Sixty-six years ago, American author and cartoonist Theodor Geisel, better known as Dr. Seuss, published Green Eggs and Ham. His whimsical, rhyming picture books have introduced generations of children to reading. This one, written using only 50 different words, became among his most beloved.
My mother read it to me as a child. At 19, a close friend gave me another copy, back in 1979. Now, that I am 68, watching Israel's political paralysis, I find myself returning to its deceptively simple lesson.
For readers unfamiliar with the story, Sam-I-Am persistently offers an unnamed character a plate of green eggs and ham. The character refuses: in repetitive rhyming, not in a house, not with a mouse, not in a box, not with a fox. He will not taste it anywhere, under any circumstances. Yet he has never tried it. Finally, he does, and discovers he likes it.
Certainty without examination
The joke is not about breakfast. It is about certainty without examination. What begins as a preference hardens into an absolute prohibition. Repetition makes the refusal feel principled; admitting curiosity begins to feel like defeat.
But suppose the stakes changed. Imagine the character aboard the Titanic, watching the ship sink. A lifeboat approaches, carrying people he dislikes. “I will not sit with them,” he declared. Another boat arrives, occupied by a different objectionable group. “Not with them either.” He repeats his convictions as the water rises.
What was amusing over breakfast food becomes insanity in a turbulent sea.
And what if he were a political leader, surrounded by followers who had learned to repeat his refusals as easy-to-remember mantras? Would they reject the lifeboats too, mistaking solidarity for courage while their families drowned?
That is the question Israel must confront. Not whether political differences are real. They are. Not whether past betrayals justify distrust. Sometimes they do. The question is when the preservation of political identity becomes more important than the survival and security of the community it claims to defend.
The mechanism is familiar. Psychologists describe this as an illusory truth effect: repetition can make assertions seem more credible.
Confirmation bias privileges evidence that supports our beliefs; motivated reasoning supplies explanations for contradictions. Our slogans become habits, our habits become identities, and our identities become fortresses.
Social media adds an accelerant. Every emphatic refusal earns applause, shares, and belonging. Algorithms reward engagement; partisan broadcasters like Channel 12 & 14 in Israel reward certainty.
Stanford psychiatrist Anna Lembke, in Dopamine Nation, explores how cycles of reward-seeking can foster denial and self-deception. The political parallel is disturbing: defending a cherished narrative can feel better than testing whether it is true.
Eventually, citizens may become unable, or unwilling, to recognize contradictions in their own camp that they instantly condemn in another. They remain free to vote, but their judgment is increasingly conditioned by the reward of belonging.
When one mantra devours the others
Consider Israel's competing mantras: never Netanyahu; never cooperate with Arab parties; never compromise with haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties over military service.
To voters, these sound like three inviolable principles. Yet coalition negotiations reveal that some “Nevers” are more negotiable than others. Politicians who have vehemently condemned military exemptions are now publicly proposing accommodations with haredi parties.
Politicians who rejected Arab-party support may reconsider parliamentary arrangements. But for parts of the opposition, “anyone but Netanyahu” remains absolute.
There is a hierarchy here. One mantra continues to devour the others.
That should provoke a fundamental question: are the subordinate promises genuine principles, or instruments serving the supreme objective? Perhaps changing circumstances justify compromise. Then politicians must explain the change.
Do not ask voters to applaud a contradiction simply because it helps their team. However, if key leaders within the Arab party leadership suggest changing the Israeli national anthem or the flag, it should hopefully not need further explanation as to why this is a redline.
Netanyahu's supporters face precisely the same test when maintaining power that overrides past commitments, which they previously called sacred. An educated electorate applies the same standards to friends and adversaries. Otherwise, politics becomes an exercise in collective self-deception.
The recent election underscored how divided Israel remains. Likud emerged as the largest individual party; Netanyahu's bloc drew substantial support with 53 seats in the parliament, as compared to the “Change Bloc,” which achieved 48 seats, yet neither secured a parliamentary majority.
Millions of Israelis cannot simply be declared politically nonexistent because another camp refuses to share a lifeboat with them.
There are three forces sustaining the refusal. First, our human hunger for identity and belonging. Second, commercial incentives that reward anger and polarization. Third, the strategic interests of those who want Israel weakened.
Allegations of foreign influence around the election deserve further and continued investigation. More fundamentally, an adversary need not invent our divisions to exploit them. It need only amplify the most intoxicating mantras until cooperation itself appears treasonous.
The danger is especially acute when leaders become captives of the constituencies they helped condition. A politician who privately recognizes the necessity of compromise may fear that supporters will punish him for proposing it. The electorate, meanwhile, interprets his silence as confirmation that no alternative exists.
Thus, the illusion becomes self-sustaining. Leaders reinforce voters' convictions; voters reinforce leaders' refusals. Each side mistakes the other's applause for proof of being right. The result is a democracy in which political options disappear long before anyone seriously evaluates them.
Meanwhile, Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah, Qatar, Turkey, and mounting diplomatic pressures do not wait for Israel's coalition arithmetic. The Titanic is not a prediction of Israel's destruction. It is a warning about the absurdity of treating who sits beside us as more important than whether the boat can carry us to safety.
Growing up in New York, I remember the often-talked-about advertising campaign of the retailer Sy Syms's slogan: “An educated consumer is our best customer.”
Israel needs a hyper-educated political electorate: people who ask what their leaders promised, what they abandoned, what they gained, and who bears the cost. Education here means independent judgment, and survival is not simply a nice-to-have.
None of this means boarding a defective lifeboat. Gadi Eisenkot has served with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu before; his distrust reflects experience. Nor does it mean that Netanyahu is entitled to govern merely because Likud is the largest party. A lifeboat must be seaworthy, with credible rules and a crew capable of working together.
So, test a different design. Could Netanyahu offer a time-limited national emergency arrangement, enforceable safeguards, genuine shared authority, and a credible leadership rotation? Could opposition leaders examine such terms without treating the conversation itself as surrender?
Could either Israeli President Isaac Herzog or US President Donald Trump convene that examination and help make responsible experimentation politically possible?
The objective is not unity at any price. It is refusing to make disunity an article of faith. Israel's leaders must answer to citizens beyond their cheering sections, and citizens must stop rewarding leaders merely for repeating what they already believe.
Sam-I-Am did not ask his companion to surrender his identity forever. He asked him to try. On a sinking ship, that modest act of reconsideration becomes a moral obligation.
The book my mother read and my friend inscribed has survived decades on my shelf. Its lesson should survive our politics too: we need not agree about everything, but we must retain the courage to question ourselves.
We have no obligation to agree. We have every obligation to think for ourselves. This past Tuesday I spent the day down south reliving the October 7 atrocities with guests from abroad.
The future of the Jewish state is too important for the politics of “I will not sit with…”
Israel, what are we waiting for?
It's time now to grow up.
The writer is a global strategist and a strategic adviser at the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs. Follow him on X: @jeffkahn2020
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · JEFFREY KAHN
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira