Ian Robbins was a regular patron at O'Shea's Public House and well known to staff who served him four to five jugs of beer before he switched to rum and colas.
By the time he left the Christchurch pub, the 53-year-old was heavily intoxicated, with witnesses later describing him as slurring his words, staggering, "stumbling drunk and struggling to stand up".
The Shirley Rugby stalwart died later that night after falling to the ground near Burger King.
Associate Coroner Dan Moore has reviewed evidence and ruled Robbins died after landing in a way that placed significant bending on his neck, blocking his airway and blood vessels.
A pathologist told the coroner the injury to Robbins' neck and his heavy intoxication may have prevented him from moving and likely lowered his breathing rate.
A sample of his blood showed an alcohol level of 284mg per 100ml of blood - more than five times the legal blood alcohol limit for a driver aged 20 or older (50mg/100ml).
While Coroner Moore is satisfied there is no need for an inquiry, the Alcohol Regulatory and Licensing Authority has investigated and was critical of the bar and owner - former All White Alan Stroud.
When questioned about Robbins' level of intoxication that night Stroud described him as being okay and only having a "wee bit of a wobble" as he left.
The authority disagreed, saying he was heavily intoxicated and shouldn't have been served.
"Indeed, his shuffling and quite unsteady gait as he made his way along Marshland Road cried out that this was a man who was grossly affected by alcohol."
The authority suspended O'Shea's' on-licence for two weeks on 30 August as a result.
A night of heavy drinking
According to police and Alcohol Regulatory and Licensing Authority evidence, Robbins arrived at O'Shea's between 5pm and 5.30pm and drank beer until about 8pm or 9pm when he switched to rum and cola.
The authority found Robbins left the bar about 9.15pm. It was not known where he went but he later returned to O'Shea's.
The last drinks he was served were likely two double rum and colas at 10.40pm, according to the evidence.
Ian Craig Robbins, 53, died on 22 February, 2025.
NZME
CCTV footage from a nearby liquor store showed Robbins walking along Marshland Road from the direction of O'Shea's at 11.15pm.
Other CCTV footage along Marshland Road captured him along the street to The Palms Shopping Centre about 1km from the bar.
Robbins arrived at the shopping centre just after midnight and withdrew $100 from an ATM.
'Extremely intoxicated'
A cleaner at nearby pub Fox and Ferret was arriving for work and told police Robbins offered him $50 to drive him home.
Robbins became abusive when he refused.
The cleaner said he was familiar with Robbins and knew he usually drank at O'Shea's and would often walk to the Fox and Ferret.
He said Robbins was usually "pretty drunk" on most occasions he had seen him.
He considered Robbins extremely intoxicated that night as he was slurring his words, staggering and at times leaning against a wall.
He watched Robbins stagger across Marshland Road towards a complex that included a Z Station, a Burger King and medical centre.
A motorist who drove into the Z Station about 12.15am saw Robbins walking along the footpath on Marshland Road outside the medical centre and said he appeared to be "stumbling drunk and struggling to stand up".
She watched him try to open the front door of Burger King without success.
As she drove out, Robbins appeared to have fallen asleep standing up.
His head slumped forward and the rest of his body rolled and he hit the concrete headfirst, she said.
It appeared to her that he must have broken his neck.
She had the staff at Burger King call 111 and stayed with Robbins until police arrived.
After she saw Robbins fall, he didn't move and she suspected he had died.
Despite resuscitation attempts by emergency staff, Robbins was pronounced dead at the scene.
Authority 'not impressed' with Stroud
The Alcohol Regulatory and Licensing Authority investigated and after a two-day hearing in April, found O'Shea's had sold Robbins alcohol when he was intoxicated and allowed him to stay at the premises while he was drunk.
According to the July decision, the bar manager said Robbins drank four or five jugs of beer over the initial stages of the evening. It was his habit to drink beer until about 8pm to 9pm and then switch to rum and cola.
The manager believed he served Robbins about four rum and colas and other staff also served him rum and colas.
Robbins funded gambling and drinks at the venue with $550 cash he acquired from the bar.
Former All White and O'Shea's Public House owner Alan Stroud.
NZME
Despite police requests, CCTV footage was never provided by O'Shea's.
Stroud told the authority Robbins was a long-standing regular at the bar for more than 25 years.
He said he was not at the bar after 7pm that night but recalled Robbins arriving just after 5pm.
Stroud said he looked at CCTV footage and noticed Robbins leaving at 10.15pm and observed him saying goodbye to people when he left.
He said Robbins appeared to look "okay".
Judge Robert Spear was critical of Stroud in his decision, saying "the principal of the licensee did not impress us at all".
"We were left with a concern as to his credibility and a serious concern at his respect for the provisions of the Act and his licence.
"Mr Stroud attempted in our view to downplay what was depicted on the various CCTV footage of Mr Robbins making his way along Marshland Road.
"He initially attempted to explain this away as Mr Robbins having a 'wee bit of a wobble' almost as if this was something quite humorous."
Stroud's explanation surprised the authority, as it had no doubt from the CCTV footage, that Robbins had more than a "wee bit of a wobble".
The authority was so concerned by the way Stroud attempted to "downplay or dismiss" the CCTV coverage during the hearing that it stopped the evidence to allow him to take advice from his lawyer.
Given uncertainty over how long Robbins was away from the bar and what he might have done while away, the authority said it wasn't proven to the requisite standard that he was allowed to become intoxicated.
"Although we suspect that this did happen and that the lax systems operating at O'Shea's did not pick this up."
Police argued cancellation of the licence should follow a finding if any alleged breaches were proven.
The authority didn't consider the proven offending warranted cancellation of the licence and instead suspended it for two weeks.
A manager at O'Shea's Public House told NZME neither she nor Stroud wanted to make any comment.
* This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald.
Open Justice
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira