New Zealand's publicly funded tertiary institutions have spent more than $9 million on employment settlements and student confidentiality agreements since 2016.

Official Information Act responses from 22 tertiary institutions show at least 811 employment settlements were signed with employees, and 35 with students.

How many employment settlements/confidentiality agreements were signed with staff?

RNZ requested data from 23 tertiary institutions including universities, polytechnics, and wฤnanga. In response, 11 institutions provided the data in full for 10.5 years, 11 others provided partial data ranging from 1.5 to 8.5 years, saying earlier data was not available. The University of Waikato refused the request, citing substantial research. The annual average is used for comparability.

Chief Victims Advisor Ruth Money was concerned about the record-keeping. "I think it is remiss and negligent not to collate and keep a database of all of these settlements so that you can see patterns of repeated or systemic misconduct."

University of Otago

The University of Otago signed the highest number of settlements at 27.7 agreements per year, or 180 over six and a half years.

The university said the agreements related to a wide range of circumstances, and not all had confidentiality provisions. "They should not be assumed to relate to misconduct, disciplinary matters, complaints or any other single category of employment issue."

Clock tower building on campus

RNZ / Nate McKinnon

An Employment Relations Authority determination documented two records of settlements between a former employee and the University of Otago. One contained non-disparagement clauses.

Otago University said while it did not comment on individual employment matters, it stood by the professionalism of its human resources staff.

Victoria University of Wellington signed 23 non-disclosure agreements over the last year and half, saying earlier data was not retrievable.

The university said there had been periods of organisational change, and negotiations of exit packages were not unexpected.

Organisational changes over the past decade make it difficult to compare settlement volume by staffing levels.

However, when adjusted for staff numbers, New Zealand Institute of Skills and Technology (NZIST) recorded the highest number of settlements per year, followed by Waikato Institute of Technology (Wintec).

The University of Otago, which ranked first based on its annual average number of settlements, fell to 14th when its nearly 9000 staff were taken into account.

NZIST said its staff numbers fell from nearly 8000 in December last year to about 800 in July, following multiple business division transitions.

Wintec said the figures reflected significant organisational changes across the tertiary sector over the past decade. It said that, since becoming an independent institute, it had reviewed its core policies relating to settlement practices.

Do you know more? Get in touch with kexin.li@rnz.co.nz

How many confidentiality agreements were signed with students?

Eight organisations said they had signed confidentiality agreements with students.

Otago Polytechnic had offered 10 agreements since 2016, and one other that was not accepted. Three had special payments valued at $3000, $17,500 and $12,000.

The polytechnic said the agreements related to complaints about programme delivery, advice provided, or where the organisation may not have followed correct process or breached legislative requirements.

A spokesperson said they followed thorough investigations, and also protected the learner's privacy, as some continued to study at the polytechnic.

Victoria University of Wellington signed nine confidentiality agreements with students over 18 months.

It said if a student was involved in a settlement with the university for any reason, a confidentiality clause may be appropriate. It did not provide details of payments.

'David and Goliath situation'

Chief Victims Advisor Ruth Money was concerned non-disclosure agreements could be used to hide abusive behaviour.

"It's a bit of a David and Goliath situation where one party doesn't have all the legal resources that perhaps the employer does have, and so people are signing things under duress rather than having full agency about the document that they are signing. "

Chief Victims Advisor to government Ruth Money.

Chief Victims Advisor to government Ruth Money.

NZME / Alex Burton

She said it was particularly the case with students who often depended on the institutions for graduation, and had few resources to access appropriate legal advice.

Money would like to see New Zealand follow a UK law change banning higher education institutes signing NDAs on complaints of sexual misconduct, other harassment and bullying.

She said NDAs could prevent workers from reporting harmful behaviour, and this might be "hiding or enabling abusers to continue in their behaviour rather than the pattern being picked up".

Tertiary Education Commission deputy chief executive delivery Gillian Dudgeon said the commission acknowledged the need for all tertiary education organisations to have appropriate policies and processes in place to respond to any allegations of misconduct and prevent behaviour that may cause harm to staff or students.

'Fearful' of taking part in research

Joe Potter, a PhD candidate at Victoria University of Wellington, has been researching workplace bullying within New Zealand's universities.

He said a few people who signed NDAs wanted to participate in his research but did not end up doing so due to fear over their NDA obligations.

"That speaks exactly the point of, or the power of the NDA. That people [were] even too fearful of the backlash of even participating in some research."

Photo is a portrait of a researcher

Joseph (Joe) Potter is researching about workplace bullying in New Zealand's universities.

Supplied

How much did all this cost?

Not all agreements involve payments. While the data is incomplete, it showed 22 institutions spent $9.35 million on settlements and confidentiality clauses with staff.

With payments made to students, it comes to $9.46m.

Te Pลซkenga, the New Zealand Institute of Skills and Technology, spent the most on settlement payments, with $2.6m over seven and a half years.

The organisation is in the process of being disestablished and the figures are from the national office and four remaining institutes.

Te Pลซkenga said the payments reflected the scale of its workforce and the complexity of managing a large organisation through ongoing change.

The Audit Office, which oversees public-sector audits, said the annual audit could include considerations of unusual or non-standard employment payments, whether they had been properly authorised, accounted for, and disclosed.

The office said it had reviewed a sample of payments made by NZIST to employees to ensure they aligned with employment contracts, and was satisfied they did.

Victoria University of Wellington spent $817,944 over a year and half, and Ara Institute of Canterbury $660,280 over 10.5 years.

Victoria University of Wellington argued the annual average payout was "misleading", as settlements were not predictable or routine.

The University of Auckland refused to provide the total sum paid on its 18 NDAs over two years, citing it could be used to benchmark future negotiations. The Ombudsman is investigating the refusal.

The University of Canterbury's response is delayed till 19 November.

How much were these payments?

<div class="flourish-embed flourish-scatter" data-src="visualisation/30780478"><script src=" https://public.flourish.studio/resources/embed.js"></script><noscript><img src=" https://public.flourish.studio/visualisation/30780478/thumbnail" width="100%" alt="scatter visualization" /></noscript></div>

Of the 23 institutions, eight provided detailed breakdowns of the payments made for each settlement.

Wintec made the highest single sum payment at $83,000, which it said was to a staff member while it operated as part of Te Pลซkenga, and reflected the employee's contractual redundancy entitlements.

Victoria University of Wellington declined to provide individual payments but gave figures showing two were in the range of $60,000 - $89,999.

Why NDAs, settlements, confidentiality clauses exist

Nick McKissack, CEO of Human Resources New Zealand, said confidentiality agreements were an important tool to resolve employment disputes.

Photo shows a portrait of a man

Nick McKissack is the CEO of HRNZ.

Supplied

He said the formal process of resolving disputes through government-supported mediation could be onerous, expensive, and often took a long time.

Private agreements including non-disclosure conditions could be used to resolve all kinds of employment disputes from performance problems to allegations of inappropriate behaviour.

The settlements could benefit both parties, enabling people to agree the employment relationship wasn't working and move on, he said.

"But I do think there are some risks, that they could hide behaviours in the workplace and allow an employer not to properly address negative behaviours ."

Do you know more? Get in touch with kexin.li@rnz.co.nz

Source: RNZ ยท RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ฟ NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira