For three years, Israel has fought on more than seven fronts against enemies who openly seek its destruction.
Hundreds of soldiers and civilians have been killed, thousands more wounded, and millions of ordinary lives have been interrupted by rocket fire, reserve call-ups, and the constant calculation of risk.
Anyone who has lived through this period finds themselves asking, late at night, what exactly the price has been for. The question is not abstract. It is the one that sits with families when a child is drafted or when the sirens sound again.
What is the value of the State of Israel set against everything that has been paid, and continues to be paid, to create and defend it?
Two thousand years of exile ended, in practical terms, with the rise of political Zionism. Theodor Herzl and his followers argued that the Jewish people required sovereignty in their ancestral land if they were to survive as a free nation.
The Holocaust demonstrated the cost of powerlessness with a clarity that no theory could match.
In November 1947, the United Nations voted for partition. On May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion declared independence. Within hours, five Arab armies invaded. The new state began its existence under fire, with a Jewish population of roughly 650,000. Today, that population stands at approximately 7.2 million.
The day is remembered as independence, yet it was independence purchased under immediate military assault and sustained by successive wars.
A sovereign Jewish state has provided physical refuge and the practical possibility of ingathering.
Jews from Yemen, Iraq, Morocco, Ethiopia, and the former Soviet Union arrived in large numbers because a state existed that would receive them and, however imperfectly, absorb them. Without that state, those communities would have remained scattered minorities subject to the whims of host governments.
Hebrew has been revived as a living national language spoken by millions in daily life, science, and literature. Israel produces Nobel laureates and high-technology companies at rates far out of proportion to its size, the result of concentrated human capital operating under conditions of sovereignty.
It remains the only full democracy in the Middle East, with regular elections, an independent judiciary, Arab members of the Knesset, and legal protections for women and sexual minorities that do not exist in neighboring societies.
Israeli innovations in drip irrigation, missile defense, and emergency medicine have been adopted worldwide, and Israeli teams deploy after natural disasters from Haiti to Turkey.
None of these outcomes would have occurred in the absence of a Jewish state capable of concentrating talent, defending its borders, and setting its own priorities.
The cost of a sovereign Jewish state
The costs are measured in concrete numbers. More than 25,000 Israeli soldiers and civilians have been killed in wars and terrorist attacks since 1948. Reserve duty continues to pull men and women from jobs and families for weeks or months at a time.
Defense spending consumes roughly 5-6% of GDP, a burden that shapes taxes, public services, and private investment. International isolation appears in the form of boycott campaigns, biased resolutions, and sharp rises in campus antisemitism whenever Israel is forced to fight.
These are not theoretical drawbacks. They are the daily experience of people who serve, pay, and explain.
If the State of Israel did not exist, the Jewish people would face greater danger rather than less. The historical record of the 20th century shows what happens when Jews lack a place of last refuge and the capacity for self-defense.
The world would lose a functioning democracy in a region dominated by authoritarian regimes, a center of medical and agricultural innovation, and a living laboratory for the revival of a language and culture that had been nearly extinguished.
The never-ending human cost of defending the state is real. The alternative cost, measured in vulnerability and disappearance, has already been demonstrated.
We fight for the State of Israel because it has made possible the physical security and cultural continuity of a people that spent most of its history as a minority without power.
We fight because the alternative has been tried and has produced catastrophe. Even though the price includes repeated wars, reserve duty that disrupts ordinary life, and a permanent diplomatic struggle, the balance remains clear for those who have calculated the alternatives.
Sovereignty does not eliminate conflict. It changes the terms on which the Jewish people can face conflict.
If I had to explain this to a future child or to a skeptical friend who sees only the headlines of loss, I would say that the state exists so that Jewish life is not dependent on the goodwill of others.
I would point to the simple fact that Jews can now decide, through elections and military service, how to protect themselves and how to build.
The losses are not denied. They are the price that has been paid by every generation since 1948 for the right to make those decisions.
A person who has watched a neighbor leave for reserve duty or who has attended a funeral understands that the willingness to continue paying is itself the measure of the thing being defended.
The value of Israel is measured by what it has already given and by what people are still prepared to give to keep it. The state is not an abstraction; it is the difference between a people that can defend its own children and a people that must ask others to do so.
The calculation is never finished; each generation makes it again under the conditions of its own time. The answer, so far, has been that the state is more than worth the cost.
The writer is a Zionist educator at institutions around the world and is the author of the book Zionism Today.
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · URI PILICHOWSKI
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira