Documents show some staff at a youth justice facility were too scared to report worrying behaviour such as colleagues engaging in sexual behaviour with teenagers.

The details are contained in a debrief as part of a "reset" staff training plan put in place in September last year to improve standards at Korowai Manaaki at Wiri, in south Auckland.

It said Oranga Tamariki (OT) staff were hesitant about reporting poor practice, often due to fear of being seen as "snitching."

Since then, the ministry says the reset plan has improved safety, culture and workforce stability.

The head of Youth Justice Services for OT says there is a "significant programme of wider work underway in our residences, which is seeing positive results".

Poor practice described in the debrief from last year also included ignoring contraband being brought into the facility and favouritism.

"There was a perception that kaimahi who do raise issues are not adequately supported," the debrief read.

The document also said kaimahi spoke about being sent into a "war zone" with little protection or support from OT when they were hurt.

There was also frustration with the regular changes in senior leadership and increasing wariness about the effectiveness of reset training.

Another training debrief noted a lack of trust in senior leadership was consistently raised, attributed to frequent changes in those leading the site.

"Many kaimahi expressed cynicism that practice resets have been attempted before" without leading to sustained change.

The absence of "visible consequences" for poor practice was highlighted frequently as well.

It comes after RNZ reported a punch-up between a staff member and a young person took place in September - a year after a "reset plan" was undertaken at the facility to lift standards.

Oranga Tamariki told RNZ last year's 12-week Reset Plan at Korowai Manaaki was a standalone project.

"Internal reporting showed it resulted in measurable improvements at the residence, across safety, culture, and workforce stability," Dean Winter, Oranga Tamariki, DCE Youth Justice Services and Residential Care said.

He said there was a "significant programme of wider work underway in our residences, which is seeing positive results".

There was also ongoing training and change programmes underway, which set clear expectations to staff about their procedures, agreements and code of conduct. There were also other initiatives underway that enable universal searches on entry to reduce harmful items.

Karen Chhour

Children's Minister Karen Chhour

RNZ / Samuel Rillstone

As well, OT said their residences have channels in place for kaimahi to speak up with any concerns they might have and for leadership teams to address these.

When asked about the concerns raised in the training debrief, Minister for Children Karen Chhour referred to earlier comments about the improved training programme being an important step towards better practice, "but I acknowledge that it will take time to embed".

"This training is just one part of Oranga Tamariki's efforts to fix long-standing issues stemming from a previous lack of standard operating procedures and adequate training at these facilities.

"I am confident that once these efforts are fully implemented, they will significantly improve the safety of young people and staff."

A report from OT to the Minister in December 2025 had also acknowledged "while some harm is still occurring on site, practice in managing complex dynamics and reducing risk of violence has improved."

It compared performance during the reset period (Sep-Nov 2025) to the previous three months (Jun-Aug 2025), and saw decreases across the number of incidents occurring, contraband seizures, secure care admissions, property claims and grievances.

Labour Ministers are sworn in by the Governor-General in a ceremony at Government House.

Labour's Willow-Jean Prime

RNZ / Angus Dreaver

But Labour's spokesperson for children Willow-Jean Prime, pointing to incidents that had occurred this year, said it was "high time" the minister admitted her reset "hasn't worked and took responsibility for it".

"These are young people with complex needs. They require consistent, therapeutic, rehabilitative care, and Korowai Manaaki needs proper resourcing, professional leadership and the right staff to deliver it."

Prime also called on the minister to explain what's happening with the money, "because it clearly isn't going where it's needed."

In Budget 2025, $40 million was allocated over four years to the professionalisation of the workforce, with the money held in contingency. RNZ is awaiting information on the specific amount spent so far on training.

But Winter told RNZ the professionalisation was operating as a change programme and has allocated a Residential Workforce trainer to each youth justice residence.

"Training as part of this investment programme is still being implemented, and in the meantime other standard training continues as usual."

There was no specific funding attached to the reset, as it was part of business-as-usual operations, Winter added.

Since RNZ's reporting regarding the punch up, OT confirmed the staff member involved at Korowai Manaaki no longer works for the organisation.

A separate incident earlier this year also occurred at Korowai Manaaki, where OT staff were present during the assault of a young person by his peers in a ritual attack known as 'walking the line'.

OT said the employment process regarding that incident "is still ongoing".

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira