An IT expert says a recent streak of software outages shows the risk of essential public services like health putting too many eggs into one basket.
The Public Service Association says hospitals should consider back-up communication systems to be just as important as emergency power generators.
Surprise IT failures have caused chaos around the world in recent days, including a worldwide Microsoft outage, a series of mishaps in the United States, and cyber-attacks impacting hundreds of websites including Zoom and the BBC.
Cogent chief information security officer Tony Grasso said it pointed to an increasingly vulnerable internet.
"I don't think they're related, it's just that we are still very vulnerable in a variety of ways and as we outsource more and more of our computing, we become more and more vulnerable," he said.
Grasso said New Zealand, in particular, relied on providers based in other countries to keep its services running.
"Where New Zealand went wrong is that we went, on premise: servers are bad, because they cost money, and the cloud is good," he said.
"It's true that you outsource, effectively, all of your maintenance and patching and all of the problems that can happen, but then when Microsoft has that problem you've got no way to fix it."
Grasso said his mother-in-law experienced the impacts of the Microsoft outage up-close.
"My mother-in-law was going in for surgery and she can't have that surgery because the email that was coming from the specialist that gives them details wasn't there," he said.
"When you have situations like that, then just relying on email and one provider... You need to find a different way to communicate, even if it's just picking up the damn phone and calling."
Association of Salaried Medical Specialists executive director Sarah Dalton said the outage was a major headache for hospital staff.
"In terms of trying to provide patient care, or do any number of tasks, there would be issues with accessing referrals, lab records, any document that was sent from another hospital or another part of the health system most likely, anything that was email related," she said.
Public Service Association national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons said it wasn't right for New Zealand's health system to be reliant on an overseas company.
"IT systems in hospitals are part of life saving clinical care, they shouldn't be relying solely on Microsoft's systems to operate, particularly for important things like prescriptions, lab results, and information about what's happening in theatre. We need much stronger resilience," she said.
It wasn't the first time New Zealand hospitals had been disrupted by IT issues in 2026.
Another outage in July forced health workers in the Waikato district to use pen and paper, and that came after a similar outage in January impacted hospitals in the upper North Island.
In the same way hospitals had back-up generators for power outages, Fitzsimons said they needed other ways for staff to communicate during IT outages.
"They need to consider much more than electricity generation back-up. Satellite technology and other communication resilience needs to be factored into the equation here," she said.
"The consequences of getting this wrong could result in lives being lost."
Health NZ director of digital operations James Allison said the Microsoft outage caused "minimal disruption" and didn't cause any delays to clinical operations.
"Where email is commonly used to communicate with patients or providers, we used alternative contact methods such as phone calls, fax, or printing of physical forms, to minimise any disruption," he said.
"We are continuing to stabilise and modernise our technology through the Health Digital Investment Plan. The first major investments under the plan have been approved, supporting work to strengthen core digital infrastructure and systems and improve digital services for patient care."
Allison said Health NZ had Starlink and satellite phones set up strategically around the country as emergency backup communications.
He said staff also had access to Whispr, Zoom and other tools in the event that Microsoft Teams or Outlook were unavailable.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- Health
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira