Close your eyes and cover your ears. Much of the world around you disappears from view and hearing, but your sense of being present – of being conscious – remains. What creates that basic feeling of being “you”?
A new hypothesis from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem (HUJI) proposes that our basic sense of being conscious – the “Me Inside” – originates in the brain stem, the stalk-like structure at the base of the brain that connects the cerebrum and cerebellum to the spinal cord. This evolutionarily ancient part of the brain acts as a vital control center for life-sustaining autonomic functions and serves as the main pathway for motor and sensory signals.
Drawing on evidence from pain research, brain injuries, and anesthesia, the researchers suggest that the cerebral cortex processes much of the information we experience, while brainstem circuits make that information consciously felt.
Veteran pain expert Prof. Marshall Devor and neuroscientist Dr. Mark Baron of HUJI and Harvard Medical School’s Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center have just published their findings in the prestigious journal The Neuroscientist under the title “Brainstem Theory of Consciousness.”
Until now, neuroscientists have identified the source of conscious experience primarily in the cerebral cortex – the brain’s folded outer layer that is responsible for complex functions including language, recognition, and planning. This outermost layer of gray matter tissue of the brain’s cerebrum in humans and mammals is split into left and right hemispheres, measures about two to four millimeters thick, and contains about 15 billion neurons. Its wrinkled, folded texture consists of raised ridges that dramatically increase surface area so more neurons can fit inside the skull.
Swimming against the tide, the HUJI experts suggest that the basic capacity to feel and experience originates in older, “primitive” brain stem circuitry.
The paper brings together existing experimental findings and clinical observations to develop this theory without claiming to establish a proven mechanism for consciousness. They base their case around the widespread experience of pain.
Detecting a harmful stimulus and feeling pain are disconnected entities. “The nervous system can trigger an automatic ‘reflexive’ withdrawal from danger, but pain also involves a subjective experience: It hurts,” Devor told The Jerusalem Post in a long interview. He and Baron argue that evidence from brain stimulation, epileptic seizures, neurological injuries, and other research suggests that this feeling does not depend on the cortex in the same way that complex visual or auditory experiences do.
For example, they note that even extensive cortical damage usually leaves pain experience intact, or even increased, while such damage can severely degrade vision and hearing. Loss of consciousness is rare. In contrast, damage to particular brain stem regions consistently causes a person to go into a coma. They assert that the brain stem may do more than just keep the cortex awake – it may generate the basic capacity for conscious experience of pain and, by extension, also the other senses of smell, touch, taste, hearing, and seeing.
Having spent much of his scientific career studying pain, Devor said this field gradually led him to study the mystery of consciousness. His theory distinguishes between the information the brain processes robotically, like a self-driving car, and the feeling of consciously experiencing that information. Recognizing a face, fearing that an animal might attack you, or understanding a sentence demands complicated processing, he said.
The researchers suggest that the cortex performs most of this work and evaluates what benefit or danger might follow. “Our brain is constantly flooded with sights, sounds, smells, and physical sensations. Because you can’t pay attention to everything at once, the brain stem filters out background ‘noise’ and only sends the most important signals up to your conscious mind. It decides which sensory signals get moved to the front of your mind for you to actively focus on, and which ones get ignored in the background.”
This distinction could help explain why damage to particular cortical regions can eliminate specific abilities, such as seeing or recognizing objects, without necessarily eliminating the person’s basic awareness.
“Under our model, the cortex and brain stem work together – the cortex provides detailed information about the world, and brain stem mechanisms shine the light of subjective experience on those aspects that deserve conscious attention,” continued Devor, who made aliyah from Toronto, studied psychology at Princeton University, earned a Ph.D. at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, completed a post-doctorate at University College London, and then joined HUJI’s Institute of Life Sciences.
The authors draw particular attention to a region of the brain stem called the mesopontine tegmentum, where previous research has identified circuits involved in coma following brain injury and loss of consciousness during surgical anesthesia. They argue that investigating this area and its connections could help researchers test the brain stem theory and explore how neural activity becomes subjective experience.
However, they said that while the precise mechanism remains unresolved, it is surely biological. Their paper proposes a framework for further investigation rather than a completed explanation of how the brain generates consciousness.
'Development of more powerful information processing'
Ultimately, Devor and Baron call for greater attention to the brain stem in the search for how the brain creates our most basic experience: being here, feeling something, and knowing the world from the inside. “The most basic feeling of being conscious has ancient roots, while the richness of what we humans experience reflects the later development of more powerful information processing,” Devor said.
Describing the “Me Inside” as one’s raw awareness – such as the redness of a surface or the sting of pain – Devor called the brain stem the true source of the self. “A frog can flick its tongue out to where a bug is,” he explained. But extracting complex fitness information from visual contrasts falling on the retina – like distinguishing a distant cloud from a charging rhinoceros – demands massive computational power.
“This did not become available until the development of the mammalian neocortex, eons after sensory processing was already well established in the brain stem,” he added.
Devor recalled attending a lecture long ago claiming that babies did not need anesthesia during an operation because they “were not yet conscious.” He disagreed: “A fertilized egg doesn’t feel pain, but nobody knows if a fetus feels pain. I think it is when the brain stem develops.”
The researchers distinguish between nociception – the nervous system detecting potentially harmful stimuli – and actually experiencing pain. Asked specifically where neural signals transform into the subjective feeling of pain, Devor pointed to the brain’s anatomy: “It’s in the brain stem, which is about the size of your thumb, long, and skinny. If an electroencephalogram is flat, doctors will say the person is ‘brain dead,’ but the brain stem can still be active. He can’t talk, but he could still be feeling pain.”
Since Devor suggests that the capacity to experience pain arose very early in evolution, before the development of the mammalian cerebral cortex, he was asked what organisms first possessed this rudimentary form of consciousness. “I think the reptiles, but maybe even fish can have consciousness of pain and awareness. They have primitive vision.” But do fish and reptiles have subjective experiences – that there is actually something it feels like to be a fish or a reptile? “We don’t know,” he replied.
Asked what experiments he would most like to see conducted to test his hypothesis, Devor said there are “ways of selectively manipulating brain stem activity while monitoring subjective experience. Functional MRI, clinical MRI, and CT look at the cortex, but the brain stem is so small and enclosed by bone that it makes imaging very difficult. However, these techniques are getting stronger, so there should be more research. I do lab experiments on rats and mice.”
If the team’s theories are proven correct, they could change how physicians assess consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries, coma, or disorders of consciousness. “If we knew how it can be done, it could help people who are in a coma,” Devor said. “Every hospital has anesthesiologists, but they don’t conduct research on how it works. Their job is to put people to sleep and bring them back. Maybe this paper will get more young doctors involved in this.”
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · JUDY SIEGEL-ITZKOVICH
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira