At 31, Quinn Shephard is behind some of the most projects about teen girls on television. In 2024, she created Hulu’s subversive true crime series “Under the Bridge,” and on Nov. 11, Netflix released her newest effort: “The Body,” a queer psychological drama set at a Catholic high school in 2004 that debuted at No. 3 on the streamer’s weekly viewership rankings. But 20 years ago, her foray into the teen genre began with an unauthorized adaptation of a popular book series that got trapped in development hell.
“I was trying to make a movie by the time I was 10,” recalls Shephard. “My parents found offer letters that I was writing to, like, my dad’s best friend: ‘Will you play Mr. Scary in my “Junie B. Jones” adaptation?’” But the project “couldn’t get off the ground because we lost the key location,” she says, laughing. (She never remotely considered the possibility that her elementary school principal had been joking when he offered her some classrooms. “I was like, ‘OK, here’s the shooting schedule,’ and he was like, ‘No, I didn’t mean that.’ I was mad,” she says. “‘Why would you tell me I could?’ I was so fucking annoying. But I don’t think I knew how to be any other way, unfortunately.”)
Shephard began her career, and life, as an actress. She barely remembers how it all began beyond the encouragement she received from her mother, Laurie, a former actress, and says that in her earliest memories, she’s in Prague surrounded by her family while shooting the Andie MacDowell-led drama film “Harrison’s Flowers” at just 4 years old. “I grew up in Central Jersey and went to public school, so being on set was my main access to things that felt bigger than that world,” she says. Her mother had worked in soap operas and commercials until she retired to focus on raising — and managing — Quinn. “My parents raised me to have dreams, and to believe that those dreams were possible,” Shephard says. “So when I was 15 and wrote a movie, my mom was like, ‘Let’s get into notes. How are we going to make this?’ I had a delusional confidence from growing up on set and seeing how it worked. It didn’t feel any more complicated than any other job. In fact, it felt sensible.”
When asked to sum up her media diet as a kid, Shephard rattles off a list of films that includes “The Crucible,” “Girl, Interrupted,” “Jennifer’s Body,” “Donnie Darko” — you get the picture. “Stuff that’s vibey and moody with a dark sense of humor,” she says. “The Sparkle Motion sequence in ‘Donnie Darko’ was one of the moments where I was like, ‘I want to do whatever this is.’”
So she did. Through a public arts program that was “mostly just me and a bunch of boys,” Shephard began producing her own work around age 12. She and her classmates stunned their parents into silence with dark short films in which she, for example, played one of a psych ward patient’s multiple personalities. She was auditioning for professional projects at the same time, but needless to say, she wasn’t a Disney-style child actress. The audition circuit for East coast youths produced an alternative kind of star: Shephard cites Rachel Brosnahan, Taissa Farmiga and even Timothée Chalamet as some of the names running in the same circles.
Armed with the “delusional confidence” those experiences gave her, a teenage Shephard began working on the script that would eventually become “Blame,” her debut feature film as a writer-director. “Not a single fact about how that movie got made makes any sense,” Shephard says. She ended up shooting the film at age 20 and premiering it two years later — but not before a flaky investor almost blew up the whole project in her face. “It’s something I could literally never do now. I don’t have the blind faith and stamina I had to have at that age to make that movie, and the level of ego I must have had to be like, ‘I can pull off a whole feature!’ I cannot process it, but it happened, and thank God.”
The investor, an indie director Shephard had been working with on another project, took advantage of her moxie and naiveté to keep stringing her along — though for what reason, she still doesn’t understand. “He was always like, ‘Money’s coming. Money’s coming,’” she recalls. “I remember the last text I sent him. I was like, ‘Hey, my parents are about to putting things on credit cards. I don’t want to put us into debt. I need to know if this is real.’ And he was like, ‘Put it on the credit cards. Tell your parents it’s all good. I got you. The money’s coming.’ And he ghosted.”
Shephard was already deep into the preparation process, and her high profile co-star, Chris Messina, was days away from arriving. So she and her parents decided to empty her college fund and the money she’d earned as a child actor, which had been untouched for years outside of careful investments. That got them through production, and post-production unfolded slowly: “I would do an acting job, then I would use that to pay for a sound mix. I would do another acting job, then I’d use that to get on a bus to Montreal and work with a friend of a friend’s colorist who gave me a deal.” And so on and so forth until “Blame” debuted at the Tribeca Film Festival, where it was warmly reviewed. Another one of Shephard’s co-stars, her then-girlfriend Nadia Alexander, was named best actress in a U.S. narrative feature.
Making “Blame” led to a major transition in Shephard’s career: She quit acting. “I was so grateful for the experiences that I had as a kid, and the access that it gave me to film, but I realized that I hadn’t consciously chosen to be an actor,” she says. “I was like, ‘If I change my mind, I could always slide back in.’ But I just haven’t. It feels so foreign to me now. It’s such a distant part of myself that it’s kind of funny to me now that I used to do it.”
She made her second film in 2022, a dramedy called “Not Okay” that taught her how difficult filmmaking is even when you step outside of the indie world. “It was actually crazy, because I was shooting a movie with Searchlight, but the process was not wildly different. You never feel like you have enough money. You never feel like you have enough time. Everything’s always hectic. It’s just that with more money, you can get cranes if you want cranes.”
“The Body” is Shephard’s best and most ambitious project to date, and it came from a combination of the processes behind “Blame” and Not Okay.” Like the latter, she had studio backing (this time from Netflix), but more importantly, like the former, she trusted in the merits of a script she’d written when she was younger.
The series follows the spread of mass hysteria through a small town after a girl named Grace (Sofia Wylie) falls into a coma after attending a Halloween party where her Catholic school dance teammates pressured her to take Ecstasy. As the girls hide what they did, they pretend they’re being visited by Grace in intense religious visions. But soon enough, half the town believes that Grace is God, or at least one of his agents. They find genuine solace in worshipping her.
Shephard wrote a version of the show 10 years ago without a clear thesis in mind, though she has a better idea of why the idea came to her in retrospect. “I always related to religious horror in a way that I didn’t fully understand, these themes of shame and passion and ecstasy,” she says. And as I got older and started working on this show, I was like, ‘Oh, it’s the perfect metaphor for a queer girl’s coming-of age. Worshipful experiences that give meaning to your life, and then deep repression. Religious horror has always explored that in a way that felt really accessible to me. It made sense.”
Though Shephard was never baptized into Christianity, she did occasionally going to church with her paternal grandmother — who was an Evangelical deliverance minister — as a young child. “I was so into it. I loved it. I was like, ‘I’m dancing. I’m singing. I’m talking to Jesus. I’m loving it,” she says. “But, as I’m prone to do, I took an incident a little too seriously and got very obsessed and upset.” She somehow wound up seeing a play meant for adults about “people being afraid they’re going to hell or killing themselves over adultery or something.” Shephard’s mother, who had been wracked with Catholic guilt earlier in her life and didn’t want the same for her daughter, decided that was enough was enough. But for a time, the abrupt end to her foray into Christianity only intensified Shephard’s interest: She recalls reading her children’s Bible in secret to figure out what was so forbidden about it.
As Shephard grew up, her separation from Christianity was unsurprisingly more political (and personal) in nature. “I associated it with oppression of the queer community and rejection of people for being different,” she says. But she didn’t know how to reckon with the pull she still felt toward some sort of faith. “Like, I’ll cry if I go to a church. Especially an ecstatic, charismatic church where people are singing and dancing. It’s so moving.”
She continues, “I’ve never been an atheist. I’ve always been curious. I’ve always believed in ghosts — I saw some when I was a kid.” But it wasn’t until working with the other writers on “The Body” that Shephard fully unpacked these experiences. “Writing this show has weirdly healed my relationship with faith to the point where I can sit with the more religious side of my family and have a really meaningful conversation about it — as long as we don’t talk about politics,” she says. “Because now I’ve had such a journey: What is my spirituality? What do I believe in? And I’ve engaged so much with journalism on unexplainable things. I’m so spiritually curious, and spent so much time talking to people about their relationship with faith for this show that I had a breakthrough, like, ‘I think I get it.’ Hopefully, it comes through that all of us who work on the show are very faith-positive, but system-critical.”
There’s a throughline that runs through Shephard’s work and the films gravitated to in her youth, even beyond the obvious aesthetic elements: meditation on what it means to deeply want something, be it power, love, sex or answers. The honest beauty and painful consequences that come with desire are as alive in John Proctor and Abigail Williams in “The Crucible” as they are in the schoolgirls of “The Body.”
As Shephard puts it, “People who go to church searching for a religious experience, and me and my friends in Silver Lake doing a guided mushroom trip and talking about connecting with ancestral energy or whatever — it’s all the same human desire.”
Source: Variety · Selome Hailu
At a glance
- Topic
- Culture
- Country
- 🇺🇸 US
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira