One of Fire and Emergency NZ's newest fire trucks is sitting idle at the Palmerston North fire station because of a problem with a roof-mounted monitor, just weeks after it entered service.

Another new fire truck, sent to the city a fortnight ago, was out of action last week when its exhaust fell off - one of several instances of this around the country.

A senior firefighter said having the trucks off the road could affect the response to big blazes, but Fire and Emergency said communities could be assured it would still rush to emergencies when needed.

'The exhaust fell off'

One of the two new MAN type 3 trucks sent to Palmerston North - bought back in 2019 - encountered a problem soon after arriving.

"It's only been on the run - in service - for about a week and half before it was coming back from a fire call and the exhaust fell off in traffic," said NZ Professional Firefighters Union Palmerston North branch president, senior station officer Tony Sealey.

"The truck that it replaced was meant to be going to Tauranga and they're now having to wait because we had to steal the exhaust of that MAN truck to keep this one on the run."

Sealey said the truck was out of action for half a day. A Fire and Emergency spokesperson said it was 90 minutes.

The spokesperson confirmed the same problem had happened in Wellington and Whanganui.

Sealey said the cause of the fault, which happened in a "small number" of the trucks, wasn't known.

"It's not being addressed. If this happens on an Auckland motorway or something like that, and an exhaust comes off at 100kmh, something bad might happen.

"We were just lucky it happened to be at 30kmh an hour coming back from a fire call, not going to it."

While that truck was back in operation, the other new one sent to the city, based at the Milson station, was not, due to an electrical fault in a monitor.

It was now sitting idle in the Palmerston North station.

"This one has been off the run now twice with separate issues, but this is the latest one, where the monitor is failing to work due to an electrical fault," Sealey said.

He wasn't sure how long that would take to fix. Mechanics were seeing if they could solve the problem with the wiring.

The Fire and Emergency spokesperson confirmed this.

"We are investigating the cause of these incidents and, as a precaution, are inspecting the other Angloco MAN type 3 appliances in the fleet."

Tony Searley says having one of the new trucks out of action could affect the response to large blazes.

Tony Searley says having one of the new trucks out of action could affect the response to large blazes.

RNZ/Jimmy Ellingham

Fault affects responses - senior firefighter

Sealey feared losing one of Palmerston North's trucks could have a negative impact on the response to a large fire.

"We need to call back staff to assist in the larger-scale jobs. We now don't have a truck for them to ride, so we'll be calling in volunteers from out of district," he said.

"We won't have the resources on the fire ground to do, realistically, what we need to do, and in time.

"Where we would probably have extra resources within about 15-20 minutes, we're probably looking more at about half an hour to have the resources that we need, which when fire doubles in size every 30 seconds is a big deal."

The Fire and Emergency spokesperson said it had one of the largest fleets of commercial vehicles in New Zealand, about 1300 fire trucks and specialist response vehicles.

"We maintain the fleet to a high standard and service them regularly. These are large and complex appliances, and they are expected to have mechanical issues from time to time.

"We have a relief fleet to support such events and ensure there is no reduction in current response capability for the community," the spokesperson said.

"During incidents, our dispatching procedures enable us to call out the next available truck if the nearest truck is attending another call or is unavailable for any other reason, like scheduled maintenance or repair work.

"Communities can be assured Fire and Emergency will respond to emergencies when needed with the right resources."

Sealey, a firefighter of 23 years, said he had seen problems with vehicles being off the road and fleets not being upgraded for about 15 years.

MP concerned by problems

Fire and Emergency has faced heavy criticism over the purchase of the MAN type 3 trucks in 2019, as well as how long it's taken to roll them out.

RNZ has also previously reported they had problems fitting the essential lifesaving gear they need to carry.

National MP Tim Costley has questioned Fire and Emergency's top brass at select committee hearings and he wasn't surprised to hear about the latest problems.

"The high-pressure delivery unit we've known about for some time. I think part of this seems to come down to issues during the build, it comes down to a lack of specification during the design phase, and a lack of understanding in terms of the logic behind it."

It was good to see some of the MAN type 3 trucks in action, although the faults were concerning.

"Anything that goes wrong on a truck is a concern to me. I want our firefighters to be able to support our community and have the best possible support available.

"The issues that we're seeing really just point to the deeper issues that we've already identified that we know that we need to fix."

Costley said he looked forward to doing that should, as expected, National form part of a coalition government after special votes were counted.

Sealey would also like to see a fix.

"That is the frustrating thing for all the career firefighters. We just want to be able to turn up and do our jobs and have reliable equipment to help everyone that we need to help."

Fire and Emergency spent millions of dollars shipping 28 MAN type 3 trucks to Britain for their fitouts. Their total cost, including this, was $28.36 million, according to figures released under the Official Information Act.

This week Fire and Emergency announced it wouldn't go ahead with a planned restructure, while the union withdrew planned strike action.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira