For more than 50 years, Joan Beale housed and cared for her son Phillip - a drug user who never maintained employment long enough to provide for himself.

After years of relying on his mother, and three nights without sleep after a meth binge, Beale turned on the 84-year-old, killing her in a "brutal" attack in the home she shared with him.

His two siblings have spoken in court about the impact Beale's actions have had on their lives.

His sister said it was "unforgivable" that this was how he had "repaid" their mother after all the years she looked after him.

"You are no longer my brother, family or anyone I know. Rest in peace mum," she said, appearing via Audio Visual Link in the High Court at Auckland.

His brother said there were no words for the pain and devastation his mother's murder had caused their family.

Phillip Beale, 51, was on Tuesday sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering his mother in their Papatoetoe, South Auckland home on 7 August last year.

Beale pleaded guilty during his jury trial last month, after arguing that although he killed his mother, he only remembered punching her in the head once and was not legally responsible.

The guilty plea came after the Crown's case and Beale had already given evidence.

On Tuesday, Justice Michael Arthur said he had the "benefit" of hearing all of that trial and described Beale's actions as "brutal" and "callous".

"It was callous because, for more than 50 years, she had housed you, fed you, and provided for you.

"You relied on her benevolence and then killed her in the house that she provided."

The judge said Beale did not stop after the initial blow, or when he realised the danger he was causing and later tried to burn down the house.

"You did not endeavour to help your mother in any way, even after the attack had finished. You took two days to even mention your mother to anyone."

A quiet, kind and caring woman

The judge described Joan Beale as a quiet, kind and caring woman with a group of friends who respected and valued her.

"It is important to also note the immense impact of Mrs Beale's death on her family.

"Not only have her children and wider family lost a loved mother, they have the knowledge that she died in vicious and traumatic circumstances, at the hand of someone she had spent most of her life caring and providing for."

During the trial, Beale said the days leading up to his mother's death were not "unusual", and he had smoked methamphetamine with his friend on the Tuesday, as he often did.

His neighbours, who also gave evidence, told a different story and recalled seeing Beale acting "unusually" before the murder, shouting at no one, taking off his shirt and damaging property.

Beale said at the trial that he was feeling "normal" on the day of the murder but this contrasted to what he had told psychiatrist Dr Ian Goodwin - he had been bingeing methamphetamine, staying up for three days.

On 7 August Beale tried to get more of the drug, but failed.

What Beale had done, however, was use his mother's card to withdraw $600. It was "unclear" whether he had been given permission to do so, the judge said.

Between just after 8pm and 9pm that night, Beale inflicted "serious injuries" on his mother, causing her death.

During the trial, Beale could not explain why he had hit his mother but told Goodwin he thought "the gangs" were going to kill him and his mother was part of it.

Beale conceded in the trial, after being questioned by Crown lawyer Chris Howard, that he must have hit his mother more than once, but he couldn't remember.

Justice Arthur said Beale's claim that he had only hit his mother once to the side of the head, causing her to fall to the ground, was "not at all credible".

The pathologist's evidence showed at least three or four blows to her mouth, head and ear, causing lacerations, bruising and bleeding around the brain that would have caused her death.

Blood found on a 1.1kg porcelain rabbit nearby was thought to be from Joan Beale and her son, and the judge was "sure" at some point the object had been used during the attack.

'Risk of death'

Despite saying that he never wanted to kill his mother, Beale knew there was a "risk of death" in the assault, the judge said, as he was much larger and stronger than his vulnerable 48kg mother.

Beale also took no steps immediately after to get his mother help, instead pouring petrol on himself and throughout their house.

The judge accepted Beale's claim that he wanted to kill himself, but also the Crown's argument that he wanted to burn the house down, and "incinerate" his mother's body.

Despite later claiming that he only learned of his mother's death when later told by police, Beale knew, when he left the house that night, that he had killed his mother, Justice Arthur said.

Beale tried to jump off a bridge on to train tracks and was apprehended by police who admitted him to hospital under the Mental Health Act.

It was only two days later, when Beale told hospital staff that he beat his mother "half to death", that a welfare check was done and her battered body was found in her bedroom, half covered by a blanket.

'You took my mother from me'

Beale's sister asked not to be named but described in her victim statement how his actions had impacted her.

"You took my mother from me."

She said she was angry, heartbroken and in complete shock.

Beale had taken advantage of their elderly mother, and after all of the years she looked after him, "this is how you repaid her".

She said she had feared for her mum's safety because of Beale's "lifelong drug addiction".

Joan Beale had overcome two kinds of cancer, without radiation, and after "fighting and surviving all those battles" it was "heartbreaking" that the thing that took her from this world was her own son.

Joan Beale's daughter said she would miss catching up with her mother on the phone.

Joan Beale's daughter said she would miss catching up with her mother on the phone.

NZME

She had seen justice prevail at the recent trial, and she hoped now people knew the truth about the "violent and dangerous" person her brother had shown himself to be.

"My mother deserved better."

A statement written by another of Joan Beale's sons, Ricky Blackmore, was read in court by his daughter.

In the statement, Blackmore said there were no words for the pain and devastation his mother's murder had caused their family.

Blackmore said he had "lost contact" with his mother for several years, which made her death particularly heartbreaking, and the possibility that he would one day reconcile with her had been "taken away".

"We want the court to understand that mum was deeply loved ... she had a place in our family ... [that] can never be filled."

Brutality and callousness

Crown lawyer Sylvie Arnerich considered that the murder showed brutality and callousness, given it was a sustained attack on an elderly, vulnerable woman in her own home.

The judge noted Beale dragged his mother from the living room to her bedroom, before continuing his attack and had used a weapon.

For this, he agreed it was callous, and also because for "more than 50 years" Beale's mother had provided for him.

The judge also acknowledged the "immense impact" Joan Beale's death had on her family, particularly because they had to live with the "traumatic" knowledge of how she died.

Beale's lawyer Tim Blackwell said a minimum period of imprisonment (MPI) of 15 years was appropriate to take into account his client's "methamphetamine psychosis", and for taking responsibility, albeit at the end of the trial.

Blackwell also noted his client's expressions of remorse throughout the trial and in a pre-sentence report.

Justice Arthur reminded Blackwell that because of the law, he was not allowed to take self-induced drug psychosis at the time into account when considering the MPI.

However, Beale's history of addiction and guilty plea could be considered, the judge said.

* This story originally appeared in the New Zealand Herald.

Open Justice

Source: RNZ ยท RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ฟ NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira