Steering and suspension issues are the main reason Teslas are failing warrants of fitness, accounting for almost a third of all failures. But experts say the explanation is more complicated than it may seem.
After receiving 156 complaints alleging suspension failure in Tesla vehicles, the US Department of Transportation opened a preliminary investigation.
Data obtained by First Up from the New Zealand Transport Agency shows steering and suspension is the main reason Teslas failed warrants of fitness.
In comparison, suspension failures for Nissan EVs were eight percent and BYD vehicles had a failure rate of 6 percent.
But Jeff Smit - the founder of the EV & Hybrid Network in Australia, who has a workshop in Sydney specialising in EVs and hybrids - said there was no particular issue with Tesla's suspension when compared to other makes or models.
But he said the data did show that Teslas were not serviced as frequently as others.
On its website, Tesla said it designed every vehicle with the goal of eliminating the need for service.
Nissan and BYD say their vehicles must be serviced every 20,000 kilometers, or every 12 months.
Smit also observed that Tesla drivers tended to drive their vehicles more aggressively.
NZTA data also revealed a difference in warrant of fitness fail rates, depending on whether the inspection is carried out by Tesla itself or by another provider.
Tesla failed 15 percent of its own cars, compared to a 31 percent fail rate by VTNZ.
In a statement, VTNZ said different manufacturers had specific tolerances and requirements for their steering and suspension components.
NZTA said it was aware of Tesla's higher-than average WOF fail rate for steering and suspension, but it did not have concerns over the design of Tesla's steering or suspension systems.
In a statement, head of vehicle regulation Geoff Williamson said the higher-than average WOF failure rate was primarily associated with a well-known suspension wear issue affecting some Teslas and the company had a warranty replacement programme for these cars.
He said NZTA had not received formal complaints specifically relating to Tesla's steering and suspension design, and was monitoring international investigations, recall activity and complaint data to identify issues that may affect the New Zealand fleet and whether any regulatory response is required.
Tesla has not responded to First Up's request for comment.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira