BySARAH BEN-NUNNOVEMBER 19, 2026 17:34

The High Court of Justice on Thursday struck out the prosecution’s petition over restrictions on questioning defense witnesses in Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s criminal trial, finding that a change in the defense’s position had already secured the practical result prosecutors sought.

The decision leaves prosecutors free to cross-examine former attorney-general Avichai Mandelblit and future defense witnesses under an arrangement adopted by the Jerusalem District Court on Wednesday. But it does not settle the broader legal question prosecutors had asked the High Court to decide.

Supreme Court President Isaac Amit and Justices Yael Willner and Khaled Kabub said the dispute raised “a substantial question,” while concluding that this petition was no longer the appropriate setting to resolve it. They canceled Sunday’s hearing and the conditional order issued on Tuesday.

The prosecution had taken the unusual step of challenging an interim decision in an ongoing criminal trial, arguing that the restrictions impaired its ability to establish the facts and could affect other proceedings.

At issue was the November 2 decision limiting prosecutors’ questioning of Mandelblit to re-examination, with the possibility of seeking permission for a different approach on specific points. Netanyahu had called Mandelblit as a defense witness, and the defense’s questioning had effectively proceeded as cross-examination.

Former Israeli Attorney General Avichai Mandelblit arrives to testify in the corruption trial of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at the Jerusalem District Court, November 3, 2026. (credit: YONATAN SINDEL/FLASH90)

The distinction affects how lawyers can test a witness’s account. Cross-examination allows the opposing side to challenge testimony, including through leading questions; re-examination is generally confined to clarifying matters raised during cross-examination.

Prosecutors say they were unable to properly confront Mandelblit

Mandelblit’s testimony has concerned his authorization of the investigations into Netanyahu and the indictment. Prosecutors argued that the restrictions hampered their ability to confront him with documents and address gaps and contradictions concerning events roughly a decade ago.

The dispute also extended beyond Mandelblit. According to the petition, earlier District Court decisions had restricted prosecution questioning of witnesses originally listed by the state but ultimately called by the defense. The reasoning included those witnesses’ identification with the prosecution and a precedent from a civil case.

Mandelblit, however, had not appeared on the prosecution’s witness list - a distinction the state emphasized in arguing that the provision governing unused prosecution witnesses did not apply to him at all.

On Wednesday, defense lawyers withdrew their objection to prosecution cross-examination for practical and procedural reasons, while maintaining their legal arguments.

District Court Judges Rivka Friedman-Feldman, Moshe Bar-Am, and Oded Shaham said they would proceed accordingly for defense witnesses going forward, explicitly including Mandelblit, without changing their earlier decisions concerning witnesses who had already testified.

Prosecutors nevertheless asked the High Court to clarify the law. They argued that the new arrangement rested on agreement rather than a legal determination, and sought clarification that leaving earlier decisions unchanged meant only that witnesses whose questioning had ended would not be recalled. The state had already said it was not seeking to question those witnesses again.

The High Court concluded that the practical relief requested had been achieved.

High Court says 'not self-evident' that civil precedent can be applied

Its discussion nevertheless identified reasons to question the earlier restrictions. The justices pointed to a 2012 judgment in which the view was expressed that prosecutors may cross-examine a witness they had listed but declined to call, once the defense calls that witness.

They also said it was “not self-evident” that the civil precedent could be applied to the issue before them. That question had not yet been clarified in the court’s case law, they wrote.

But the justices expressly stopped short of deciding it, saying it would also be inappropriate to do so when the respondents’ substantive arguments had not been heard before them.

The result closes the High Court proceedings without endorsing or overturning the District Court’s earlier legal reasoning. Prosecution cross-examination will proceed under Wednesday’s arrangement.

Netanyahu’s trial, which began in May 2020, is in its defense stage. He faces charges of fraud and breach of trust in all three cases, and bribery in Case 4000. He denies wrongdoing.

Follow us on Google

Source: The Jerusalem Post · SARAH BEN-NUN

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇱 IL
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira