Two wildfires in recent years almost trapped firefighters, forcing them in one case to leave hoses and gear behind as they evacuated, according to internal reports.
In the second case, the firefighters narrowly avoided having their truck engulfed in flames.
"There was an obvious lack of knowledge in vegetation firefighting, wildfire risk assessment and safety approaches," one Fire and Emergency (FENZ) report said.
FENZ has been dealing with a "rapid reduction" in wildfire capabilities over several years, with its top leadership warned about the problem since at least 2023.
At the same time, it has been warning people in recent weeks to "have grab bag and plan to run this summer".
'Dead man zone'
In the first fire - near Middlemarch in early 2024 - the volunteer crew had shifted position to near a pine plantation without telling their commander.
But they moved into the 'dead man zone', an unburnt area directly around a wildfire that is likely to burn within five minutes if the situation changes.
A change of wind sent the fire racing through dry grass towards them about 4am, trapping three firefighters.
"The fire direction changed dramatically, causing a rapid retreat. A priority message was transmitted noting the evacuation, causing confusion.
"Working in the crew's favour was the fact they had burst a length of hose which had wetted the immediate vicinity, saving the appliance from being engulfed," said the April 2025 operational review, released to RNZ under the Official Information Act.
The battle against the blaze near Middlemarch went well overall, as it did at the second vegetation fire at Fernhill in Hawke's Bay in December 2025 - but there were some major issues.
'Drop equipment if necessary'
The wind also changed at the Fernhill fire, sparking multiple warnings to evacuate a hilltop, reflecting "good situational judgement".
Crews were told to "withdraw and drop equipment if necessary".
But several fire trucks were parked up a narrow track with high-pressure hoses snaking round them. They were forced to reverse out.
"Some personnel reported not hearing the evacuation order due to channel congestion," said an operational review from two months ago.
"There were reports of instructions to 'use up water' before withdrawing."
Communications were not great, with patchy compliance and confirmation around the evacuation orders and tactical positioning all created "friction".
It added up to "a near-miss entrapment scenario".
"This represents a significant safety signal and reinforces the need for continued focus on communication capability, structured withdrawal discipline, and operational positioning in high-risk environments."
Working on it
The operational reviews made a series of recommendations to do better, including in training recruits on safety.
Asked by RNZ how it had responded, FENZ gave a short statement saying it got the Fernhill recommendations in September "and is currently working through the process of how to implement them effectively. We are expecting to complete this process by the end of the year".
The wildfire risk is higher than usual for the months ahead. FENZ recently warned people to "have a grab bag and plan to run this summer".
But the agency withheld in full 2024 discussions among teams about what to do about wildfire gaps, on the grounds "staff must be able to contribute openly and honestly to organisational reviews and planning processes, including by identifying issues, risks, and opportunities for improvement, without concern that their comments may subsequently be disclosed publicly".
On Tuesday FENZ axed a restructure that had loomed over crews for a year, and that would have disestablished six specialist wildfire roles.
An email at FENZ headquarters last month referred to a 2023-24 report about erosion of wildfire capability.
"The reduction in our wildfire capability is a serious concern for the future unless remedial actions are taken to address the rapid decline," the report said.
All regional managers were worried and the "issues being raised are fundamental and core". A core one was that there were few ways to recruit experienced people.
'Obvious lack of knowledge'
The Middlemarch fire in March 2024 demonstrated the "obvious lack of knowledge", including around command and control processes for wildfires.
Not only did the crew not alert their commander they were shifting, but broke with training about where they shifted to, into the 'dead man zone'.
"Even though the crew should not have relocated themselves, if they had applied lessons from the recruit course... they would not have chosen this location."
A bunch of recruit and officer training protocols were not followed, notably 'Working Safely at Vegetation Fires', 'Crew Leader', 'Safe Person Concept', 'Lookouts, Awareness and Anchor Points, Communications, Escape Routes and Safety Zones (LACES)' and 'Dynamic Risk Assessment'.
FENZ has put great weight on the 'Safe Person Concept' and 'Dynamic Risk Assessment' in recent statements to RNZ about how its training and approach are good enough.
Monitors squawk - in the cab
In the December 2025 Fernhill fire, crews were also exposed to dangerous levels of smoke, but had left their personal gas monitors in the firetruck cabs.
"Multiple accounts confirm detectors were audibly alarming in truck cabs during peak smoke exposure" due to high carbon monoxide levels.
There was no rule to say personal gas monitors should be worn at vegetation fires, but there was one that said not to use them inside the inner cordon as overload may damage them.
FENZ also lacked a threshold where levels of gas and smoke would trigger withdrawal of fire-fighters.
"While ambulance response and post-incident welfare were strong, real-time exposure monitoring, structured respiratory decision thresholds, and medical reporting integration into command awareness require improvement," said the Fernhill report, completed in July and provided to FENZ managers in September.
A third operational review found problems around the big Tongariro wildfire of November last year.
RNZ revealed FENZ had problems two years ago rolling out personal gas monitors. It did not provide an update as requested about this.
The 2023-24 wildfires report said leadership had to come up with an action plan, figure out where to spend their budget and open up the very restricted channels for recruiting people with wildfire experience.
FENZ has not said if it has done all this and filled the gaps.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira