"Jewish Americans do not have to accept violence as the price of living openly as Jews," said Alan H. Scheiner, Senior Litigation Counsel at the National Jewish Advocacy Center.
Follow us on GoogleThe National Jewish Advocacy Center (NJAC), supported by StandWithUs, has filed a federal civil rights lawsuit in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York on behalf of Moshe Katz over what the organizations describe as an antisemitic assault outside an Israeli restaurant in Manhattan in 2024.
The complaint details an incident that took place shortly after midnight in January 2024, when Katz and a group of Jewish friends, one of whom wore a necklace displaying the Hebrew word "Chai" ("life"), were standing on a public sidewalk outside an Israeli restaurant in Manhattan, which displayed an Israeli flag.
According to the filing, defendant Sami Bibovic and an unidentified companion approached the group, inquired whether the business was Israeli, and launched into derogatory and hostile accusations against Jews, Israelis, and the State of Israel once confirmed. The complaint states that as a heated verbal argument escalated between Bibovic and one of Katz's friends, Katz stepped in to de-escalate the situation, putting his arm around his friend and quietly asking him to leave the area.
According to the complaint, when Bibovic directed hostile remarks at him, Katz responded with the Hebrew phrase "Am Yisrael Chai" ("the People of Israel live"). Immediately following the phrase, Bibovic allegedly punched Katz in the face with a closed fist without provocation, knocking him unconscious.
The filing states that Katz suffered fractures of both nasal bones and frontal processes, lacerations, and a severe concussion resulting in post-concussion syndrome, speech pathologies, cervical radiculopathy, and post-traumatic stress disorder, requiring at least 15 prescribed medications and ongoing medical and rehabilitative treatment nearly three years later.
The complaint also notes that Bibovic was previously prosecuted in criminal court for the conduct, with that prosecution concluding within a year prior to the civil filing.
NJAC lawsuit hopes to bring justice for victims of antisemitic attacks
The lawsuit brings claims under federal, New York State, and New York City civil rights laws that protect individuals against discrimination, harassment, and bias-motivated violence, alongside state claims for assault and battery. Katz is demanding a jury trial and seeking more than $75,000 in compensatory damages for his injuries and ongoing medical care, as well as punitive damages, civil penalties, and attorneys’ fees.
"Jewish Americans do not have to accept violence as the price of living openly as Jews," said Alan H. Scheiner, Senior Litigation Counsel at NJAC. "No one should fear standing on a public sidewalk, wearing a Jewish necklace, saying a Hebrew phrase, or defending fellow Jews and the Jewish state. Mr. Katz deserves justice and we hope to make it clear that assaulting Jews carries legal consequences."
"Jews who are targeted by antisemitic violence do not always receive the justice they deserve from the criminal courts," stated Yael Lerman, Executive Director of the Saidoff Law Division of StandWithUs. "When that happens, StandWithUs helps victims use the civil courts to fight back and hold their attackers accountable. We are proud to do so here in support of Moshe Katz and the National Jewish Advocacy Center."
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · ALEX CARSON
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira