ByHERB KEINONNOVEMBER 22, 2026 20:22

Last Wednesday, after Naftali Bennett surprised everyone by meeting for two hours in the Knesset with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the B’Yachad party leader also met with the other heads of the “change bloc.”

At that meeting, Bennett – pushing for some kind of unity government – reportedly warned: “Swearing in a government with Arab parties’ votes would, for the other side, be like Levin’s speech on steroids. You don’t understand the consequences for the country.”

That comment did not get the attention it deserved.

What was Bennett warning about? That if Gadi Eisenkot swears in a government that passes only with the support of the Arab parties, the reaction in the streets could make the judicial reform protests that roiled the country in 2023 look like child’s play.

It’s a warning worth taking seriously.

Protests against the judicial reform at Kaplan Street in Tel Aviv, May 27, 2023. (credit: AVSHALOM SASSONI/MAARIV)

Levin's speech triggers nine months of protests 

Bennett was referring to the press conference Justice Minister Yariv Levin gave on January 4, 2023, just a week after Netanyahu’s government took office. Levin unveiled the first stage of his judicial overhaul plan: giving the coalition greater control over judicial appointments, allowing the Knesset to override some Supreme Court rulings, curbing the court’s use of the reasonableness standard, and changing the status of government legal advisers.

The reaction was furious and fast, triggering nine months of protests and civil disobedience that ended only with the massacre of October 7. Three days after this press conference, more than 10,000 people protested in Tel Aviv, a number that swelled to 80,000 a week later and kept growing.

Opponents of the overhaul package believed the democratic character of Israel as a Jewish democratic state was under attack. To save it, many were prepared to go well beyond weekly demonstrations: blocking highways, disrupting access to the airport, shutting down parts of the country, and, among some reservists, refusing to report for duty. All of this was justified in the name of saving Israel’s democratic soul.

Gantz, Barak, Lapid called for protests 

On January 9, Benny Gantz, then the head of the National Unity party, said: “It’s time to go out en masse and demonstrate; it’s time to make the country tremble.”

That same day, Yesh Atid head Yair Lapid promised: “We will fight in the streets” until Israel returned to being a democratic state. “This is a war over our home,” he said. “It is only beginning.”

And on January 14, former prime minister Ehud Barak said that the government was legal but “completely illegitimate because of its plan to crush Israel’s democracy.” He called on the country’s citizens to take to the streets and even block roads.

Civil disobedience, Barak said, “is the duty of citizens when the government has lost its senses.”

And therein lies the rub.

Who decides when a government has lost its senses?

What looks like madness to one part of the country can look perfectly logical to another. If one side concludes that the danger is so grave that extraordinary measures are justified to stop it, what happens when the shoe is on the other foot? What happens when the other side looks at a government about to take power and reaches the same conclusion?

That is where Bennett’s warning comes into play.

If Eisenkot swears in a government on the strength of Arab parties’ votes, a substantial part of the country will regard it as illegitimate. Not because Arabs are taking part in politics, but because of the positions of some of the MKs in parties on whose votes the government would depend – MKs who reject Israel’s identity as a Jewish state.

If hundreds of thousands were willing to take to the streets to defend Israel’s democratic character, why would anyone assume that hundreds of thousands would not do the same over what they see as a threat to its character as a Jewish state?

The opposition is not to Arabs sitting in the government, but to the anti-Zionist ideology of some of those Arabs who will either be sitting in the government or supporting it from the outside. For instance, if it were Yosef Haddad, No. 2 on Ofer Winter’s party that did not pass the electoral threshold, who was being considered for a cabinet post, and not Mansour Abbas, then the opposition would be marginal and only coming from the far-Right.

So what is Bennett saying? He is not endorsing roadblocks or civil disobedience. Rather, he is saying that going through months of this type of protest again, which he predicts will be even more intense than the judicial reform protests, is something the country can ill afford. His answer: form a government that does not depend on the Arab parties.

What goes around comes around

Another subtext can be extrapolated from his warning, one Israel’s leaders keep forgetting: What goes around comes around.

Likud members who tried to steamroll the judicial overhaul through the Knesset because they had the votes should have understood that one day the other side might have the votes, too. The methods they used would be available to their opponents.

And, voilà, look what is happening now. The change bloc controls the Knesset and is using its majority in a legislative blitz to undo parts of the judicial reform legislation that was enacted, shortening committee hearings along the way. It is acting on the same conviction that animated the other side: We have the votes, so we can steamroll through whatever we want.

The same principle applies beyond the Knesset. Those who considered roadblocks and national disruption legitimate tools against a government they believed threatened the country’s democratic nature cannot assume their opponents will reject those tools when they believe there is a threat to Israel as a Jewish state.

If a government is sworn in with Arab parties’ votes, Bennett is warning, expect streets to be blocked and massive protests to follow. Perhaps there will even be calls from the fringes not to serve. And when one side objects that the protesters are using illegitimate means to demonstrate their point and trying to paralyze the country, it may hear an uncomfortable reply: You did the same when you believed the stakes were this high.

Two things follow. First, Eisenkot needs to consider the consequences of forming a government that depends on the votes of parties whose ranks include MKs who view Zionism as a European colonialist enterprise to be swept away. Second, everyone needs to reckon with the precedent set by the methods they embrace when they believe passionately in a cause.

What you do to the other side today, it may do to you tomorrow. And then on what moral ground can you object?

Follow us on Google

Source: The Jerusalem Post · HERB KEINON

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇱 IL
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira