One of the country's most expensive schools can continue to exclude students from activities like cross country races and sports coaching unless they stump up nearly $11,000 for the privilege.
A district court case challenging Whanganui Collegiate's optional fee for day students wanting access to property and services provided by its owner, the Whanganui College Board, but not covered by its integration agreement with the government has been struck out.
The decision at the end of October followed an Ombudsman's investigation that concluded the practice did not appear to be unlawful.
The school did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
The man who brought the court case, Craig Sinclair, told RNZ he worried the two decisions opened the way for other schools to make access to certain facilities and activities contingent on paying a fee.
The school's website said students who purchased access to the non-integrated facilities had access to boarding houses, "prep spaces during the School day, tutor support, pastoral care support from the Health Centre, Housemasters, Residential Masters and Matrons, along with House supervision during timetabled breaks".
"As an Anglican school, it contributes to our faith and chaplaincy. NIFfDS students participate in all Inter-House sport and cultural competitions, co-curricular activities such as the House Swimming, Athletics and Cross Country events, House Music, Tikanga and other School-wide House activities," the site said.
Sinclair contended that the fee should be optional because some of the activities provided via the charge formed part of collegiate's special character and he said took place during regular school time.
He said students who did not pay the fee were excluded from a large part of school life and other integrated schools asked families for a donation to cover similar costs.
"They're operating a school that's half state, half private," he said.
"The ministry at the moment have got an opinion that what Whanganui Collegiate School is offering is a very high-quality, expensive, after-school programme and that is a load of nonsense because the cross-country is during school time, the swimming sports is during school time, quite a few of these things are during school time."
Sinclair told RNZ he was working on an appeal.
He said he was worried the decisions opened the way for other schools to charge high prices for activities that many people would consider standard.
"I can go around New Zealand and educate all the state schools and state integrated schools that you can do it this way and charge parents fees and it will lead to the erosion of section 33 the Education and Training Act where all New Zealanders when they turn five till the 31st of December after their 19th birthday receive a free education," he said.
A long-time campaigner against the high fees and donations charged by some integrated schools, Guy Gifford, made the Ombudsman's complaint.
He told RNZ he was very disappointed by the result.
Gifford said collegiate's practice of charging a fee rather than asking for a donation deprived families of tax credits worth thousands of dollars.
He said regulations were designed to prevent integrated schools offering an environment superior to regular state schools.
"A lot of the individual parents would be happy to pay, they want to pay. They want to contribute to their children's education and get something a bit better than the state provides but the act is designed not to let them - you must operate at the level of a state school," he said.
Association of Proprietors of Integrated Schools chief executive Kevin Shore told RNZ schools of all types had always been able to charge for some services rather than ask for a donation.
Shore said examples included overseas trips and school magazines.
He said schools were finding it increasingly difficult to make ends meet and that could drive more to make optional activities or services contingent on paying a fee rather than a donation.
"Many of our proprietors would not go to that step of withdrawing services from parents for non-payment of a voluntary thing, whatever it might be, but some are," he said.
"I'm not necessarily right at the moment seeing an increase in it but I'm always very aware when I see this there is a potential for increase in it."
Shore said he agreed the cases set a precedent.
"There's no doubt this sets a precedent and it sets a precedent for state schools as well as state integrated schools," he said.
"Will it increase the amount of schools that are doing this? Time will tell, I suppose."
Meanwhile, the Education Ministry said collegiate had fixed a lease that breached education legislation.
RNZ reported in April the school had been paying the Whanganui Collegiate School Foundation for use of a hockey turf, even though integrated schools were not allowed to enter lease arrangements - only their owners were.
The ministry said the school, its proprietor, and the hockey turf owner reached an agreement earlier this year to amend the lease agreement.
"The proprietor has leased the turf for the school's use," it said.
"The lease agreement is now consistent with the school's integration agreement and legal requirements which state it is the role of the school's proprietor to provide property, via purchase or lease, for the school to use."
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira