Alex ScarboroughNov 18, 2026, 01:26 PM ET
- Covers the SEC.
- Joined ESPN in 2012.
- Graduate of Auburn University.
BIRMINGHAM, Ala. -- A federal judge scolded lawyers representing LSU on Wednesday for claiming the SEC "hallucinated" citations in a court filing, demanding what amounts to a retraction as well as "heartfelt" public statements expressing their regret for using language that maligned the character of opposing attorneys.
The SEC filed a lawsuit against LSU in September over its attempts to play professional athletes. The LSU football team ultimately did not roster the former pros it had sought to sign, but the lawsuit has continued to progress through the legal system.
On Tuesday, LSU basketball rostered former professional RJ Luis, following a local judge's ruling that made Luis eligible.
The hearing on Wednesday at the Hugo L. Black United States Courthouse centered on LSU's language in a filing that accused the SEC of negligently supplying or hallucinating case citations. The SEC called the statement as "scandalous and professionally insulting."
Judge Annemarie Carney Axon questioned LSU attorney Bruce Rogers extensively over use of the term "hallucinated." She clarified with Rogers that the citation was indeed legitimate. To which Rogers said, "They're not made-up cases."
Rogers focused on what came after the use of the word "hallucinated." He said they were hallucinated "because" the holdings of the cases cited didn't support the SEC's argument.
Axon pushed back.
"You're not going to tell me you don't understand the ramifications of an allegation that somebody hallucinated something?" she asked.
Rogers claimed they were not calling out the lawyers, which Axon said was the "opposite" of what was written in his brief.
Rogers said the brief was written by the solicitor general of the state of Louisiana. Axon asked whether there was enough time for him to attend, and Rogers said there was.
LSU has sought to dismiss the lawsuit. The SEC claims attempts to resolve the case privately have failed.
Rogers argued that "hallucinated" was a broader term drawn from when artificial intelligence hallucinates or distorts facts. The SEC included in its filing that it used A.I. But Rogers pointed out that the SEC also said that it independently reviewed the document before filing.
Axon asked Rogers, "Do you consider attacks on people's professional reputation and character to be legitimate advocacy?"
Rogers said no.
"You wouldn't want somebody to wrongly accuse you of hallucinating a case, knowing full well what the implication of that accusation is," Axon said.
Rogers again said there was a broader definition to the term "hallucinated."
"We're not dressing this up, OK?" Axon said. "You put the pig out there. There's no time for you to put lipstick on it."
Rogers told Axon he didn't think it was "appropriate" to attack the character of another member of the bar.
SEC attorney Tom Warburton briefly addressed the court. He said one of their "major fears" was that the language from the LSU filing would be "picked up" in public. He brought multiple instances of that happening, including holding up a printout of a story from USA Today.
Rogers said they would file in the afternoon a request to remove the term "hallucinated" from the filing.
Axon said Rogers could file the motion and to include that it exhibited "poor professional judgment."
"That's No. 1," she said.
No. 2, she added, would be "heartfelt" and "robust" public statements to be approved by her from Rogers, LSU and the attorney general's office.
Axon closed the proceeding by telling Rogers what a "privilege" it had been for her to work alongside him before becoming a judge.
"I have to tell you I'm so disappointed," she said.
"If this happens one more time, you're going to be sanctioned to the fullest extent I can."
Source: ESPN · Alex Scarborough
At a glance
- Topic
- Sports
- Country
- 🇺🇸 US
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira