use AI will collapse and any remaining employees will be out of work, creating more people who can’t afford to buy.
If people can’t buy, then all the harvesting of information held in data centres will be of no use. If that data is of no use and doesn’t generate income, the data centres will close and the data centre owners will not be able to recoup their investment and make a profit.
If people lose their incomes, they can’t pay their mortgages. This will lead to a glut of properties on the market, depressing property values further.
If people lose their jobs, they can’t pay tax. No tax collection means the government will not have enough money to run the country.
What is the AI revolution trying to achieve? Is it illusory economic efficiency, or the pursuit of power by making people vulnerable?
Al exists by stealing other people’s original work. It then uses that stolen work to put the originators out of work.
Michael Meszaros, Alphington

They walk among us
Regarding Ross Gittins’ column on our fossil fuel dilemma (18/11), palaeontologists may need to rewrite the textbooks. Contrary to popular belief, the dinosaurs never actually went extinct, they just traded scales for suits and entered politics.
Roaring loudly about climate scepticism and stomping on renewable energy plans, this stubborn species seems entirely unfazed by the looming asteroid of global warming. Rather than evolving with the rest of the planet, certain right-wing politicians are determined to drag voters straight back to the Jurassic period, where coal is king and long-term planning is a foreign concept.
It is darkly amusing to watch leaders treat ancient fossil fuels like an endangered species that needs protecting, all in a desperate bid to hunt down a few short-term votes. Still, nature has a funny way of dealing with creatures that refuse to adapt to a changing climate.
If our politicians keep ignoring the warning signs, they might just find themselves joining their prehistoric cousins in the museum.
Paul Caine, Glen Huntly

Photo: Matt Golding

AND ANOTHER THING

World affairs
Robert F. Kennedy jnr will go down in history as the man who lost the United States’ measles-free status.
Reg Murray, Glen Iris

Anthony Albanese probably knows he is in difficult waters politically in Australia. Now he gets praised by Donald Trump, could it get any worse?
Ross Hudson, Mount Martha

Can anyone imagine the cringe factor if we ever have Pauline Hanson or Barnaby Joyce representing us on the world stage?
John Walsh, Watsonia

Furthermore
So if I’m offered a gold ingot at a ridiculously low price by a shady looking character, should I buy?
Myra Fisher, Brighton East

Your correspondent (Letters, 18/11) notes that sandpapergate, has become ″⁣sandpapergategate″⁣. A case of sandpapergatisation?
Deborah Morrison, Malvern East

And so it is that the body of this beautiful horse So You Are is dumped, like so much rubbish, after its short life of usefulness has ended.
Lawrence Pope, Carlton North

The sickening story of So You Are says everything you need to know about the racing industry.
Linda Robertson, Ivanhoe

Does anyone remember when the rich last got poorer and the poor got richer?
Dale Crisp, Brighton

Get ready for Jess Wilson’s announcement that the state coffers are skint, justifying the reneging of election promises and four years of inaction.
Colleen Heatley, Drouin West

Your correspondent’s Sir Walter Scott quote (Letters, 17/11) reminds me of the addition my parents used to make to it: ″⁣But when we’ve practised for while, how vastly we improve our style″⁣!
Judy Small, Alphington

Finally
There are now three certainties in life: death, taxes and that the AFL will introduce or change a rule annually.
Gerry Lonergan, Reservoir

From our partners

Source: The Age

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇦🇺 AU
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira