In the theater, some of the most painful moments occur when two people who love each other become so convinced of their own righteousness that they can no longer hear what the other is saying.
Each knows the other’s weaknesses, remembers every slight, and believes that yielding even an inch would amount to betraying something essential.
By the time the curtain falls, the original disagreement may seem almost beside the point. What remains is the damage they have done to one another.
I wonder whether Israel has become trapped in a similar drama.
The country has endured extraordinary trauma, external threats, and years of bitter political confrontation. Its citizens have argued over the courts, religion, military service, the Palestinians, and the character of the Jewish state.
These are profound disagreements that cannot simply be wished away. But the language of Israeli politics has become so unforgiving that opponents increasingly seem unable to recognize one another as people who might also love their country.
As Israel emerges from another election and enters the familiar turmoil of political bargaining, the question is not simply who will govern. It is whether the next government, whatever its composition, can begin repairing a society in which mutual suspicion has become deeply ingrained.
You can survive fierce political disagreement, but it is much harder to flourish when disagreement becomes permanent estrangement.
Importance of the State of Israel
As the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, I grew up with a profound appreciation for the importance of Israel. My mother’s generation understood what it meant to live in a world where Jews had nowhere to turn.
The establishment of a sovereign Jewish state represented an extraordinary transformation in our people’s history, one that must never be taken for granted.
That history also helps explain why Israelis approach questions of security with such intensity.
The trauma of October 7, the wars that followed, and the continuing threats to Israel’s existence have reinforced fears that are neither imaginary nor easily dismissed.
But precisely because Israel faces such serious external challenges, its internal divisions should be treated as a matter of national security.
The country’s extraordinary military capabilities, technological achievements, and economic dynamism depend ultimately on the confidence of its citizens in their shared future.
A society in which large segments of the population distrust one another, question the legitimacy of democratic institutions or feel excluded from the national project cannot indefinitely sustain the solidarity on which its security depends.
Israel’s founders disagreed passionately about almost everything. Religious and secular Zionists, socialists and conservatives, and immigrants from vastly different backgrounds somehow managed to build a functioning state.
They did not eliminate their differences. They recognized, however imperfectly, that their common enterprise was larger than any single faction.
Today, that recognition seems increasingly fragile. Political disagreement becomes a test of patriotism. Those who advocate territorial compromise are accused of endangering Israel’s survival.
Those who insist on uncompromising security measures are dismissed as indifferent to human suffering.
Religious and secular Israelis regard one another with growing suspicion, while Arab citizens these days are finding their place in the national conversation contested.
There are legitimate arguments on all sides of these disputes, even if not every position is equally defensible. My point is not that Israelis must abandon their convictions; it is that they must recover the ability to distinguish between an opponent and an enemy.
That requires something largely absent from contemporary political discourse: forgiveness.
Forgiveness does not mean forgetting October 7, excusing leadership failures, or abandoning demands for accountability. It does not mean overlooking injustice or pretending that differences can be resolved through goodwill alone.
A healthy democracy requires vigorous debate, independent institutions, and the willingness to confront uncomfortable truths.
But it also requires recognition that no political faction possesses a monopoly on patriotism, and that a nation cannot remain indefinitely captive to its grievances.
There is an international dimension to this as well.
Israel’s reputation abroad has suffered enormously. Some hostility reflects antisemitism and a refusal to acknowledge Israel’s legitimate security concerns.
But much also reflects genuine distress over Palestinian suffering, the conduct of war, and the apparent absence of a credible path toward peace.
Israel cannot repair its standing through better public relations alone. Its actions, its treatment of minorities, the vitality of its democratic institutions, and its willingness to pursue a less violent future will ultimately speak more loudly than any diplomatic campaign.
Nor can Israel’s internal reconciliation be entirely separated from its relationship with the Palestinians. The obstacles to peace are formidable, and Israelis have every reason to insist that their security be protected.
Yet a country that cannot imagine compromise among its own citizens will find it even harder to imagine a different relationship with its neighbors.
Peace begins, in part, with the capacity to recognize another person’s fears and aspirations without surrendering one’s own.
These questions are at the heart of my new play, The Blue Violinist Over West End Avenue.
Set in the Manhattan apartment of a Jewish family, it follows an argument over Israel that becomes so bitter that a father orders his son and the son’s anti-Zionist girlfriend to leave.
The father believes he is defending the history and survival of the Jewish people. His son believes he is defending the moral principles he inherited from that same history.
Neither can hear the other. Each becomes so determined to protect what he believes that he risks destroying something equally precious.
Eventually, the father receives an unexpected lesson from his ancestors, who appear to him in a dream. They do not ask him to renounce his convictions. They urge him to recognize the harm he has caused, to apologize, and leave the door open.
I have come to think that this is a lesson with implications far beyond the family.
Nations, of course, are not families. Their conflicts require laws, institutions, difficult compromises, and leaders willing to accept responsibility. Forgiveness cannot substitute for justice, and reconciliation cannot be imposed by decree.
But nations, like families, can become prisoners of their own grievances.
Israel has demonstrated time and again that it possesses the strength to defend itself against its enemies.
The challenge now is whether it can find the generosity, courage, and political imagination to repair the relationships within its own society and begin imagining a less hostile future beyond its borders.
A playwright knows that not every conflict can have a happy ending. But the greatest tragedy occurs when the characters have the power to change the ending and cannot bring themselves to do so. Israel still has that power.
The writer is a playwright and documentary filmmaker whose work explores Jewish identity, Holocaust memory, and intergenerational trauma. She is the playwright of The Blue Violinist Over West End Avenue.
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · DEBBIE GOODSTEIN
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira