A teachers union in the city of Fukuoka has obtained time sheets showing that almost every public junior high school teacher there had taken “zero minutes of break time” despite Japan’s labor law requiring employers to provide breaks.
The records, obtained from the municipal board of education through a freedom-of-information request, covered time sheets of about 4,000 teachers and staff members at all 72 municipal junior high schools from April through June. The more than 48,000 pages of document blacked out teachers’ names but listed their schools, start and end times, and break periods.
After examining the records, the union found that only eight entries showed anything other than zero in the column labeled “total break time.”
The labor standards law stipulates that employers must provide at least 45 minutes of break time when employees work more than six hours and up to eight hours a day, and at least one hour of break when they work more than eight hours.
Yuya Kitahata, 32, the union’s representative, said, “doesn’t it violate the law?” referring to the work records showing no break time.
The city’s education board explains that the records do not reflect the actual break time teachers have taken.
According to the city, schools use a timekeeping application on dedicated terminals in staff rooms to record the time teachers spend at school. Teachers clock in and out at the beginning and end of their workdays, but are not required to clock in or out when taking breaks.
The “break time” column in the time sheets is intended for exceptional cases in which teachers clock breaks during overtime work, said Yu Matsuse, 48, head of the education board’s labor relations division. “Under our system, we consider breaks to have been taken during regular working hours,” he said.
“We are also urging school administrators to ensure that teachers take breaks appropriately to maintain their health,” Matsuse added.
Yuya Kitahata, head of a teachers union and a teacher at a municipal junior high school in Fukuoka, says teachers cannot really take breaks, even during lunch time. | Nishinippon Shimbun
On paper, teachers are considered to have taken their legally granted breaks. But teachers on the ground say they have no time to rest.
“Lunch break runs straight into lunch duties then to classes, so there is practically no time to rest,” said the union’s Kitahata, himself a teacher at a municipal junior high school. “Even in the staff room, we can’t completely step away from work as, in reality, we are constantly on standby.”
At his school, teachers are supposed to take a 30-minute break during lunch and another 15 minutes after classes end for the day.
In practice, however, teachers often remain in their classrooms for several minutes at the beginning of lunch break to check whether students on lunch duty have finished carrying out the dishes. At the end of the break, teachers must return to classrooms early or prepare for their next lessons.
Even in the staff room, teachers must answer phone calls and remain available for students who may come looking for them at any time, Kitahata said.
A teacher in his 30s at another junior high school described a similar situation. “There is no time at school when we are not dealing with students or their parents,” the teacher said. During lunch break, students bring assignments to the staff room. As soon as classes end, teachers begin supervising students as they leave school or overseeing extracurricular activities. “In reality, there isn’t a break.”
The situation is not limited to Fukuoka. According to a Japan Teachers’ Union survey of teachers and staff at elementary, junior high and high schools nationwide released last year, 95.3% of about 17,700 respondents said they had actually taken less than 45 minutes of break time. Among them, 44.3% said they had taken no break at all.
The issue was also raised at a meeting of the Upper House committee on education in May. As the situation could harm teachers’ physical and mental health and potentially undermine the quality of education, then-education minister Yohei Matsumoto proposed measures including rotating teachers’ lunch-supervision duties and having school support staff watch over students during breaks.
“We will examine a wide range of options, taking into account the teacher shortage and progress in work-style reforms,” Matsumoto said at the time.
The principal at Kitahata’s school said he did not want to discourage teachers from willingly interacting with students during lunch time. “That is why we must not assign them work during their breaks,” he said.
If teachers are required to work during a break, the school encourages them to take the time off later, such as during a free period when they have no classes, the principal said. Still, some teachers continue to spend time with students during their breaks out of a sense of commitment, according to the principal.
“We are trying to come up with various ways of taking breaks while listening to teachers’ voices at staff meetings,” the principal said.
At Susenji Junior High School, a break room for teachers has been set up. | Nishinippon Shimbun
Some schools are also working to create spaces where teachers can relax.
At Susenji Junior High School, the first new municipal junior high school to have opened in the city of Fukuoka in 18 years, a break room has been set up in a corner of the teachers’ changing room. The six-tatami-mat room is equipped with air conditioning and a table and can be used for naps.
Having a dedicated break room allows teachers to spend time away from students. But for students, it is natural to expect their teachers to be available during the school day, and some even search the school when they cannot find them. As a result, some teachers choose not to use the room.
“There are challenges because this is an educational setting with children present, but the times are gone when being a good teacher meant never taking a break,” said principal Kosuke Eto.
“As school administrators, we are speaking to teachers and ensuring that we do not create an atmosphere in which taking a break is difficult,” he said.
This section features topics and issues from the Kyushu region covered by the Nishinippon Shimbun, the largest daily newspaper in Kyushu. The original article was published Oct. 22.
Source: The Japan Times
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇯🇵 JP
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira