• Ben SolakNov 17, 2026, 06:45 AM ET

    Close

      Ben Solak joined ESPN in 2024 as a national NFL analyst. He previously covered the NFL at The Ringer, Bleeding Green Nation and The Draft Network.

Are you excited for NFL Week 11? At first, it might look like a sleepy slate. Jaguars at Giants and Raiders at Broncos are two of our marquee games. But there's one contest that, to this enormous football nerd, is the game of the season.

Every Tuesday of the NFL season, I'll turn the page from the previous week to the upcoming one with seven things I think. These aren't full-scale predictions. They aren't concrete takeaways from the past week of NFL action, either; those are fired off Sunday or Monday. Instead, these are the uncertain topics. They are things that might be true, but it'll probably take the next few games to find out. And at the bottom, you'll find a few extra half-thoughts ... just those little inklings I'm unable to shake.

Subscribe: 'ESPN's Leaguewide'

This week, I'll expand on why Joe Burrow looks like an MVP, tell you about another Rams personnel innovation, project eventual QB changes for two NFC South teams and wonder if Aidan Hutchinson is the final defensive injury the Lions can't overcome. But first, here's one matchup you won't want to miss.

Jump to:
Shanahan vs. Flores is matchup of the best
Why Burrow is the MVP
Rams should lean on their RBs
Hutchinson's injury wounds Lions bad
Do Falcons need a new 2027 QB?
Do Saints need a new 2027 QB?
Mendoza's debut is a scratch
Some extra inklings

I think ... Vikings-49ers is the coolest game of the season

The Vikings have had a fraught three weeks. Everyone was excited to see them face the Lions in Week 8 -- the best offense they'd faced in a while. Detroit stuck it to 'em with a sick schematic wrinkle for which the Vikings were not prepared -- multiple tight ends lined up in the backfield as quasi-fullbacks to pave open rushing lanes.

pic.twitter.com/H0N9PKfBkX

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

Then the Vikings played the Bills in Week 9 -- Josh Allen and another grindy running game -- and the Packers in Week 10 with Jordan Love coming off a flamethrower performance against the Patriots. At various points over those three weeks, it has felt like the upcoming test for the Vikings has been the test for the Vikings. Will this be the offense to build a blueprint against Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores' unique defense? Or will Flores prove that his defense is insurmountable even by the league's top attacks?

The NFL rarely exists in such absolutes. All of those particular matchups were exciting and educational in their own ways. But if there's one game I've been waiting for with bated breath in the seasonlong pursuit of an answer to the Flores defense, it's this one: Vikings against 49ers in Week 11.

This is quite literally the best against the best. The 49ers lead the league in points per drive (3.0), success rate and EPA per play on offense. The Vikings lead the league in points per drive (1.24), success rate and EPA per play (if you eliminate the Bucs' rainstorm game against the Falcons, which is cheating, but I don't care) on defense. It does not get better for offensive football than what the 49ers are doing right now. It does not get better for defensive football than what the Vikings are doing right now. Snap the pool stick, toss it down at midfield and let's see who survives.

Not only are these the most effective units on their respective sides of the ball, there's actually some structural similarity between the two. The Flores defense has been exhaustively covered this season, but if you've missed them to this point of the season: The Vikings are blitzing on 72.3% of opposing dropbacks through 10 weeks. I shouldn't need to tell you where that ranks among league defenses, but just in case: It's first.

To blitz that much sounds deranged (and likely is), but Flores has greatly deepened the meaning of blitz packages in the modern NFL. He doesn't blitz to get the quarterback down, but blitzes to force the ball out fast to predictable hot reads. He blitzes to keep the back and tight end in protection and limit the pass-catching options the opponent can deploy. For many defensive coordinators, the blitz is an end to itself -- they want to get to third-and-long so they can blitz. For Flores, the blitz is a means to many different ends depending on the opponent and context.

Let's consider the route distributions. Opposing offenses get all five routes into the concept 31.2% of the time against the Vikings, which is the lowest number in any season as far back as I have data (2017). The aggressive blitz fronts -- with five or six (or seven or eight) bodies on them -- keep backs and tight ends in the formation to protect, which makes the Vikings all the more dangerous when they drop bodies into coverage and only bring four on the rush. Against the Vikings' four-man rush, opposing quarterbacks are averaging an eternity to throw the ball (3.34 seconds, highest in the NFL Next Gen Stats database) and still suffer a 44% pressure rate, which leads the league.

pic.twitter.com/UHBBPDyXiE

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

Flip the coin to the other side, and you'll discover that no offense gets five routes into the concept more often than the San Francisco 49ers. On 72.5% of Brock Purdy's dropbacks this season, the 49ers have five eligible in the concept -- that's tied for the highest rate of any offense over the past two seasons with ... the 2025 49ers.

Why so many players out in the concept? It is indicative of a change that's been underway in San Francisco's offense since the Christian McCaffrey trade in 2022.

When you employ McCaffrey, you don't keep the back in to protect. Are you out of your mind? Have you seen this guy catch passes? The only season of the past five years in which the 49ers have been below 72.5% in five-out rate was 2024, when McCaffrey was hurt for much of the year. When the Cowboys called up a Cover 0 blitz in Week 10 in a got-to-have-it spot late against the 49ers, San Francisco had no issue getting McCaffrey into the route and quickly throwing him the ball against a defensive end (Von Miller) peeling off into coverage. A 74-yard touchdown later, the game was over.

pic.twitter.com/np7G3Y1UNI

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

This peeling defensive end is a big part of how the Vikings like to deal with pass-catching backs, mind you. No edge rusher drops into coverage more often than Andrew Van Ginkel. But for as special of a Swiss Army knife as the Gink is ... do you like him dropping with McCaffrey in space?

Much as Flores throws additional bodies at the offensive core to force players into protection, the 49ers throw as many eligible bodies as possible into the route to force defenders to win in coverage. Because the ball can go to George Kittle and McCaffrey at high volumes, it's hard to play man coverage against 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan -- your linebackers and safeties will be victimized -- so you have to drop into zone, which pulls players out of your blitz packages. Purdy has been blitzed on 29.1% of his dropbacks, 27th among 37 qualifying quarterbacks this season.

When I say "five receivers in the route," you might instinctively think about spreading the defense out -- and you'd be right. But the 49ers, critically, do not play from spread formations. No offense has been more condensed in the entire Next Gen Stats era than the 2026 49ers, who have an average formational width of 18.9 yards -- a full yard tighter than second place (the 2025 49ers at 19.9 yards).

This has been another big leap in the 49ers' offense since they acquired McCaffrey. From 2017 to 2021 -- B.C, or Before Christian -- the 49ers were in condensed sets on 42.3% of their offensive snaps. After the McCaffrey trade, that number leaps to 61.2% -- easily the highest among offenses.

The condensed sets serve several purposes. They allow the 49ers to get extra blockers into the run concept more easily -- they wouldn't have nearly as complex of a running game otherwise. They allow pre-snap motions to hit faster across the formation, which strains how well a defense communicates -- linebackers have to see a lot more when all 11 players are in the offensive picture. They all but guarantee opposing cornerbacks have outside leverage on the 49ers' wide receivers (otherwise out-breaking routes would be far too easy to complete), and that outside leverage opens up runways for the deep crosses, posts and in-breakers than Shanahan tends to favor.

The McCaffrey of it all is very simple: he's the 49ers' slot receiver. He's their player to win on option routes inside the numbers, to run little safety-valve routes through the middle of the field. But because he lines up in the backfield, the 49ers don't actually need to create a slot alignment with a nice wide formation. It would be a waste of space.

Condensed sets have drawbacks, and the first is the blitz issue. When all 11 offensive players are pulled into the core of the formation, all 11 defensive players follow. For a coach like Flores, who wants to (and has shown the ability to) blitz every single player from every possible alignment, condensed sets are a dream. It's far easier to disguise a blitz when all of the bodies are close together anyway, and the path to the quarterback is inherently shorter for cornerbacks and safeties -- the most surprising and often most devastating of the potential blitzers. The league is blitzing condensed sets at a 38% clip this season relative to 29.6% for all other formations. To condense against Flores feels like playing into his hand.

Because Flores blitzes so much, his defense is also the most condensed defense, just as the 49ers' offense is the most condensed offense. He wants as many players close to the ball as possible so that the blitz paths are shorter, just as Shanahan wants as many players close to the ball as possible so that the motion paths are shorter. Flores has at least five men in his defensive front on 79.2% of his snaps this year (highest in the Next Gen Stats era) and at least six men in the defensive front 35.8% of his snaps, second only to the 2025 Vikings. It doesn't matter if these bodies are defensive tackles or safeties or anything in between -- Flores crowds your space.

This is why the 49ers/Vikings game is so interesting to me. Shelve the actual efficiency stats for now. No two units put as much formational strain on their opponent pre-snap as these two units. And no two units throw as many bodies at their opponents as these two units. Shanahan and Flores are dictators -- not in the political despot sense, but in the playcalling sense. Elite offense against elite defense is often cast as unstoppable force against immovable object, but this matchup is more unstoppable force against unstoppable force.

This will be a true clash of football minds with six, seven layers of counterpunches and curveballs. I have absolutely no idea who will win. Play ball!


I think ... Joe Burrow is the MVP

The Bengals are throwing the football on 66.4% of their plays this season.

That number leads the league, but it's not particularly interesting. The Eagles are right behind at 65.6%. Of course, the Eagles trail in their games far more often than the Bengals do, and the Eagles are much worse at throwing the football than the Bengals are ... so that context is a little important.

We can use context -- down and distance, score differential, time remaining on clock, et cetera -- to see how often a team passes the ball relative to its expected pass rate. As we might imagine, the 2026 Bengals pass the ball a lot more than expected. They pass it when they're winning games, when they're facing third-and-short ... basically whenever they want. The Bengals' pass rate over expectation of plus-7.1%, according to NFL Next Gen Stats, is the highest of any offense since the 2022 Chiefs. We haven't seen an offense this pass-happy in four years.

Here's the real kicker. Despite having the highest pass rate over expectation we've seen since 2022... the Bengals also have the fourth-highest dropback success rate we've seen in the past 11 seasons. They are below only the 2018 Saints (elite Michael Thomas/Drew Brees year), the 2020 Bills (breakout Josh Allen season) and this year's 49ers. In terms of the rate at which they throw it and the success they have when dropping back, this is the most valuable passing attack we've seen in years.

That, case in point, is the argument to give Joe Burrow the MVP award. He has 103.7 total dropback EPA through nine games -- the most any quarterback has had through nine games since those 2022 Chiefs. That season, Patrick Mahomes had 118.3 total dropback EPA through nine weeks and he went on to win MVP.

It is significant that we haven't seen a passing game this prolific and this central in the past four years because of the defensive shift that has occurred over that time. In 2022, the league was amidst its downswing from single-high shells into two-deep zones. It's not just that NFL defenses started spamming two-deep zones -- the rate only climbed from 39.6% in 2022 to 43.9% in 2026 -- it's that defenses got a lot sharper at playing two-deep zones. Vic Fangio-style match coverages proliferated. Mike Macdonald teaching tools became widespread. Passing production fell so much that, by the start of the 2024 season, Mel Kiper Jr. was calling for two-high shells to be banned from football.

That 2022 Chiefs' offense? It lost star receiver Tyreek Hill and fell into a torpor. Only this season, with the addition of Kenneth Walker III to the roster, have the Chiefs recovered an explosive element to their offense. And it has come with an accompanying commitment to the running game. The Bills under Allen have similarly started running the ball more. Teams with elite quarterbacks have been forced to become balanced by the box counts and safety shells they've faced.

But not the Bengals. The Bengals have proved uniquely immune to this league trend.

They've experimented with the running game and with getting under center -- their pass rate over expectation through the first three weeks of the season was barely above average -- but there has simply never been a running play they can hit that's more valuable than a Burrow dropback. They've experimented with under-center alignments and heavier personnel. It just isn't potent enough, and they scrapped it this season just as they scrapped it in seasons past. All game against the Steelers, the Bengals were in the gun in spread formations. The Bengals were going to pass, the Steelers knew the Bengals were going to pass, the Bengals knew the Steelers knew that the Bengals were going to pass ... and it just didn't matter.

Burrow was sensational on Sunday night -- Aaron Rodgers called it a clinic in their postgame handshake, and he was right. Burrow went 35 for 44 with 409 passing yards and four touchdowns. He had over 300 passing yards by halftime, and was the first quarterback to do so in the last three seasons.

Aaron Rodgers to Joe Burrow: 'That was a clinic out there, kid.' pic.twitter.com/qbF8MyUsHZ

β€” Jeremy Fowler (@JFowlerESPN) November 16, 2026

Many of Burrow's throws were unspectacular decisions and unchallenging attempts. But it's the sheer volume of dropbacks, and the constant correctness -- both in decisions and in ball placement -- that allow Burrow to endure a larger weight of dropbacks than any other quarterback in the league. It isn't always so flawless. Burrow had two giveaways in their Week 4 loss to the Jaguars and another three in their overtime win against the Titans. This is why most coaches are fearful of dropping back this frequently -- as the old coaching adage goes, three things can happen when you pass, and two of them are bad. But again, Burrow is the exception that proves the rule. The league is moving to a play-action-heavy, under-center and balanced approach. The Bengals fly in the face of that headwind because their quarterback allows them to.

It looks better than it ever has under Burrow thanks in large part to the continued excellence of Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins and the emergence of All-Pro tackle Amarius Mims. Other players on this offense deserve their flowers, and head coach Zac Taylor gets his as well for staying committed to the formula despite league pressures to do otherwise. But the story starts and ends with Burrow and the MVP award he rightfully deserves through nine weeks.


I think ... the path out for the Rams is through their running backs

In the Ram's Sunday win against the Cardinals, they had more snaps in 20 personnel than any offense has had in a game since the 2019 season.

That already sounds pretty cool, but it actually gets cooler. The Rams weren't just in 20 personnel -- that's two backs, no tight ends and three receivers. They were in 20 pony personnel. Pony is a tag added to the personnel number to specify that the two backs on the field are both running backs (i.e. not a running back and a fullback). A vast majority of the two-back sets run in the league are running back and fullback. What the Rams are doing is a little different.

On their 18 snaps of pony personnel, the Rams were in the gun on all 18 and dropped back to pass on all but one. They had five explosive passes out of those 17 dropbacks, good for an explosive rate of 35.2%. That's triple the league-leading explosive pass rate of 11.9%.

The explosive passes came at the hands of actual receivers: Konata Mumpfield had two, Tutu Atwell had one and Stafford hit undrafted free agent rookie CJ Daniels (active only because of the injuries above him to Puka Nacua, Davante Adams and Jordan Whittington) on a beautiful hole shot against a Cover 2 look for a gain of 22 yards.

pic.twitter.com/79kXMtN5DI

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

But what I want you to see here is the gravity of Kyren Williams, the back who climbs out of the backfield and pulls the attention of the underneath zone defenders. The Rams were so consistently targeting their backs out of the backfield in these split-back gun looks -- four targets in the first 13 minutes of the game, to this point -- that the Cardinals' defense was forced to pull their levels closer to the line of scrimmage to take away space.

pic.twitter.com/dKwflfxEKn

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

The logic for the Rams here is sound. With Nacua, Adams and second-year tight end Terrance Ferguson all injured, the three primary targets in this offense were all absent. Because the Rams are such a heavy tight end team, they're not particularly deep at receiver, and keep only four active on game day. Did they want to live in a world in which they funneled all of Nacua's usage to players like Mumpfield and Daniels? Probably not.

Instead, the ideal players to get the ball to were the backs. Both Williams and Blake Corum are good with the ball in their hands, especially in space. Williams has long been a reliable receiver in this offense, and Corum has started to expand his skill set into that role. By targeting the backs so frequently, the Rams also let their depth receivers do what they do best: block.

Corum and Williams combined for 29 carries and 123 yards (Corum produced 100 of those himself) and another five targets for 28 yards. Corum tied his season-high mark for routes run in a game (13) and Williams put up 22 of his own (third most in a game this season). If the Cardinals had kept the game competitive, their numbers would have ballooned even higher -- by the third quarter, the Rams shelved all their pony personnel plays and became a run-the-clock under center offense.

I like this formula for the Rams as a short-term salve to their receiver absences. They're off in Week 11 before a Week 12 Wednesday game against the Packers that might decide the final NFC wild-card spot. If they can get through that game (and Week 13 against the Chiefs) before they get players like Nacua and Ferguson back, the pony personnel snaps will have done their job. Corum especially looks like a firm breakout player who is simply more dangerous as a runner than Williams, and he should continue to out-carry him accordingly.

Of course, the Rams underwent a personnel evolution midseason in 2025 when their offense shifted from 11 personnel to 13 personnel -- we wrote about it and pontificated on its consequences many times. This pony personnel interlude is not similar. The Rams' entire base offensive ideology -- under-center runs, play-action fakes, vertical downfield throws -- fits in both the 11 personnel and 13 personnel versions of the offense. The pony personnel packages, at least through one game, can't really get under center. They're far more about quick game throws and spread philosophy. This is a knuckleball that Sean McVay is pitching out of desperation. It may prove valuable enough to hang around into December, but it is unlikely to draw the same think pieces that the 13 personnel shift did.

For the short term, kudos to McVay. He had six total snaps in his Rams tenure before this Sunday. Assistant head coach Kliff Kingsbury was likely a big inspiration and author of these packages, but it remains extremely impressive how quickly the Rams can pivot midstream in their offensive approach. Despite the calamitous start, they've won four straight and could be in the playoff picture within the next two weeks. That's good coaching.


I think ... the Falcons need a new starting QB in 2027

Since the start of the 2024 season, 36 quarterbacks have taken at least 500 dropbacks. Among those 36, Michael Penix Jr. ranks 25th in EPA per dropback.

He has started 20 games in that time frame -- barely more than a season's worth. There's been a healthy dollop of good in those 20 starts. Remember the Falcons' Week 3 win over the Packers in primetime, when the running game rolled and Penix was hitting big throws down the field off play-action? Or the Week 8 win over the undefeated 49ers, after which I said Kevin Stefanski was building a Coach of the Year candidacy? Penix has splashed plenty, and splashed again in the Falcons' 35-13 loss to the Chiefs. Look at him rip this window throw to tight end Kyle Pitts Sr. between the hashes. That's serious arm strength and accuracy!

pic.twitter.com/SbomUGyLs1

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

Here's the issue: Splashes don't earn a quarterback a fourth year of patience. Penix will be entering the final year of his rookie deal in 2027 before the fifth-year option, and expectations in Atlanta are accelerated given the new coaching staff and new ownership structure (president of football Matt Ryan). With three highly paid offensive players in RB Bijan Robinson, receiver Drake London and Pitts, Atlanta's offense should, in theory, be a dangerous unit.

Penix has the next two months to prove he is consistent enough to captain that unit and that his game isn't splashes, but actual reliable stretches of production. The clock is ticking, and the recent play has not been encouraging.

Penix has always been a dangerous big-play thrower, but the Falcons are desperately trying to elicit more down-to-down accuracy from him, especially on quick-game throws. Penix has an 18.4% off-target rate this season on quick passes, worse than all quarterbacks save for the Giants' Jameis Winston; his QBR of 63.6 on those throws is well below the league average (76.0).

Because Penix is a bit robotic mechanically and doesn't have a particularly fluid build, he struggles to get to quick game throws on time, and those late telegraphed releases can draw defenders to the target. He also generally struggles to throw the ball to his right, which is another mechanical deficiency (remember, Penix is a left-handed passer). He has an off-target rate of 25.3% when throwing to the right since he entered the league relative to 18.8% on throws to his left.

So quick-game throws are tough, and half the field is cut off. Penix can offset these deficiencies with his big-play strengths. A run-first Falcons offense can get to the play-action pass game -- something offensive coordinator Tommy Rees is running more this season than outgoing offensive playcaller Zac Robinson ever did -- and use Penix's big arm talent to stretch the field.

But there's another issue here. In order to get routes down the field, the quarterback needs to hold the football ... and that time in the pocket invites pressure. Penix simply cannot handle pressured dropbacks at a starting level, and has not been able to since entering the league. On the season, he is 22nd in the league in EPA per unpressured dropbacks and 36th (out of 37 QBs) in EPA per pressured dropbacks. The difference in his performance from unpressured to pressured dropbacks is bigger than any quarterback in the league save for the Ravens' Lamar Jackson, who barely makes the minimum dropback threshold.

Steve Spagnuolo and the Chiefs knew this, and they regularly dented the pocket to affect Penix's throwing platform and dramatically impact his accuracy. Penix was pressured on 16 dropbacks and blitzed on 13 dropbacks by the Chiefs, largely in the second half when dropbacks were forced by the point differential. You can feel the discomfort in these dropbacks

pic.twitter.com/GSeZ5SMOJA

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

It's understandable that Penix is worried about getting hit, given his prolonged injury history. But Penix is rarely hit with the Falcons -- his 4.7 contacts per game is lowest in the league -- and limits the offense by his inability to take on contact and find bigger throws for his patience.

There are too many limits in Penix's game. The injury history creates unreliability and limits how easily the offense can get the ball down the field with him. The mechanical issues create accuracy sprays that limit the efficacy of quick games and make the passing game one-handed. There will undoubtedly be more and more splashes as the season goes on -- there always will be with a quarterback of Penix's arm talent. But even if he ends the season hot, the Falcons need to see the forest through the trees and understand that they'll never get the level of consistency they want from the position with a player like Penix under center.

Who knows? Maybe he will turn a corner over the next two months. The Falcons' coaching staff is clearly trying to get him to operate better in the quick game, and that lightbulb may come on here. But short of a massive stylistic change, I think Atlanta needs a new starting quarterback in 2027.


I think ... the Saints need a new starting quarterback in 2027

Since the start of the 2025 season, 37 quarterbacks have taken at least 300 dropbacks. Among those 37, Tyler Shough ranks 24th in EPA per dropback. He's 25th in dropback success rate and, perhaps most notably, 37th in explosive pass rate.

He has 18 starts in that time frame -- barely more than a full season -- and the Saints are rightfully leaving him as the unquestioned starter as they look to elicit more development from him. But Sunday's game against the Panthers was between two 3-5 teams leading their division, and the Saints played at home against a Panthers defense that had fired its defensive coordinator, was missing both starting cornerbacks and was 22nd in EPA per drive (and 27th in actual points per drive) entering the contest.

The Saints managed 17 points on 11 drives. Their 3.6 yards per play was their lowest output of the entire season save for their contest against Brian Flores and the Vikings' defense. Anytime you're making this Panthers' defense look like a Flores-coached unit, you didn't have a good day on offense.

This was the most frustrating Shough start I've seen through his NFL career. A towering 40% of his throws were behind the line of scrimmage; 80% of his throws were within 10 yards of the line of scrimmage. Both are the highest numbers for a single game in his career. That 40% mark is one of only 13 games this season -- by any quarterback -- in which the ball stayed behind the line of scrimmage that frequently.

The playcall contributed far less to the concentration of underneath passes than you might suspect. Shough was terrified of pushing the ball despite the fact that he finally had both of his top receivers, Chris Olave and Jordyn Tyson, available for a game; that left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. was back in the starting lineup against a very mediocre pass rush; and that there was air available to him in the Panthers' secondary.

Here's an unacceptable turndown. It's first-and-10 from the Panthers' 43 yard line with 1:07 left and the Saints are down by three. They still have one timeout. Shough's priorities here are to avoid negatives, as the Saints are already in long field-goal range, and to get his team in position to take some end zone shots before attempting an end-of-game field goal.

Again, on first down Shough has a wide-open checkdown over the ball from Devaughn Vele and a one-on-one with Olave against Corey Thornton to the bottom of the screen. The Vele throw takes the field goal from a 60-yarder to a low-50-yarder. The Olave throw might give them a chance to win. Shough bails on a clean pocket and throws late to Alvin Kamara on the sideline.

pic.twitter.com/YpOMxKHKG6

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

Shough got off Olave's stutter-and-go because the corner had such a deep alignment, but the post safety isn't even inside the hashes. Olave has been one of the five best receivers in football this year. Thornton is a practice squad call-up. Throw the ball.

Here's an earlier first down on the same drive. Olave is on a 10-yard hitch to the top of the screen. The corner is in the half-turn, which will make it hard for him to drive on this throw. The seam carries two defenders with it. Throw the hitch to Olave. Throw, throw, throw.

pic.twitter.com/RAcH4HKLpG

β€” Good Clips (@MeshSitWheel) November 17, 2026

Shough breaks the pocket -- and what a boon he discovers! His gravity pulls the linebacker down to the line of scrimmage, and tight end Noah Fant (87) is open on the logo. Still Shough does not throw this ball.

Shough has become totally allergic to the intermediate depth of the field over the course of the season. Only 15.5% of his pass attempts have gone 10-19 yards downfield this season -- only Deshaun Watson and Bo Nix go to that thorny patch less frequently. Particularly frustrating is that this was not an issue last year, when 23.9% of his passes hit that range. Shough has become more fearful of coverage as his career has gone on, and that trend is a hard one to unteach.

Such an apprehensive approach to air yards can be endured if a quarterback has a particularly deep ball. Such is the case with Nix, who really struggles to make intermediate passes but can uncork pinpoint deep throws that get many of those lost yards back in one fell swoop. Shough has yet to earn that faith. His off-target rate on throws of 20-plus air yards is 47.4% -- 31st among 37 qualifying quarterbacks this season. Since he entered the league, that number is 52.1% when you include the 2025 season, and is the lowest of any quarterback over that stretch.

If Shough cannot connect on deep balls and does not attack the intermediate area of the field, he cannot create the chunk gains necessary to hold down a starting quarterback job in the league. There is a mitigating concern here -- the Saints' running game has been among the league's worst since Shough took over the reins, and without that running game, Shough has to dink-and-dunk more often to keep his offense on schedule. But C.J. Stroud has a running game as ineffective as Shough's and is leading the league in air yards per attempt this year. It isn't enough to say "the running game is bad, the passing game will open up when it improves." Shough is a ceiling on this passing attack as much as the handoff game is.

Shough will likely get a longer grace period than Penix might, seeing as he's only a second-year pro, but he is 27 and it's hard to imagine him improving much at this age. Of all the things difficult to teach a quarterback, aggression is perhaps the most challenging. Unless I see Shough decide to push the ball into tighter windows down the stretch of 2026, I'll wonder just how committed the Saints are to a second-round pick -- remember, he doesn't have a first-round pedigree! -- as the unquestioned starter.

Perhaps my eyes are on the wrong target, and Kellen Moore will get the heat for the lack of a running game -- a justifiable frustration. But then Shough will enter the 2027 season much as Penix entered the 2026 season ... with an uncertain hold on a starting job, and perhaps a veteran minimum addition like Tua Tagovailoa meant to challenge him in training camp. The quarterback hurt the offense in the must-win against the Panthers and has kept their passing game far too meek through 10 weeks of this season. Something needs to change, fast.


I think ... the Aidan Hutchinson injury might be season-ending for the Lions

Let's start with a necessary caveat. The Lions have a top-five offense, and a top-five offense is never truly out of it, because the NFL playoffs are short enough that a perfect run is possible. There are a maximum of four games in a Super Bowl run. I've always appreciated that about the NFL playoffs. If a team decides to get thermonuclear hot on offense -- as the Lions very well might -- then they'll just win the Super Bowl on the back of that excellent streak.

With that caveat out of the way ... the Lions are in trouble, man.

Star linebacker Jack Campbell is on injured reserve and likely out for the season with a neck injury. Star safety Kerby Joseph has practiced, but his return from a knee injury -- which plagued him for the entire 2025 season -- is far from guaranteed. And now the star pass rusher is out for the season with a torn ACL, suffered celebrating a sack of Drake Maye in Munich on Sunday.

play

2:10

McAfee can't believe how unlucky Aidan Hutchinson's injury is

This is brutal stuff. Not only was Hutchinson one of three remaining stars (Brian Branch, Alim McNeill) on the Lions' depleted defensive roster, he was the one with the highest potential to take a game over with pressures on the quarterback.

Earlier in the season, I documented the Lions' defensive issues on pressured dropbacks. The air in the secondary was so tremendous that even when Detroit was getting after the passer, they still allowed big gains through the air because of coverage miscommunications and poor man coverage performance. They have since tightened things up tremendously -- hats off to defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard, who came under heavy fire to start the season and has found serious solutions in the weeks since. The Lions have blitzed far less frequently and played more man coverage across the board to great effect. Since Week 5, they are 26th in blitz rate and first in man coverage rate.

In this new version of the defense -- aggressive man coverage, extra bodies in the defensive backfield to get brackets and QB spies -- you better be able to get after the passer. Because Detroit's defensive line is peppered with big-bodied brawlers who slow down the running game, the Lions don't really generate immediate pressure. Again since Week 5, the Lions are just about league average in pressure rate (35.3%), but 25th in time to pressure. Even with Hutchinson out there, they were not manufacturing many quick wins.

Give any NFL quarterback time against man coverage looks, he'll find open receivers. The league is running less man coverage this season than ever before for that simple reason: Quarterbacks and receivers are just too good. Schemers create separation. Athletes get yards after the catch. On unpressured dropbacks since Week 5, the Lions are 27th in defensive success rate with a completion percentage allowed over expectation of plus-3.1%, well above league average. They don't have the defensive backs to live like this.

As the Lions' team pressure rate falls without Hutchinson -- he led the team with 50 pressures on the year, and McNeill was second at 35 -- opposing offenses get more time in the pocket to challenge players like Roger McCreary and Rock Ya-Sin in man-to-man. Expect McNeill, who has been having a resurgent 2026 season, to see a decrease in efficiency without the threat of Hutchinson as well. Offenses can dedicate all of their additional protection resources to McNeill and dare DJ Wonnum, Tyleik Williams and Derrick Moore to punish them. It's an easy bet to make.

Of course, in the ideal world, Sheppard could crank up the blitzes to account for Hutchinson's absence ... but we already know how that goes, don't we?

Detroit's defense is caught between a rock and a hard place. It's awful to see injuries like this on a contender, but I struggle to rank the Lions' defense as a playoff-caliber unit without Hutchinson. Sheppard has eight weeks to uncover something new schematically to account for the absence of the star pass rusher, or a depth player on Detroit's defensive line has the same time frame to ascend rapidly into a game-changing player. Otherwise, the Lions' defense -- with all of their many absences considered -- simply feels outgunned entering January football.

Detroit will fight -- Dan Campbell's team always will. But if they can't secure home-field advantage in a highly competitive NFC and are forced to play on the road in the winter, the path to the Super Bowl will pass through the eye of a needle. There are always a couple of true contenders every year who fall to injury attrition -- the Lions were one such team in the 2024 season, and it feels like they're becoming one again.


I think ... the Fernando Mendoza debut game is a total scratch

It is not in my best interest to tell you this: I feed my family with your clicks and engagement. Ideally, I should tell you this: "The secret to Fernando Mendoza's entire career was revealed to me in his first start, and if you scroll to the bottom of this page and click my affiliate links, I will reveal the information to you."

But this is a scratch. Not so much because the Raiders were facing Mike Macdonald and the Seahawks' ferocious defense, though that was certainly a factor. The Seahawks had five unblocked pressures, tied for their second-highest mark in a game this season. That volume of unimpeded rushers is too much for most quarterbacks to handle, yet alone a young passer in his first career start. The Seahawks also had three unblocked sacks on Mendoza after totaling four through the first nine games. If the pressures are an offensive line and playcalling issue, the sacks are more of a quarterback issue; Mendoza needs to better recognize when he's hot and get the ball out.

But it's not the Seahawks' defense that scratches the game for me. It's Brock Bowers' right ankle injury.

The Raiders' star tight end was on the field for eight snaps Sunday. He left the game after the Raiders' first drive, tried to go again, and left the game for good early in the second quarter.

Bowers is as integral to a game plan as any offensive player in the league. He's at Jaxon Smith-Njigba or Jahmyr Gibbs' level in terms of getting him the ball a lot in high-leverage spots. During Bowers' plays on the field, he was targeted twice and had key gravity on an easy Michael Mayer completion. Against a team like the Seahawks, who play nickel defense to almost any personnel, Bowers and the Raiders' multiple tight end sets figured to be the centerpiece of their offense.

Once Bowers went down, a majority of the game plan went with him. The Raiders were in 11 personnel on 50.8% of their snaps in this game after averaging 12.6% 11 personnel through the first nine weeks -- the lowest rate of any offense in the league. Again, because the Seahawks are so good in nickel, playing 11 personnel is playing into their strengths. Second-year wideout Jack Bech, who recently returned from the injured reserve, played 56% of the snaps -- his season high -- but delivered only 10 yards and two receptions on seven targets. Free agent signing Jalen Nailor -- the lone addition to this thin receiver room -- ran 34 routes and produced minus-1 receiving yards. Titular WR1 Tre Tucker didn't fare much better: 32 routes, two targets, one reception for 9 yards.

The Raiders' wide receiver room isn't the worst in football given other teams' injuries (looking at you, Los Angeles Rams and Arizona Cardinals). But this is a bottom-five unit at the position leaguewide. If Mendoza were in his fourth or fifth start throwing to this group of receivers, we would know that the talent is insufficient to get a fair read on a budding passer.

play

1:00

Seattle Seahawks vs. Las Vegas Raiders: Game Highlights

The Raiders know this, too. Rookie coach Klint Kubiak has been expressing his frustrations with the WR2 role behind Tucker since August. This is why Bowers is such a load-bearing wall in the passing game. They can't recreate his impact in the aggregate -- neither backup tight end Mayer nor third-string tight end Ian Thomas can line up in the slot and run a full route tree -- and they can't hide the receiver room without him.

Kubiak said Bowers is day-to-day because of his ankle injury, and the Raiders better hope those days run quickly before their Week 11 matchup with the Broncos. Las Vegas' receiver room is wholly outmatched against Denver's group of cornerbacks, and Broncos defensive coordinator Vance Joseph will bring blitzes just as Macdonald did, to test Mendoza's ability to undress defensive looks and adjust protections. But Kubiak will have a week to build a game plan without Bowers, and Mendoza will have that week to ingest it -- but will still be an unendurably uphill battle for a young passer.

I'm not interested in any sweeping Mendoza takeaways until he gets a normal game with a healthy Bowers. Sorry, take machine.

Four things I might think

I might think ... Parker Washington will make $40 million a year next season. I cannot get over how technically skilled he is. His catch-point work is at the same skill level as Tee Higgins or Drake London -- Washington just plays at 5-foot-10, not 6-foot-4. The way he elevates, invites contact to box out defenders, rips the ball off the shelf and protects it from late defenders is all sensational. Washington is in the final year of his deal and is the clear WR1 in Jacksonville. When the Jaguars have to play more competitive four-quarter games down the stretch, he'll produce more outings similar to the one he had this past Sunday: 7 catches, 152 yards and a score.

I might think ... Chuba Hubbard is my new Most Underrated Player in football. Coming into this season, it was Higgins, but he's getting his proper shine now. In this big-time win over the Saints, Hubbard had a career-best 172 yards from scrimmage and put up 55 receiving yards on two checkdowns to set up the go-ahead drive in the fourth quarter. Hubbard is a sound runner, excellent receiver and quality pass protector who has cleaned up some early-career fumble issues over the past two seasons; he has two fumbles in his past 356 touches. Hubbard is fifth in touches per game (21.3), putting him in the same company as premier backs such as Bijan Robinson and Jonathan Taylor. Good player.

I might think ... the Tory Horton bat is the play of the year. Did y'all see this? With 2:04 on the clock, the Raiders wanted to kick a touchback to preserve the two-minute warning as a clock stoppage. Horton, the Seahawks' returner, doesn't let them secure that touchback by skying for the kick and batting it into the field of play for Rashid Shaheed to retrieve and run out some clock. It was a little thing, but spectacular awareness. He looked like he was robbing a home run!

β€” NFL (@NFL) November 15, 2026

I might think ... Josh Downs is going to save the Chiefs. Eight routes, five targets, four receptions and a touchdown. Now that's efficiency. I thought Downs looked so skilled as a receiver; he always has, but especially against the backdrop of the Chiefs' alternatives at the position, his reliability is already apparent. As his role expands, the menu of touches in Kansas City should run through Downs, Kenneth Walker III, Rashee Rice, Travis Kelce and rookie breakout running back Emmett Johnson. It's not amazing, but you can win a Super Bowl with that group.

Source: ESPN Β· Ben Solak

At a glance

Topic
Sports
Country
πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ US
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira