ByJONATHAN LIEBERMANNOVEMBER 21, 2026 22:02

This week, I found myself in the historic English city of Lincoln for work. Despite spending most of my life in Britain, I had never visited it. An embarrassing admission, because Lincoln is a jewel of English history.

The Romans called it Lindum Colonia. William the Conqueror built its castle in 1068. Its magnificent cathedral dominates the skyline, and a surviving copy of the Magna Carta (Great Charter) recalls the city’s place in English history. Cobbled medieval streets complete the picture.

But it was not the cathedral, the castle, or the Magna Carta that most captured my attention. It was Lincoln’s extraordinary, and largely forgotten, Jewish history.

Jews arrived in England after the Norman Conquest, and the first written evidence of a Jewish community in Lincoln dates from 1159.

Demonstrators from the ''Palestine Coalition'' gather in support for Palestinians, after a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas in Gaza went into effect, in London, Britain, October 11, 2025. (credit: REUTERS/JAIMI JOY)

By the late 12th century, this was one of England’s most important Jewish centers. They lived around The Strait and Steep Hill, trading, studying, and raising families in a community whose traces remain visible.

One of those traces is the Jew’s House, a remarkable stone residence dating from around 1170. Nearby is Jews’ Court, traditionally associated with the medieval synagogue and now, astonishingly, used again by Lincoln’s modern Jewish congregation. These are buildings in streets where Jews lived eight centuries ago.

And then there was Aaron of Lincoln.

Aaron, who died in 1186, was among the most powerful financiers in medieval England. He lent to aristocrats, bishops, monasteries, and the Crown, financing buildings that would outlast his community.

When he died, the royal treasury created a special department, the Exchequer of Aaron, to administer his vast estate and collect debts owed to him.

A Jew could become indispensable to a kingdom’s economy. Yet his wealth was never quite his own. The king, who offered him protection, could also appropriate the fruits of his lifetime’s work whenever he wished.

One of the most surprising figures in this story is St. Hugh of Avalon, Bishop of Lincoln. When anti-Jewish violence swept England in 1190, and the Jews of York were massacred, Lincoln’s Jews found refuge in the castle.

Bishop Hugh stood up for them. When he died in 1200, Jewish neighbors reportedly mourned him.

Here, surely, was an encouraging example of coexistence: an influential Christian leader willing to defend Jews because they were his neighbors, not because defending them was popular.

But another Hugh was to enter Lincoln’s history, with terrible consequences.

In 1255, a young Christian boy, later known as Little Hugh of Lincoln, was found dead. His death became the basis of an accusation that Jews had murdered him as part of a religious ritual.

It was a blood libel, a grotesque fabrication resting upon no credible evidence, yet eagerly embraced by those ready to believe the worst about Jews.

King Henry III intervened. Scores of Jews were arrested. Eighteen were executed in London. A child was made a supposed martyr, and a community punished for a crime it had not committed.

The slander survived in English religious culture and literature for centuries.

And here it is difficult not to hear an uncomfortable echo across the centuries.

No permanent guarantee

Today, another accusation of extraordinary evil is directed against the Jewish people, this time through their nation-state: that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.

All decent and reasonable people must reject that accusation.

The suffering of Palestinian civilians is real and tragic, and legitimate criticism of Israel’s conduct is both necessary and entirely permissible.

But genocide is a specific and exceptionally grave legal accusation, not simply another word for the horrors of war.

The medieval blood libel and the contemporary accusation are not identical.

What troubles me is the ease with which allegations of exceptional Jewish wickedness can become accepted narratives, and how quickly condemnation of Israel can spill over into collective hostility towards Jews everywhere.

Back in Lincoln, the historical progression is breathtaking. In 1190, a bishop helped save the Jews from a mob. In 1255, Jews were executed on the authority of the Crown. In 1290, King Edward I expelled every Jew from England.

Barely a century separated prosperity and protection from persecution and expulsion.

Those Jews had homes, businesses, synagogues, scholars, and generations of memories. Then, by royal decree, they were told they no longer belonged.

And where could they go? Wherever another ruler might permit them to settle. Somewhere they could begin again, pay taxes again, become useful again, and hope the next welcome lasted longer than the previous.

That is the recurring tragedy of much of Jewish Diaspora history. Hospitality could be genuine, and Jewish communities could flourish for centuries. But their security ultimately depended on the goodwill of others, and goodwill could change with frightening speed.

I found myself thinking about this as we watch the climate facing Jews change across the world today.

In Britain, the Community Security Trust recorded 1,926 antisemitic incidents in the first half of 2026. Across Europe, Jewish communities face increasing anxiety.

And perhaps most troubling is the changing mood in the United States, Israel’s indispensable ally. A 2026 Pew survey found that six in 10 Americans held an unfavorable view of Israel.

History does not repeat itself neatly. Modern democracies are not the kingdoms of Henry III and Edward I. Jews have rights, allies, and institutions.

Yet Lincoln reminds us that acceptance is not a permanent guarantee. A community can be integrated, prosperous, and valued, and still discover that the terms of its belonging have changed.

There is, however, one decisive difference between the Jews of Lincoln in 1290 and the Jewish people today.

We have Israel.

Not merely a refuge if matters deteriorate, but a sovereign Jewish homeland, where our future is not granted at another nation’s discretion. A country with grave challenges, certainly, but one in which Jews are not guests awaiting the next decree of expulsion.

That does not mean every Diaspora Jew must leave, or that Jewish life outside Israel lacks a future (although it may, in many places). It means our collective destiny is no longer wholly dependent upon the tolerance of others.

Lincoln’s medieval houses are still standing. The Jewish community that built its life around them was driven away. But today, across the sea, stands a Jewish state that those medieval families could scarcely have imagined.

Their story is a warning. Our answer is a homeland.

The writer is a rabbi and physician. He writes and teaches on Jewish ethics, leadership, and resilience. His work appears on rabbidrjonathanlieberman.substack.com and youtube.com. @rabbidrjonathanlieberman

Follow us on Google

Source: The Jerusalem Post · JONATHAN LIEBERMAN

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇱 IL
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira