A French presidential election is still months away, but many of the country’s Jews are already contemplating what they will do if Jean-Luc Mélenchon wins. In a recent survey, 69% of Jewish respondents said that they might leave France in that scenario. Forty percent said they certainly could.
That is not the same as 69% saying they will leave. A hypothetical answer is not a packed suitcase. But it is hard to imagine a more damning assessment of the far Left leader from a community that has been part of France for centuries.
The survey, conducted by IFOP for the American Jewish Committee in partnership with Fondapol, found that 86% of French Jewish respondents believe Mélenchon contributes to rising antisemitism. Whether he agrees with that assessment or not, anyone seeking to lead France ought to be troubled by it.
Mélenchon has denied being antisemitic. Earlier this year, his remarks about the pronunciation of Jeffrey Epstein’s name drew accusations of antisemitism. Days later, he faced criticism over a remark about the name of Jewish politician Raphaël Glucksmann, for which he apologized.
Those incidents alone do not explain the poll. They do, however, illustrate why Mélenchon cannot expect Jewish concerns to disappear simply because he and his supporters reject the accusations.
His allies have questions to answer, too. Some politicians on the Left have challenged Mélenchon over antisemitism, and they deserve to be distinguished from those who have dismissed the issue. Others need to explain how they intend to work with him while reassuring Jewish voters that their safety and place in France are nonnegotiable.
Both political extremes dangerous toward French Jews
A commitment to fighting racism should not depend on who is accused or whether an alliance is electorally convenient. The French Left cannot demand that Jews overlook their fears for the sake of defeating the Right.
That does not make the far Right a safe harbor. The same survey found that 31% of French Jewish respondents could envisage leaving if Marine Le Pen became president.
Her party’s history matters, whatever its current leaders say about Israel and antisemitism. French Jews should not be told to choose which political extreme makes them feel less threatened.
For many, this is about more than politics. Eighty-two percent of Jewish respondents said they had experienced an antisemitic act in their lifetime. Many have altered their behavior since October 7 to avoid drawing attention to their identity.
Consider what that means in practice: parents thinking about what their children can wear to school, or families deciding whether to display a mezuzah. These are choices that should not require a calculation about personal safety.
The survey also found that 79% of Jewish respondents had felt blamed or held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government. French Jews are French citizens, not representatives of Jerusalem. They hold a range of views about Israel, as Jews everywhere do.
Criticism of Israel, even when harsh, is legitimate. Blaming a Jewish neighbor, classmate, or colleague for what Israel does is not. This is antisemitism. Politicians who claim to fight prejudice should be able to say so without qualification.
France has responsibility to give its Jewish citizens a future
France needs more than statements of solidarity after an attack. Schools must protect Jewish pupils. Police and prosecutors must take threats seriously. Parties must challenge antisemitism among their own members and supporters, even when doing so is uncomfortable.
Israel will always welcome French Jews who choose to make aliyah. But their departure is not a substitute for France doing its job. A French Jew should be able to stay, leave, vote, argue, worship, or live secularly without having to weigh those choices against the risk of being Jewish.
The Left has a particular responsibility to confront what this survey says about Mélenchon and his movement. The French Republic has a responsibility to make sure its Jewish citizens have a future in France, whoever occupies the Élysée.
Follow us on GoogleSource: The Jerusalem Post · JPOST EDITORIAL
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇱 IL
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira