Oranga Tamariki used a top public relations company to help prepare its chief executive ahead of the damning Tom Phillips inquiry, while also putting her through a mock press conference to rehearse questions about the agency's failings.

Documents released to RNZ under the Official Information Act show the agency's communications team prepared a detailed Q&A plan for chief executive Amanda Malu, anticipating questions including "you clearly failed these children - what is your message to them?" and "has anyone lost their job because of this?".

The correspondence also includes the director of communications and media at Oranga Tamariki (OT) referring to the report as "a big risky thing for us".

They also used award-winning former TV journalist Amanda Millar and her public relations company as part of its response.

The public inquiry into the handling of the Phillips case was released on 15 September.

The inquiry, by Honourable Justice Simon Moore KC, found the harm Phillips caused in isolating the children as well as concerns from maternal whānau were "minimised or overlooked by agencies for significant periods".

It also said that while agencies worked well together at times a more consistent and collaborative interagency approach "could have prevented the children's disappearance and brought them back sooner".

amanda millar

Journalist Amanda Millar.

supplied

On Monday, RNZ obtained more than 100 pages of correspondence in relation to OT's comms planning in relation to the inquiry under the OIA.

The OIA included plans for an hour-long media training session for Malu for 19 August.

The document said it would be the first media training session for Malu ahead of the "anticipated release of the Phillips public inquiry".

"This session will be followed with further media training, which will include Amanda Millar and her team."

Millar is the founder and chief executive of public relations and communications company Amanda Millar & Co. The company's website says she "changes lives".

"She helps even the most reluctant communicators, talk powerfully about themselves and their experiences with confidence and conviction."

The document said the first session was to "test and refine our early messaging ahead of aligning with Amanda Millar and other agencies for potential press conference".

The meeting would include a "mock press conference", with two staff asking questions they expected media would ask of Malu following the release of the report.

"The session will run continuously in a Q and A form, recorded on video…"

A senior solicitor at OT would also be present to "ensure the answers are legally safe".

The video recording would then be played back to review "both messaging and body language".

It's understood the mock press conference did not go ahead during that session.

A day after the training, an email was sent from OT's director communications and media Alison Horwood to Millar and another person whose name is redacted.

Horwood said Malu had indicated she wanted Oranga Tamariki's comms/media team to "align with am&co" for media training in advance of an "upcoming public inquiry…"

Malu had a three-hour session booked with the company for 4 September. Horwood asked whether it would suit to set aside some of that time for media training in relation to "this specific matter".

Millar said she was happy to work with Malu's "needs and priorities".

She said she was keen to have members of OT's comms team involved "as the more angles and voices in the mix, the better for Amanda's preparation".

"I understand the content will be confidential but any background briefing that can be provided ahead of this training would be ideal," Millar said.

A photo of Tom Phillips over a picture released by police of one of the campsites he used.

One of the campsites Tom Phillips used.

RNZ / Supplied / Police

On 21 August, Horwood emailed two OT staff about a comms plan for the Phillips inquiry.

"The Attorney General is expected to table the report on August 31. We are not sure as yet who announces and on what day, but it is a big risky thing for us."

Malu had media training in relation to the Phillips inquiry on 4 September.

In advance of the meeting an email was sent from Horwood which said a cameraman would be in attendance.

The following morning, Horwood sent an email saying that the chief media advisor was no longer able to make it, but that another staffer from the media team would join.

"I understand Amanda Millar needs people to be 'journalists' to test the messaging".

The OIA includes the communications plan for OT in relation to the Phillips inquiry.

The plan includes key messages reacting to the report specifically such as "this report makes for difficult reading" and "I take accountability and it is why I am standing here today".

There are also some "bridging statements" including "I understand", "I totally get it", "I totally understand" and "let me reassure you".

The plan for responding to questions about the children was for Malu to say she appreciated there was "enormous public interest in the wellbeing of the children," but she was not going to talk about them.

"What these children need more than anything is privacy. So, I'm not going to address any questions specifically about them."

In relation to questions about the interaction with the maternal whānau, there were several responses including "as a mum myself, particularly as a mum of girls, I have an enormous empathy for the courage and perseverance shown by the mother and older siblings of the children".

Malu would not discuss individual employment matters.

The plan also includes a Q&A for Oranga Tamariki with nearly 40 questions, two of which are redacted, and planned responses.

The questions include "you clearly failed these children - what is your message to them?", "do you accept the children could have been found sooner if Oranga Tamariki had done its job?" and "why did no one put the children at the centre of their decision making".

In response to the third question, Malu would say: "I don't support the assertion, but I do accept that our practice fell short."

Other questions include: "is it standard practice for Oranga Tamariki to close a report of concern when they haven't sighted children?", "has anyone lost their job because of this" and "is Oranga Tamariki racist?"

The response to the question about whether OT was racist was "I would disagree with that, every single person comes to work at Oranga Tamariki to make the lives of children better".

The Q&A then has a follow-up question: "How can you say that when there was clearly race based discrimination at play against the children's mother?"

The planned response was:

"Over the last three years, through our Practice Framework and practice tools, Oranga Tamariki has shifted towards a stronger focus on whakapapa, identity, belonging and whānau connections, ensuring that decisions for tamariki are grounded in who they are, where they come from, and the relationships that sustain them."

There were also questions regarding whether OT misled the Family Court, and "were the OT workers lazy or is it a system issue?".

"The key issue here is the full picture was not developed or presented to the family court; we didn't accurately represent the wider concerns of the whānau."

Malu was "not going to speak about individual employees".

She was also prepared in case reporters asked about Mustafa Ali. RNZ earlier revealed a series of failings by OT in relation to its handling of the baby before he was killed by his father.

As earlier revealed by RNZ, both cases were managed by the same site for a time, but handled by different social workers.

According to the comms plan, if asked if there was an issue with the site, Malu would say she had read the review regarding Mustafa.

"We have undertaken a review of practice in this case.

"There are questions that have arisen for me as part of this report and I will be seeking answers to those questions."

In the OIA response, OT chief of staff Stephanie Short said Amanda Millar and Co was contracted in to "provide specialised communication training for the chief executive".

"For the Moore Inquiry, Amanda Millar supported Amanda Malu, chief executive, ahead of fronting her first press conference as the Oranga Tamariki chief executive.

"Amanda Millar had no involvement in the development or production of the communications plan or any other messaging."

In relation to the Q&A, Short said that for most organisations it was a "routine part of preparing staff for interview to anticipate what they might be asked, and to gather information to ensure they are well-equipped to answer on the spot".

Short said Amanda Millar and Co was engaged shortly after Malu began her tenure as chief executive.

"Led by CEO Amanda Millar the programme is an ongoing professional development coaching course that focuses on communication and leadership, it is not media specific it is a program that caters especially for new chief executives."

Millar told RNZ Malu had committed to a leadership programme with the company as part of her professional development.

"I am one member of the am&co team who works 1:1 with Amanda on all areas of communication and leadership. The programme does not focus solely on media.

"We started working with Amanda Malu soon after her appointment. We were not contracted specifically to prepare her for the release of the Tom Phillips report."

Millar said the company works with chief executives across all sectors.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira