LONDON — Andy Burnham stood up two months ago and promised a new national conversation on Brexit. The challenges were dawning on him before he even opened his mouth.

Britain’s prime minister — who heads to a long-awaited EU-U.K. summit Friday — has spent much of this week trying to calm a conversation about closer European ties that he started. He told his Labour Party in September that he would begin a public debate on long-term “options” for Britain’s future relationship with the EU around the time of the summit.

The PM and his aides now suggest he will do this in mid-December — if there are viable options at all — in comments widely interpreted as slowing his pace amid hesitation from members of his own Cabinet.

But it’s not the first time Burnham has had to temper his idealism on Europe. His September conference speech originally intended to go even further in his language on Europe, four people familiar with the discussions in Liverpool told POLITICO.

“There were various iterations [of the speech] knocking around with different language, some of which was stronger than what he delivered,” said one U.K. government official, granted anonymity like others quoted in this piece to speak frankly. 

A person who speaks to No. 10 regularly added: “There was a very active debate about how far they should go. If you look back at the speech, the buildup to the Europe bit of it was quite a lot more emphatic than the dividend. A lot of us were sitting there thinking ‘and?’ … ‘and?’ … ‘and?’ … ‘oh.’”

Burnham’s allies insist the substance of his pitch has been consistent: that he will start a conversation on the future that could lead to him making a pitch to British voters in the next general election, due by 2029 — and it might go as far as pledging to rejoin the EU. 

They argue that he has opened a conversation that no one before him dared to. “It has to be open-ended to work,” said a former Cabinet minister. “I am leading on Europe,” Burnham told MPs on Wednesday.

But the sight of the new prime minister adjusting his language in real time has led to suspicions among MPs and ministers that either he is watering down his ambition, figuring out his own position in real time — or both. 

POLITICO spoke to more than 30 politicians, officials and campaigners in the U.K. and Brussels to ask the question: What is Burnham’s grand Brexit strategy? 

Several of them responded by asking back: Does he have one at all?

Options by Christmas

Burnham’s first priority is to get through Friday’s summit, where he hopes to secure long-wrangled deals on food standards, carbon emissions trading and youth mobility, and work toward an assurance that Britain’s industries will not be cut off by Brussels’ Made in Europe scheme.

The trickier question is what happens after that. Burnham said on Tuesday that once he takes stock of the summit, he will “consider whether there are options to further the relationship with the EU” long-term.

The prime minister now intends to present these around the time of his largely domestic “10-year plan” — which is being lined up for publication on Dec. 17, two officials with knowledge of the conversation told POLITICO. It remains a movable feast and his team has not yet decided whether to present Europe options on the same day, or slightly earlier.

Burnham says he has not settled for or against any path, including rejoin, but in practice caution is the dominant theme. He said Tuesday that there is “no rush” and his team sought to stress that he will only press ahead if there is a domestic advantage.

A No. 10 official said: “The thing that’s most important to him is, how can our long-term relationship with the European Union help us with his domestic priorities? Whether that’s the cost of living, reindustrialization or growth in every postcode. He thinks that the best way to do that is in the context of the 10-year plan.” A second U.K. government official added: “It’s about showing something that’s tangible.”

The No. 10 official quoted earlier argued that this shift in position actually happened several weeks ago. Burnham wrote to his Cabinet on Oct. 28 saying merely that he would set out “next steps” on Britain’s EU relationship (rather than full-blown options) around the time of this week’s summit.

Burnham could speak about those “next steps” as soon as next week — “clearly there is an impetus for Andy to say more on this soon,” said the second U.K. government official quoted above — but even for those deep in Whitehall, the way ahead is unclear.

When Burnham does lay out options, officials suggest these may not go into granular detail — despite Westminster and the EU broadly knowing what is at stake after years of painful debate.

One minister in Burnham’s government said they expected him to focus in the near term on making “a pragmatic case” focused on GDP growth, which had a chance of appealing to more skeptical MPs and voters, rather than options per se.

“We’re still trying to get to a point where we know which options that we want to put forward to the British public,” said the second U.K. government official, arguing that whatever deal Burnham secures on Friday will give him the “right to be heard” on the future relationship.

“The big focus from everyone is just to get through the summit,” the official added. “All the questions of where you go after that haven’t fully been answered because we’re not yet there.”

The wrangling is “slightly painful” to watch, said Anand Menon, director of the U.K. in a Changing Europe think tank. “I think with every passing day, I become more skeptical about whether there’s a strategy.”

‘He’s always wanted to rejoin’

Some of this is down to Burnham’s personality. The new prime minister speaks his mind and talks off the cuff far more than his predecessor Keir Starmer.

This was his appeal to many Labour MPs, who see it as old-style leadership, but frustrates some officials who watch policies spring from Burnham’s turns of phrase. “The strategy will be whatever the PM decides when he wakes up in the morning,” grumbled one Labour official in government.

A U.K. official working on the upcoming reset summit said Burnham “makes it up as the questions come to him.” “If you can work out what his plan is, please let me know,” said one anti-rejoin Labour MP: “No one can work out if there’s some 4D chess or they’re just feeling as they go.”

Burnham played down his europhile tendencies in the June election for his seat of Makerfield, which backed Leave in the 2016 referendum. A week before becoming prime minister, he told Labour MPs it was not the time to re-run the Brexit vote. 

He has never hidden his views though. Burnham co-authored an “epilogue to our grandchildren” in his 2024 book “Head North,” which expressed “hope that your generation will take us back into the EU.” 

Like so many things for Burnham, there is a gut feeling. He has privately lamented the plight of musicians who find it harder to go on tour. “He’s got a Dutch wife whose surname is France,” said one campaigner who speaks regularly to the government. One person who has known him a long time added: “He’s always wanted to rejoin in his lifetime.”

The problem is many members of his Cabinet feel differently.

Unlike Burnham, who spent the last decade as mayor of Greater Manchester, most of them bear the scars of Westminster’s Brexit wars.

Burnham held a meeting of his political Cabinet last Tuesday. His aides insist there was not a row, but some of his most powerful Cabinet ministers either have seats that backed Brexit, represent briefs that would be complicated by rejoin chatter or both — and many of their views are already on record.

Those appear to include Chancellor John Healey, Burnham’s top finance minister. Healey said last month that “we had a referendum, we’re out of the EU” and his role was to make the best of the economy.

They also include Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood and Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy, who one ally said previously had a “particular bugbear” about the Erasmus+ student exchange scheme, feeling that it helps few students in her working-class Wigan constituency. (An aide pointed to recent interviews in which Nandy backed the U.K.’s plan to rejoin Erasmus).

Housing Secretary Angela Rayner — a powerful ally of Burnham on the party’s “soft left” — voiced doubts about a second EU referendum when Starmer backed one in 2019, while Health Secretary Yvette Cooper, who represents a Leave-backing Yorkshire seat, argued in July this year that Europe’s future was about Ukraine, Norway and Turkey, not just the EU.

Business and Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds insisted last month that he agreed with the PM after telling POLITICO that re-litigating Brexit battles would cause “uncertainty” for business. Any push to rejoin the EU’s customs union would scupper trade deals, some of which Reynolds personally negotiated. 

His business department is still quietly going about negotiating new trade deals which would be incompatible with rejoining a customs union with the EU. One official pointed out that talks with Turkey are ongoing while initial forays about another trade deal are due to start in the coming weeks. 

One person who speaks regularly to the Cabinet said: “When they were the shadow Cabinet they could finish each other’s sentences. Now they see themselves as shop stewards for their departments.”

Menon added: “I get the sense that there are some members of the Cabinet who really do not want to reopen this debate. That’s the fight that will be going on at the moment — and I don’t know how Burnham plays that, to be honest. We’ve not got much experience of seeing Burnham see off disagreement within his own Cabinet.” 

The first U.K. government official quoted in this piece predicted there would be points in the coming weeks where Burnham “temperature-checks the Cabinet” and “crowd-sources” from fellow ministers. “It’s not a ‘my way or the highway’ approach,” they said. Burnham told reporters last week: “We’ll take a decision as a Cabinet on what, if anything, comes next.”

A senior Labour official predicted that Cabinet ministers would fall in line as they do not want to upset Burnham’s momentum, since Labour is six points ahead of Nigel Farage’s right-wing Reform UK in POLITICO’s Poll of Polls. “People know we have just had a chance to do the most incredible mid-air refuelling job,” the official said.

That doesn’t guarantee that Burnham’s ministers know his mind. One Cabinet minister laughed when asked if they knew the Europe strategy: “They don’t tell me anything!”

EU says: tell us when you’re ready

All this hard thinking sets up a culture clash with the EU, where officials’ view of Britain is “when you’ve got an ask, come and ask,” said Menon.

One EU diplomat told POLITICO: “On the next steps, it should be about the U.K. first assessing its options and then engaging with the EU, rather than the other way around.”

Burnham met European leaders at the European Political Community summit in Dublin last week. The No. 10 official quoted above suggested the PM has told his counterparts he needs to get a good deal at the summit because if not, it will be harder to win over the British public in future talks.

It is a message reminiscent of David Cameron, Theresa May and Boris Johnson before him. Like his predecessors, Burnham is trying to win better treatment from a technocratic Brussels machine — a tough job for Hamish Falconer, the ex-diplomat who once negotiated with the Taliban and is now European relations minister. 

One person who was in a recent meeting with Falconer said: “I sat in a meeting with Hamish where he was saying, I’m pretty sure with geopolitics and my negotiating prowess, the EU will give us a special deal on the single market.” (A U.K. official said they did not recognize this characterization.) The same person said each administration had thought they could forge a better relationship with Brussels than the one that came before, and “I’m worried that Burnham is falling into that same trap.”

An official who worked on Brexit issues under Starmer added: “Politicians always unfortunately have a strong lack of realpolitik in this space. No matter what pathway the U.K. decides to take, the EU will get what it wants.”

Personality plays a part too. When Burnham met European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen on the same day as U.S. President Donald Trump at the U.N. General Assembly, the stark difference in character did not go unnoticed. While British officials respect Von der Leyen’s precise, calm style, Trump’s approach was far more like Burnham’s — conversational, anecdotal and gliding over the hard policy details.

After Burnham’s September speech, confused officials from EU member countries tried to decode his pledge to lay out options “around” the EU-U.K. summit. Some complained privately that the PM should’ve been clearer that the summit was about technical talks that began under Starmer, and talks about the world beyond that could only begin afterwards.

Sandro Gozi, an MEP for French President Emmanuel Macron’s Renaissance party, said he agreed with Burnham that “Brexit has been a disaster,” but added: “I hope that [he] will be bolder and more specific.”

The good news for Burnham is that it is in the EU’s geostrategic interests for new members to want to join. 

An EU official said Brussels would not treat the U.K. like most candidate countries because its past membership means it is still fairly aligned with EU law, and “it is frankly just a more developed country with the rule of law, which some other candidates are not.” Another EU official said: “His willingness to be open about the different options and the trade-offs has been noticed. That hasn’t always been the case in the U.K.”

But the U.K. official working on the summit quoted above said the EU did not need another distraction while eyeing the far-right’s rise in France and Germany. “The EU are at their wits’ end with us,” they said. “Showing up and saying ‘can we once again have something else, but we’re not sure what, for nothing’ is going down like a bucket of cold sick.”

A Brentry referendum?

No. 10 officials stress that Burnham has not made up his mind and his political operation hold their cards close. Much of the work on Brexit is being done by his chief of staff James Purnell — who one long-time associate said backs rejoining the EU in private — and Political Secretary Hayden Munro.

In that vacuum, the focus among many MPs is settling on the most extreme choice in Burnham’s arsenal — reversing Brexit. 

Supporters, including the former Starmer Cabinet ministers David Lammy and Peter Kyle, and the Institute for Public Policy Research think tank that is influential in Labour circles, believe rejoining is the the most viable option to secure much closer ties beyond this point.

Yet despite Burnham’s personal support for rejoining, he has said very little recently about whether he would push for it or how it would happen.

Downing Street officials have not even confirmed if they would make a second referendum a precondition of rejoining, rather than trying to do so based on an election mandate alone — which would outrage anti-EU campaigners. (The No. 10 official quoted above said: “We’re just not going there at the moment.”)

London mayor Sadiq Khan has indicated he would support rejoining based solely on an election mandate. Khan told POLITICO: “I think at the general election, we should have in our manifesto that if you vote Labour and Labour wins, we will rejoin the EU.”

Former Starmer ministers Peter Kyle and David Lammy, by contrast, both said on Wednesday that Burnham should promise a second referendum on rejoining. 

Plenty of Labour MPs in “red wall” seats — Brexit-backing areas of the Midlands and northern England — don’t want to touch the debate at all. Northumberland MP David Smith said the party should “respect the democratic decision” of a decade ago, while Grimsby MP Melanie Onn declared: “I don’t think we should be having another referendum.”

And that’s if Burnham even wants to follow through. The senior Labour official quoted earlier in this story predicted the PM’s enthusiasm for rejoining could wane if Marine Le Pen won the French presidency and pulled the bloc’s axis of power toward the far right. “In private Andy is incredibly passionate but there’s no cunning plan — he is pragmatic,” they said.

Other MPs and think tanks are putting forward alternative options between membership and the status quo, such as a “Swiss-style” deal that has free movement of people — anathema to some Labour MPs — but not membership of the customs union.

Alain Berset, former Swiss president and current secretary general of the Council of Europe said: “Switzerland’s experience shows that you can have a close and constructive relationship … what matters is dialogue, cooperation and finding practical solutions.” 

But the rejoin argument has the most cut-through. Of 2,000 Brits polled by the Labour-friendly Good Growth Foundation think tank, 44% said they believed Labour wants to rejoin the EU. Only 23% of them thought Labour wants a closer relationship without rejoining.

EU officials are making clear it will be “all or nothing,” argued Menon: “We’re going to face a decision, which is we either go single market and customs union membership or we stay where we are. Once you start thinking seriously about Finland, Norway or Switzerland [which all have complex deals without full membership], you realize they’re awful. So the debate very quickly becomes binary between rejoin or stay put.”

Smith disagreed: “Many people around this debate are steeped in law, but politics is also about the art of the possible. The people who tell us we can’t join the EU are often the same people who said we’d never get the deals being negotiated at the summit this week.”

Burnham’s ‘bloc efficiency’

Downing Street has been buoyed by polling that suggests the cost of living — rather than immigration — is now the main priority for many voters, and opposition to Brexit has risen. “If you look at the polling now, it has changed since 2016 and it’s changed in all parts of the U.K.,” Burnham said Wednesday.

That could in turn give Burnham a boost in the next general election — where he is fighting a five- or six-party battle and has only one large viable coalition partner: the pro-EU Liberal Democrats. Several people around Burnham said they believe he is thinking about the Europe debate in terms of electoral politics.

Steve Akehurst, the director of the research firm Persuasion UK, said “bloc efficiency” is a key consideration. “If you need to build a coalition that unites the left, but also can then bring over some soft Tory voters, you quite quickly get to Europe — especially once you assume most of the Labour to Reform vote are not coming back.”

But several people working with No. 10 told POLITICO there is nervousness inside Downing Street about polling that appears to show support for rejoining the EU.

Backing for rejoin “will all hinge on the wording,” said one person running polls. Wary Labour officials have noted that support appears to fall if voters think Britain would use the euro or pay into the EU budget. And they have discussed polling by the research organization More in Common on how support for rejoin falls when the question is about “removing limits on immigration,” rather than “freedom of movement”. 

Akehurst said support for rejoin is “soft” because the idea has high sympathy but low salience. “Most people are just not thinking about this subject right now,” he said. “The basic winning argument against [it] is, ‘can we really be fucked with this?’”

Akehurst added: “The big unknown unknown is, what does it do to the other side’s bloc efficiency? It might fire up the Labour vote and the progressive vote, but does it unite the right against them in red wall seats? Do people suddenly become willing to vote Reform just to stop Labour?”

Reform is raring for a fight; Farage has already called Burnham’s Europe push the “ biggest boost in my career.” It is more difficult for the center-right Conservative Party, which opposes rejoining but sees limited political capital in devoting energy to the debate.

Robert Hayward, a polling analyst and Conservative peer, said party leader Kemi Badenoch “is keen to avoid a prolonged Brexit debate because it risks rejuvenating Reform.” Ironically, given Burnham has restarted the debate, Hayward argued the same argument applies to Labour. “Both legacy parties will adopt a policy of ‘don’t scare the children.’”

The former Conservative aide Oliver Lewis rejoined frontline politics at the weekend to set up a new anti-rejoin group, “Stay Out.” Both he and the government have the same argument: that Burnham wants to tear things up. “People don’t think the status quo is good enough,” argued the No. 10 official quoted earlier. “Stay Out are the status quo campaign.” Lewis accused Burnham of “gaslighting” the British public with ever-shifting positions on Europe.

The Lib Dems have the opposite risk: not appearing europhile enough. The party currently has a “four-stage plan” that places rejoin only in step four. Senior officials believe that Burnham has allowed the conversation to run away from him and it needs careful pacing to win over the public.

But one campaigner who works with the party claimed “I think they will move” to a full-throated rejoin policy. “I think they’re realizing one can’t be half-pregnant. They’re all quite worried they are about to be leapfrogged by Labour.”

Starmer’s No. 10 discussed dropping ‘red lines’

Even senior Labour officials can’t agree over what drives Burnham the most to reopen old wounds on Brexit.

But growth is the reason for closer EU ties that Burnham talks about the most in Downing Street, the No. 10 official quoted earlier in this story argued. The PM has said this week’s deal with the EU could raise U.K. GDP by 0.4%. Last week he told Cabinet ministers that closer ties with the EU were the most impactful lever he could pull to boost growth, the same official said.

The geopolitical context has changed since 2016, too, with a protectionist U.S. and China encroaching on Europe’s turf in areas such as car manufacturing.

Starmer’s No. 10 noticed that too, despite the “red lines” — not rejoining the single market or customs union before the next election — on which he won in 2024.

Two former senior officials in Starmer’s Downing Street said that by the time he left, there were internal conversations about dropping the red lines at the next election.

One of the two ex-officials said: “It was certainly not the working assumption we would have the same red lines going into a subsequent election.” The other said that in the context of global conflict including Iran, “there was a view in No. 10 that we would need a discussion with the public about whether the red lines were still in the right place — and that this would happen pre-election, not as part of the manifesto.”

The seeds of this conversation were in 2025, when Falconer’s predecessor Nick Thomas-Symonds gave a speech pointing to closer European ties — and No. 10 strategists were surprised at the lack of outrage from opposition parties. They believed Westminster’s omerta around Brexit was coming to an end.

Starmer got personally involved and would digest negotiations in person with Thomas-Symonds at the British residence in Brussels, with a whisky in front of an open fire. (“Keir was very adept at lighting the fire,” Thomas-Symonds said.)

This has left a bad taste in the mouth of some former Starmer aides — who believe Burnham has simply put a shiny gloss on the direction of travel that they created, first by rebuilding the basics of the European relationship and then by pushing for “iterative” deals, each year building on the last.

The second ex-Starmer official hailed the appointment of Ben Nunn — a political aide who was once one of Starmer’s closest allies — to Burnham’s No. 10 to work on the EU relationship, arguing it showed a consistent approach across two prime ministers. There is “no change in substance” and “this is a consistency of approach in every form, except for floating rejoin post-election,” they said.

Burnham’s allies, of course, would argue that the mere mention of rejoining shows a huge difference — that Burnham is talking more favorably about the EU than Starmer ever dared.

The question will be whether he follows through on his most radical options; a prospect that plenty in his party still doubt, especially when he will also face Cabinet resistance on other bold prospects such as electoral reform.

One Labour MP compared Burnham’s big pitch to one of the first acts by former Prime Minister Tony Blair. In 1997 Blair asked the Labour grandee Roy Jenkins — a former president of the European Commission, no less — to investigate whether the voting system should be changed. It did not.

One government minister said they doubted that Burnham will even present detailed options for the U.K.-EU relationship before the next election, despite his promise to spell out the choice in December. “It would be such a distraction,” said the minister quoted earlier in this piece. “We’re Perfidious Albion — we’re neither one nor the other, not fully out, not fully in.”

“The logic is to go for membership,” said Menon, “but I think the more the practical problems of that become more apparent, the more if I were prime minister, I would get scared off.”

Menon added: “I genuinely don’t know whether he’s going to follow through.”

Additional reporting from Charlie Cooper, who interviewed Sadiq Khan, and Caroline Hug, who interviewed Alain Berset.

Source: POLITICO Europe · Dan Bloom, Sam Blewett, Esther Webber, Jon Stone

At a glance

Topic
Business
Country
🇧🇪 BE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira