Over half the homes in some districts face moderate to high flood risk, new data shows.

However, the analysis suggested the greatest financial threat from flooding might come from areas with lower overall exposure, but a larger number of houses in total.

Property analysis firm Cotality, which released the data, said flood and other climate change-related hazards were already beginning to affect how insurers and lenders were making decisions.

Homeowners and buyers also needed to take that information into account as the risks grew, it said.

The analysis, based on detailed third-party data already used by some banks and insurers, assigned every property in New Zealand a score of zero to five, based on its combined risk from river, coastal and surface flooding.

Two-thirds (66 percent) of homes in Wairoa - which was badly affected during Cyclone Gabrielle - had a score between three and five (the highest risk).

That was followed by Buller (61 percent) and Napier (56 percent), while Gore (50 percent) and Westland (43 percent) also had high levels of exposure.

Earlier this year, AA Insurance said it had temporarily stopped offering new home insurance policies in Westport - in Buller district - because of the town's high flood risk.

However, scale was also important, Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson said.

Although places like Wairoa and Buller had higher concentrations of flood-exposed homes, they were relatively small housing markets.

"We're not downplaying it for those individual homeowners in those areas or potential homebuyers in those areas, but ... the bigger concentrations in terms of scale are Christchurch, Wellington, Auckland."

About 24,000 homes in Christchurch had higher risk scores, followed by 13,900 in Napier, 11,300 in Auckland, and 10,400 in Lower Hutt.

Cotality's findings aligned with previous analysis the Reserve Bank had done, identifying Hawke's Bay, Wellington and Canterbury as areas that should be closely monitored for climate-related flood risk.

Kelvin Davidson

Cotality chief property economist Kelvin Davidson.

SUPPLIED

Earth Sciences New Zealand also released data late last year showing over a third of the country's population was exposed to inland flooding if a major event were to hit their region.

That analysis found buildings worth $235 billion were currently exposed to flood risk, with more than half of that concentrated in Auckland, Wellington and Canterbury.

Despite the latest findings, "we shouldn't necessarily panic about it", Davidson said.

"Lots of parts of the country on these flood assessments are still relatively low risk."

However, insurers were already reacting to rising risks from climate change and banks were also beginning to factor it in, Davidson said.

"We saw [that] last week with Westpac's announcement around starting to look more closely at so-called riskier properties in terms of their lending decisions and the amount of finance they might advance to those types of properties."

Westpac was the first bank to publicly acknowledge doing so, but there could be other banks that were starting to take natural hazard risk into account behind the scenes, he said.

Homeowners and buyers should also be educating themselves on that risk.

"The bottom line for me with all of this is that there's an awareness thing here," he said.

"Any information that we can get out there to help people make the best decision they can around these things is very worthwhile, because we know that it's going to be a bigger issue."

There was evidence that some properties with higher flood risk were selling at a discount, but a wholesale move away from such properties was not happening "to any great degree".

"People are still buying coastal properties, still paying top dollar for that holiday home right by the beach, basically at sea level or by that river," Davidson said.

"It's very hard for people to price that in right now ... there always seems to be that disconnect between what people know is likely to happen in the future and how they really reflect that now."

Any question around government intervention, if houses become uninsurable or unsellable, was "for other people to think about", he said.

However, there was a "fairness question" that needed to be addressed for people who might have bought their home decades before they became aware of any risk.

A report commissioned by the government and published last year concluded that the government could not continue to buy out flood-affected properties at market rates - such as the purchases that occurred in Auckland and Hawke's Bay after Cyclone Gabrielle in 2023.

However, reference group chair Matt Whineray said there would always be a role for the government in alleviating hardship.

Local councils have pushed hard for the government to commit to long-term co-funding for climate adaptation projects.

The incumbent government has previously pointed to its adaptation framework - a set of high-level guiding principles - together with a National Flood Map due to be published early next year, as among the steps it is taking to address the issue.

It has delayed any decisions about how the costs of adaptation will be shared until the next term of government.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira