Logo text

Lewis Kelly wasn’t chasing an extra $1 million when he put his Survivor 51 fate on a coin flip. Convinced he was heading home anyway, he figured he might as well go out with a bang. The gamble didn’t pay off, but it was a fitting finish for a player whose adventure began with a last-minute casting call at Coachella and a flight to Fiji with little time to prepare. In an exclusive exit interview with The Hollywood Reporter below, Kelly explains why he took the risk, how his early stint on Exile Island left him struggling to break into established alliances, and which castaway deserves credit for running the game.

***

We have to start with the coin flip. At the start of Tribal Council, you said, “I’ll be flipping a coin before you can even ask me.” But you hesitated. What changed for you when you were so enthusiastic about flipping?

I went in there really anticipating that was my last tribal. I was like, “I’ll just take my time. Let me make and savor the most out of this tribal.” It was a real long tribal. I think it was over it was at least over two hours, had to be, so there’s no rush. I was just trying to run through all the factors, all the different decisions. Ultimately, I have to do it. I think it was almost like my destiny because my name wasn’t in anyone’s mouth until that day and then Jeff hands me a coin and I’m like, “Oh, okay. Maybe I was supposed to do this.”

How close did you come to not flipping it? Because you could tell Devin was interested.

I was just going back and forth on it a million times. I had a bunch of tricks up my sleeves. I could play around with this, I could see if I could maneuver my way out or I could just try to flip it. I had ideas for things I could have done and you know, are we going to go to rocks? No one was going to go to rocks for me. Ultimately, I have to flip the coin.

When you decided to flip, how much of it was chasing the extra million dollars and how much of it was feeling like, well, I have nothing left to lose.

I couldn’t give a wally about that extra $1 million. I couldn’t even believe I made it this far in the game to begin with. Honestly, I’m thankful for Devin for making it crystal clear I was going home. It gave me clarity. I’m either going to go out with a bang or I’m going to get a vote without. What do I want?

We saw you scrambling before tribal and getting some mixed responses. Who did you feel you could really count on? Did you have a true number one?

I didn’t really have a true number one to be honest. I think that’s a product of Exile Island. I came in on day four. People already have their alliances. I was close with Thien An but I wasn’t her number one. Her and Maggie were like this (crosses fingers). And then Carter and Christian were like this and then Sharonda and Eric and Devin and Jelly. I felt like me and Mike were kind of the outliers so I pitched to Mike, “Listen, We don’t fit in here as well as everyone else. Why don’t we start knocking off one of each of the pairs?” I really thought that was the best path forward for me because I knew where I stood. I knew people would keep me in for a number, but no one would really protect me if push came to shove.

Talk to me a little bit about Sharonda. You seemed to build something with her based on last week’s challenge and supporting her when she was doubting herself. Why couldn’t you build anything off of that and why does everyone tell her all their secrets?

Am I the only one out there looking at Sharonda like, “Hello? Look at this, she’s a threat!” She has mad aura. I did try to work with her actually this last day because I knew things were not looking good for me. I pitched Maggie to Sharonda, Devin, and Jelly. I was like, “Let’s go. Let’s get her out.” And then Thien An comes over to me 10 minutes after I tell them that plan and Thien An’s like, “You’re pitching Maggie?” Oh, I’m cooked.

Sharonda is playing an amazing game. I’m honored I was able to kind of clock what was going on. It’s impossible to get people to think someone’s a threat if people don’t already think someone’s a threat. It’s almost impossible to to really drill that into their heads. Because everyone has their own people they want out and Sharonda’s not on anyone’s radar right now, so good for her.

We saw Jelly and Mike talking about you and they were concerned about you, but they didn’t view you as a strategic threat. What were some of the strategic moves that you were making that people weren’t aware of?

I think that I really left myself open to be a circuit for people to have fun. I made it clear to everyone that, “If you ever want to make a crazy move, use me. Let me be the target. Because I’ll do it. I’m not afraid to go home.” Whereas I feel like a lot of people were afraid to go home. I think being too strategic, in my opinion, is a little bit boring. I’d rather have fun and be crazy.

I had a really good lay of the land. I knew where all of the alliances were. I think when I came in late to the game, I had a pretty good idea of this person’s with this person, this person’s not with this person. Then when we merged, it was very clear cut to me who was working with who. It’s just trying to get that information and get other people to assimilate it is so hard.

What’s something the audience didn’t get to see from your game that you really wish had made the edit?

I can tell you something that I’m glad didn’t make the edit. When I was on Dina Beach and I was pooping my pants, I pooped everywhere. I was sleeping, pooping my pants in my sleep. Sharonda makes a comment, “What’s the smell in this camp?” And everyone’s like, “Why is this new camp so stinky?” So that definitely put a target on me.

Me and Linnea, we slept next to each other and I was literally pooping in my sleep next to her and it wasn’t pretty. They rightfully wanted me out of the game just for that reason alone. I had a lot of issues. I had a slight prolapse because of that. Extreme diarrhea, and I was like, I cannot tell anyone this. I do not want to get pulled out of this game. So I fought through this game with some nasty stuff happening on my bottom end.

The fake idol necklace you revealed right before Jeff snuffed your torch. Do you still have it?

I have it, yeah. It’s my pot idol. My pot idol necklace. I got creative out there, I had a million different tricks up my sleeve, and if I had survived this coin flip, I would have had to put them to use because the target would have been on me without a doubt. That would have been a lot of fun so I’m sad I didn’t get to do all that. I just had so much fun. I really wanted to embrace thinking outside the box.

I really just want to inspire other people, future players who go. I think it’s better to go out early and go out swinging and have fun and do amazing things because a lot of people want to wait until the merge to play and I think that ends up being one of the biggest regrets of a lot of people. That’s what I hope to have inspired in everyone who’s watching and everyone who wants to apply.

Is there anything else about your Survivor experience you want to share that you haven’t told anybody yet?

I got rejected from 51, actually. I got a “no” and then I was in this waiting zone. Maybe I was going to get accepted for 52 so I just decided to remove Survivor from my head. I didn’t watch any episodes, didn’t practice fire, didn’t do nothing. Then I’m at Coachella with my wife and I get a call from casting and they’re like, “We want you for 51. In two days.” And I’m like, what?! What I wore on the island was actually my Coachella outfit. I had no backup clothes or anything like that, and I had that Blood Idol (ring) with me.

I feel like it set a cool tone for the rest of my game. I kind of felt like an alternate in a way, like I’m not even really supposed to be here. I just was literally just plucked last minute, so let’s have feckin’ fun. Let’s go give it a crack. Honestly, that was kind of a real cool part of my Survivor journey. I was embracing the spontaneity before I was even out on the show and went out without any prep or practice. I don’t have any jury outfits. Madness.

***

Survivor airs new episodes Wednesday at 8 p.m. on CBS, streaming on Paramount+.

Source: The Hollywood Reporter · Terry Terrones

At a glance

Topic
Entertainment
Country
🇺🇸 US
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira