Nobody is born knowing anything innately about the stock market. And if you feel like you've missed the investing class, you didn't. Usually there isn't one. 

So responsible people who are trying to do the responsible thing by building a portfolio for themselves and their families often find huge gaps in their knowledge and don't know where to turn. 

As the co-founder and CEO of the hedge fund Metropolitan Capital Advisors and a longtime panelist on CNBC's Fast Money, I know that there's no shortage of advice when you're getting started about great investments to buy. It can feel easy and gratifying, especially when your portfolio is doing well. But then things get tougher.

One of the hardest things to do as an investor is to figure out when to sell. You buy a stock because you believe it will go up in value. But the decision to sell is rarely so straightforward. Personally, I've made just about every selling mistake. But over time, I've developed a framework for knowing when to sell — and when not to. 

Why selling is so hard 

Selling decisions are often rooted in emotion and cognitive bias rather than logic. One major culprit: anchoring to past performance, a flawed reference point that clouds clear thinking. 

Behavioral economics, particularly prospect theory, shows that we experience the pain of a loss more intensely than the joy of a gain. This leads investors to cling to losers ("just need to get back to even") and sell winners too early ("lock in the gain"). 

We also place too much emphasis on recent events, a phenomenon known as recency bias. If your last tech stock soared, you're more likely to chase another. If your last trade flopped, you may avoid the market altogether. And when recent trades go well, people tend to trade more — often to their detriment. 

Finally, selling triggers a storm of second-guessing and rationalization. Here are my responses to common excuses: 

  • "What if I'm wrong and it goes up?" What if you're right and it keeps going down? 
  • "What will I do with the cash?" You don't always need to put it to work right away, or you can buy a little more of what you already own. 
  • "If I double down and it rebounds, I'll make it all back." But if it continues to go down from here, your losses will double. 
  • "I don't like having a loss, so I'll sell once it gets back to even." What you originally paid is irrelevant. Yet for many investors, it becomes the most important factor in their decision-making. To assuage their fragile egos, they risk even bigger losses. 

7 smart reasons to sell a stock

These biases and emotional landmines are why you need a clear, disciplined plan for when to sell, including when:

  1. The original thesis no longer holds. If the fundamental reasons you bought the stock are no longer true — if earnings slow, revenue shrinks, margins deteriorate or the company loses market share — it may be time to move on.  
  2. There's a regulatory risk. Legislative changes can dramatically shift a company's prospects. For example, the outlook for solar-related companies can decline dramatically when tax credits are cut for installations. 
  3. Management loses credibility. Frequent earnings misses or misleading guidance suggest deeper problems. One-off surprises happen; recurring surprises reflect poor leadership.
  4. It becomes too big a slice of your portfolio. A stock that grows from 10% to 25% of your portfolio due to the superb performance of its underlying business, which fuels a soaring stock price, increases your risk from a diversification standpoint. Rebalancing is smart and necessary. The maximum I would have in any one position in my own portfolio is 20% — and that's probably too much! 
  5. The stock becomes overvalued. Sometimes the hype drives prices beyond what fundamentals justify. If valuation detaches from reality, it's okay to take some profits. If it really goes nuts, I will sell enough to take my original investment off the table. 
  6. You need the money elsewhere. Selling to fund a home, college tuition or retirement is perfectly valid. Opportunity cost matters. 
  7. You have tax reasons. For example, tax-loss harvesting may allow you to offset capital gains or deduct up to $3,000 of losses against ordinary income.

My golden rule of selling

When you've decided to sell for a solid reason — especially the first, second, or third outlined above — don't hesitate. Don't wait for the perfect price. Just sell. 

When not to sell 

Just as important as knowing when to sell is knowing when not to sell. Avoid emotionally driven decisions that sabotage long-term gains. 

  • Don't sell just because it went up. Great companies like Costco, Apple and Microsoft have rewarded patience for decades. Selling too early can mean missing out on compounding returns. 
  • Don't sell just because it went down. Market pullbacks are often temporary. If the fundamentals are intact and the decline is market driven, it may be a buying opportunity rather than a reason to exit. Trying to time the market rarely ends well. 
  • Don't sell because of scary headlines. Economic fears are often priced in before they fully materialize. The market is forward-looking; headlines usually aren't. Selling during fear often means missing the rebound. 

Selling well is an advanced investing skill that demands discipline, logic and self-awareness, and there's no place for ego. If you create a sound game plan, you'll be equipped to act confidently, even in the face of uncertainty. I keep a list of reasons to sell handy so I can literally look at it and keep my wits about me. 

Karen Finerman is co-founder and CEO of the New York-based hedge fund Metropolitan Capital Advisors and a longtime panelist on CNBC's Fast Money. She is the author of the New York Times bestselling book, "Finerman's Rules: Secrets I'd Only Tell My Daughters About Business and Life" and the host of the podcast How She Does It. Karen is a proud member of the Wharton Board of Advisors, her alma mater, and serves on the board of The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson's Research. 

Source: CNBC · Karen Finerman

At a glance

Topic
Business
Country
🇺🇸 US
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira