Many New Zealanders do not understand how relationship property rules apply to de facto relationships, and it can make break-ups complicated and expensive, one legal expert says.
Lauren Milne, JustFund's New Zealand director of family law, said its data showed almost 80 percent of people could not correctly identify when relationship property equal-sharing rules generally applied to de facto couples.
JustFund offers legal loans to help with family law fees, divorce, and relationship property separation.
Under New Zealand law, relationship property is usually evenly shared when a couple has been together three years, but there can be exceptions to that timeframe when there is a child or a partner has made significant contributions.
The law says a relationship is de facto when people are over 18, live together and are not married or in a civil union. But "living together" does not always require that the couple only has one home that they share. The law says to determine whether people are living together as a couple, things that should be taken into account are whether or not a sexual relationship exists, the degree of financial interdependence and support, the ownership and use of property, the degree and commitment of a couple to a shared life, the care and support of children and the performance of household duties, as well as the reputation of the relationship.
JustFund found 43.6 percent of people thought the threshold for the law to take effect was two years not three, and another 20.4 percent were not sure when the rules applied at all.
"A lot of people think it's a two-year rule, some say five years, some say they didn't know it applied at all, of course it doesn't actually even just come down to specific time frames," Milne said.
"There are a number of factors that the courts will look at as well that I think are probably not very widely known in New Zealand."
She said people might not realise that it did not matter who brought property into a relationship when it came to dividing it.
"What we will often see is one party owning a property, the other party moves in and it becomes the family home, and after that three-year period there is this presumption that that then becomes relationship property and there is a 50-50 sharing available. But there are actually a number of factors that a court will look at.
"Living together is a very strong indicator, but living together full-time isn't strictly mandatory to find a de facto relationship. Other factors that the court will look at are whether the parties have an intimate or sexual relationship.
"This doesn't even need to be exclusive. They'll look at financial dependence or interdependence, whether the bank accounts are shared. They will look at whether one party is contributing to the other party's property, care and support of children, household duties, and it's really this overall mutual commitment to a shared life."
JustFund said its data showed almost 80 percent of people could not correctly identify when relationship property equal-sharing rules generally applied to de facto couples.
123RF
She said whether a relationship passed the de facto test would not necessarily come down to any one particular factor.
"It is an overall picture that the courts look at, and that can sometimes make it a little bit tricky for parties to be able to protect their assets or to know when their assets need protecting."
She said the only thing people could do to make sure things happened the way they wanted them to in case of separation was to put together a contracting out agreement, often commonly known as a "prenup".
This would clearly set out both people's expectations and entitlements.
There was no record of how much this happened, she said.
"When this new de facto rule came into being in New Zealand some 20-plus years ago, there was a sort of a flurry of activity of people being concerned, and the advice at that time from a lot of lawyers was you should put your assets into a trust … And that's what a lot of New Zealanders used to do. But there was a recent Supreme Court decision … where the court actually found that the very act of putting your property into a family trust could be seen as you having an intention to defeat your partner's rights under the Relationship Property Act."
She said, since courts had started taking that stance on trusts, contracting out agreements had become more common.
"But if you don't know to go to a lawyer, then you don't necessarily know that that's what you need to do. So yeah, it is quite tricky. And certainly at JustFund, we don't see a huge amount of prenups unless there is a really large asset pool. Most people don't tend to do that because there is obviously a cost involved in going to a lawyer and having that documentation drawn up ... it needs to be certified by an independent lawyer by each side in order for it to be binding. So there is a cost involved, unfortunately, but it really is the only way to do it unless you want to risk things not necessarily going the way that you want them to."
She said when she was a family lawyer, she had dealt with cases where older women had taken on flatmates or boarders who had then claimed a de facto relationship.
"Or for clients who are at the end stage of life and then they pass away and the caregiver brings a claim against the estate and says that that was actually a de facto relationship … it's not always clear. It's not just a case of how long was the relationship. It's was there a relationship at all?"
She said it was important that people knew that even if they were not living together, or sharing bank accounts, relationships could still be found to have existed.
"Overall the best thing you can do is try and document what your intentions are."
The definition of a de facto relationship under the Property Relationships Act is different from that used by the Ministry of Social Development for benefit entitlement purposes.
Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira