âWe will introduce a fair conscription law that will pass through three stages. This is a law that will be the fairest, one that will pass the [IDF] chief of staff, the High Court of Justice, and [Degel HaTorah spiritual leader] Rabbi Lando.â
Thus spoke Yisrael Beytenu leader Avigdor Liberman, just minutes after taking the gavel as chairman of the Knessetâs temporary Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee on Monday.
Yeah, sure.
To do that - to come up with a bill that would satisfy the IDF, the Supreme Court, and Rabbi Lando - one would have to be a political magician, a consensus builder, and a miracle worker.
After some 30 years in politics, Liberman has proven to be nothing of the kind. Rather, he has proven to be a political survivor and the Great Disruptor.
He survived years of criminal investigations, an indictment on fraud and breach-of-trust charges that ended in acquittal, and the convictions of senior figures in his party in a separate corruption case.
He survived floating the idea in 2001 of bombing the Aswan Dam. He survived giving Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh a 48-hour ultimatum in 2016: Return the Israelis and the soldiersâ bodies held in Gaza or face death. Haniyeh outlasted Libermanâs tenure as defense minister.
He survived a 2009 proposal aimed at Arab Israelis that would have conditioned citizenship rights - including the right to vote - on a pledge of loyalty to Israel as a Jewish state and a commitment to military or national service. He also survived a plan to redraw Israelâs borders to draw outside the country the major Arab population centers in the Triangle and draw into the country the major settlement blocs.
He survived leaving the Likud in 1999, then joining forces with it in a joint electoral list in 2013, only to dissolve that parliamentary partnership in 2014.
Heâs a political survivor.
Liberman is a great disruptor
As for being the Great Disruptor -Â a role once filled by the Likudâs David Levy -Â he played that to the hilt in 2019 when he shocked the country by blocking Netanyahu from forming a government over, of all things, the haredi draft issue, sending the country spiraling into a seemingly endless cycle of elections.
And there he is, doing it again. This time he is disrupting Yashar chairman Gadi Eisenkotâs hope of swearing in a minority government resting on outside support from the Arab parties, and he is disrupting the whole political universe by doing a volte-face on the haredi draft issue.
Some might say he is just doing what Naftali Bennett did in 2021, going back on a campaign promise to prevent Yair Lapid from serving as prime minister, including in rotation, and avoid forming a government reliant on Mansour Abbasâ Raâam party.
The difference is that whereas Bennett signed a pledge to that effect on television two days before the March 2021 election - and less than three months later formed a rotation government with Lapid and brought Abbasâ Raâam into the coalition - Â Libermanâs entire political persona has been built for years on confronting the haredi parties over running buses and opening stores on Shabbat, as well as demanding yeshiva students go into the army. Â This is not a three-month-old promise, but a political persona developed over decades.
And then, poof, he now wants to draft a law that will pass muster with Lando. The same Lando he wanted the police to go after last year for telling yeshiva students to ignore their draft orders.
When the previous government said it was trying to pass a conscription law with its haredi partners that would satisfy both the IDF and the High Court of Justice, Liberman led the chorus - picked up by much of the mainstream media - calling it not a âconscription bill,â but a âdraft evasion bill.â Â Since the elections, much of the mainstream media has already changed its tone, labeling any such compromise law not as a draft evasion law, but as a âsofterâ conscription law.
Liberman's draft bill is not realistic
Libermanâs vow to draft such a bill acceptable to the IDF, the High Court, and Lando is about as realistic as his threat to bomb the Aswan Dam or kill Haniyeh within 48 hours of being sworn in as defense minister.
Why? Because those three positions are extremely far apart.
The IDFâs position is that it is short some 12,000 soldiers - including 7,500 in combat roles and the rest in support positions - and needs haredi conscription to fill its ranks.
The High Court of Justice ruled in June 2024 that once the law allowing yeshiva students to defer military service expired, the government needed to apply the existing draft law equally, Â including to yeshiva students. Continuing to exempt them without a legal basis, the court held, would constitute discriminatory enforcement. The case dealt specifically with yeshiva students. Arab citizensâ military service is a separate question.
And the position of Lando? At a minimum, that no yeshiva student should be drafted. In February 2026, at a yeshiva in Rehovot, he vowed, âNot a single yeshiva student, not even one, will go into the army.â
And the maximum: that no haredi - not even those not in any yeshiva framework - don a uniform.
So passing a bill that meets all three standards is, quite clearly, a gargantuan task.
And that is not all. He will also have to defuse opposition in his own change bloc.
One of the first bills already presented by Bennettâs BâYachad party would expand benefits for reservists and discharged soldiers, funded in part by cutting support to households that neither serve nor participate in the workforce.
On Monday, just after taking over as head of the temporary Finance Committee, BâYachadâs Liran Avisar Ben Horin said: âThe committee that I head will promote the revolution of those who serve and work with all the means at its disposal to return the taxpayersâ monies to them, and to halt payments that incentivize draft evasion and life in poverty.â
She was interrupted by Landoâs representative, Ya'akov Asher, who said, âWhat a great joke.â
Liberman said his bill would have to pass through three stations. Make that four. The fourth is in his own camp. He might want to start there. It ought to be the easiest, but even that one will be extremely difficult to get through.
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · HERB KEINON
At a glance
- Topic
- Politics
- Country
- đźđ± IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira