Mauricio Pochettino has arrived at Manchester United and the former United States men's national team coach has no time to waste as the new manager of the Premier League's fallen giants.
Pochettino's immediate task is to halt the team's slump and drag United out of the relegation zone, starting with Sunday's trip to Liverpool as his first game in charge. Securing a first league win since August is also a priority for the former Tottenham Hotspur and Chelsea boss.
However, the 54-year-old must look beyond the short term at Old Trafford. He must begin to shape a team in his own image, with players capable of playing the Pochettino way.
- Man United, Pochettino's to-do list based on what's gone wrong
- Pochettino can't fix United on his own. The owners have to do their jobs
- Where are they now? Every Utd player, coach, exec since Glazers' takeover
Former United captain Gary Neville said last week that, while interviewing him at Spurs in 2014, Pochettino was sat in front of a whiteboard with two lists of players: those he could trust and build around, and those he decided he could not work with.
Having inherited a squad built by United's six previous managers dating back to Louis van Gaal's signing of Luke Shaw in 2014, Pochettino must quickly assess his players and draw up a similar list of who will stay and who will go.
So with the Pochettino era about to start at United, what will his whiteboard look like at the end of the season? Who stays, and who has to go?
Jump to: Goalkeepers | Defenders | Midfielders | Forwards
Goalkeepers
Senne Lammens (24 years old)
The Belgium international had an impressive first season at United last term, but his form has dipped at Old Trafford since a costly error at the FIFA World Cup led to Belgium's elimination against Spain. But while United could find an upgrade, Lammens is not one of the team's problems and he deserves to stay.
Verdict: Stay
Karl Darlow (36)
Signed as a free agent this summer after his exit from Leeds United, the Wales international is United's No. 2, but he is not a top-class keeper and nowhere near the level of his counterparts at the Premier League's top clubs.
Verdict: Go
0:17
Pochettino addresses Manchester United supporters for the first time
Defenders
Diogo Dalot (27)
Ordinarily, Dalot would have no future at United and been offloaded years ago. But his versatility and fitness record -- the Portugal defender has missed just 18 games due to injury since January 2020 -- have made him a regular starter. Dalot lacks defensive qualities, but he is durable and committed. With both of those qualities in short supply at Old Trafford, Pochettino might need him to hang around.
Verdict: Stay
Noussair Mazraoui (29)
A £15 million signing from Bayern Munich in 2024, the Morocco international was recruited as a squad player. He has played in a variety of positions in defense and midfield and even once, unsuccessfully, as a No. 10. But he's not good enough for any role and has an unreliable fitness record.
Verdict: Go
Matthijs de Ligt (27)
United's football department opposed De Ligt's €45 million signing from Bayern Munich due to concerns over his injury record, but ultimately sanctioned the deal as a means of backign manager Erik ten Hag. According to Transfermarkt, De Ligt has been unavailable for 343 days due to injury since arriving at Old Trafford in August 2024.
Verdict: Go
Harry Maguire (33)
Once the world's most expensive defender following his £80 million transfer from Leicester City in 2019, Maguire has had an up and down United career, but he earned a new one-year contract last summer. In a mediocre defensive unit, Maguire brings leadership and experience, albeit with a lack of pace. With with a huge defensive clear-out likely, Maguire's positives outweigh his negatives in the short-term.
Verdict: Stay
Lisandro Martínez (28)
The Argentina defender is out of contract next summer and even though the former Ajax player may develop a connection with fellow countryman Pochettino, he remains too reckless and injury-prone to have a long-term future. His form has been poor all season, so there are no reasons to offer him a new contract.
Verdict: Go
Leny Yoro (21)
The France defender has struggled with form and fitness since arriving from Lille two years ago. However, his age, potential and pace are all positives Pochettino can exploit. Yoro needs to develop defensively, but he is a player who can become a top player at his position with the right coaching.
Verdict: Stay
Luke Shaw (31)
The former England left back has made 241 Premier League appearances for United in more than 12 years since arriving from Southampton -- just over half of the 466 league games played by the club in that time. Shaw knows Pochettino from their time together at Saints, but even that connection is unlikely to save him when his contract expires at the end of the season.
Verdict: Go
Ayden Heaven (20)
The former Arsenal youngster has made over 30 senior appearances for United and has shown potential, but has also struggled for form in an inconsistent team. It is too soon to assess whether he can be a United player and he may need a loan move to gain more experience.
Verdict: Stay
Harry Amass (19)
The naturally left-sided full back hasn't made a Premier League appearance since May 2025 having been loaned to Sheffield Wednesday and Norwich last season. He was overlooked by former manager Michael Carrick in the league this season, but expect Pochettino to give him a chance in the weeks ahead.
Verdict: Stay
3:08
What does Pochettino need to change to make Man United successful?
Midfielders
Mason Mount (27)
The former Chelsea midfielder has completed 90 minutes in a Premier League game on just four occasions since arriving at Old Trafford in 2023, and has missed 71 games due to injury in that time. Mount is under contract until 2028, but Pochettino can't rely on him in any way.
Verdict: Go
Bruno Fernandes (32)
United's best player and captain, but his future is a big dilemma for Pochettino. United can trigger a one-year contract extension on Fernandes' deal to keep him until 2028, when he will be approaching his 34th birthday. But if Pochettino wants to rebuild, it may be in everyone's best interest to cash in next summer and start again with a younger alternative.
Verdict: Go
Andrey Santos (22)
Santos was loaned out to Nottingham Forest and Strasbourg during Pochettino's one season as Chelsea coach in 2023-24, so that doesn't bode well for the Brazil international. But having signed a five-year contract following a £48 million transfer this summer, it won't be easy to offload a player who has struggled to make an impact so far at United.
Verdict: Go
Youri Tielemans (29)
A proven Premier League player following seven years with Leicester and Aston Villa, the Belgium international was signed for £35 million this summer to add experience following Casemiro's move to Inter Miami. Tielemans is a quality player and will survive, but long-term he might struggle with Pochettino's demands for fitness and energy.
Verdict: Stay
Carlos Baleba (22)
A £65 million summer signing from Brighton & Hove Albion, Baleba was starting to add tenacity, mobility and energy to United's midfield before suffering a hamstring injury in the win against Roma earlier this month. When fit, he will be a key figure under Pochettino.
Verdict: Stay
Manuel Ugarte (25)
United had planned to offload the Uruguay midfielder this summer before he suffered a cruciate ligament injury at the World Cup which will keep him sidelined until the spring. The €50 million signing from Paris Saint-Germain lacks pace, mobility and passing ability, so has no future at Old Trafford.
Verdict: Go
Kobbie Mainoo (21)
The England international signed a five-year contract this summer, but his future is by no means certain. His age and contract length mean United could secure a significant fee if he is moved on. But while his immediate prospects are good under Pochettino, he will need to become fitter and quicker around the pitch to be a long-term part of the new manager's plans.
Verdict: Stay
Patrick Dorgu (22)
The Denmark international is naturally left-sided and has played at full back, left midfield and left wing since arriving from Lecce in January 2024, but he has only shown rare glimpses of being good enough for United. He is unlikely to survive for long if Pochettino gets the chance to rebuild.
Verdict: Go
1:44
Why now is the right time for Man United and Pochettino
Forwards
Marcus Rashford (29)
United have tried and failed to offload their highest earner (on wages of £325,000 a week) for the last two summers, with neither Aston Villa nor Barcelona turning loan moves into permanent deals. At his best, Rashford can hurt opponents with his pace and finishing, but he doesn't work hard enough for a Pochettino player.
Verdict: Go
Matheus Cunha (27)
The Brazil international has only scored 14 goals since his £62.5 million move from Wolverhampton Wanderers in 2025. However, he is one of a handful of United players to have shown fight and determination in bad moments. Cunha also scores big goals so, while he has his flaws, he can be a key player under Pochettino.
Verdict: Stay
Joshua Zirkzee (25)
Too slow to be a Premier League forward and lacking in any kind of physicality, but he has done well as a substitute in recent weeks. He may be completely unsuited to English football, but having signed for just €42.5 million, United might get most of their money if they can offload the Netherlands international.
Verdict: Go
Amad Diallo (24)
The former Atalanta winger can be a frustrating player who often makes the wrong decision, but the upside is that he makes things happen in the attacking third. He is unlikely to be good enough long-term, and United could raise much-needed funds by offloading him.
Verdict: Go
Bryan Mbeumo (27)
Mbeumo has struggled for form this season after an impressive first campaign at Old Trafford last term, but he is a proven Premier League goal scorer. The former Brentford forward has looked short on fitness recently, but if he sharpens up under the new regime, he can get back to his best quickly.
Verdict: Stay
Benjamin Sesko (23)
The jury is still out on the 6-foot-6 Slovenia forward, an €85 million signing from RB Leipzig in 2025. He scored some big goals last season and offers United height and a physical presence up front, but lacks mobility and is likely to take time to return to full fitness having suffered a shin problem that has sidelined him this season. He may not appeal to Pochettino, but good luck offloading him for anywhere close to the transfer fee they signed him for.
Verdict: Stay
Shea Lacey (19)
If United are to return to some kind of success under Pochettino, they need to jumpstart their once-productive youth system and Lacey is showing that the club's youngsters are still capable of having an impact. The winger has pace, trickery, awareness and courage, so expect him to be given an early chance under the new boss.
Verdict: Stay
Source: ESPN · Mark Ogden
At a glance
- Topic
- Sports
- Country
- 🇺🇸 US
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira