An independent review has uncovered widespread weaknesses in Selwyn District Council's historic water billing system, estimating almost $3 million may have gone unbilled, while the full financial extent remains unclear.

The PwC report estimated about $2.87m might not have been billed between 1 July 2024 and 31 December 2025. It identified about 1300 properties with missing or incorrect billing records, and about 2200 records where billing started later than it should have.

The review separately identified 809 meters showing water consumption without an associated billing account. PwC could not calculate how much revenue might have been missed because sufficient historic meter readings were unavailable.

Selwyn District Council chief executive Steve Gibling said the report showed where the council fell short.

"We accept what the review found. I'm making putting it right my top priority, and that work has already begun," he said.

"Importantly, if you've had a bill from Selwyn Water, the amount on it is correct. This means everyone is now paying their fair share for the water they use.

"What we've identified is that the connection between our property valuation data, the meter reading data and our systems weren't adequately connected and more importantly they weren't being regularly tested to make sure they're producing consistent results. That's one of the things our team have put in place now to rectify this."

Steve Gibling.

Selwyn District Council chief executive Steve Gibling.

Supplied / Selwyn District Council

The report looked at drinking water charges from 1 July 2024 to 31 December 2025, and wastewater charges over the 18 months to 30 June 2026. The periods reviewed all fell before 1 July 2026, when water services moved to Selwyn Water Limited.

Mayor Lydia Gliddon stressed that no one would be sent a backdated bill.

"The time available to correct any undercharging through the Rating Act has passed. We also don't think it would be fair when the mistakes were in council's own systems," she said.

PwC said where the council decided not to recover historic amounts, it should consider fairness to customers who were correctly charged, "including whether unrecovered historic amounts may ultimately be borne by other current or future customers or ratepayers".

Gliddon said the council did not regard the historic underbilling as a budget shortfall that had to be recovered from other customers or ratepayers, because the revenue had not been included in its budget.

"The first thing to recognise is that this is unbilled revenue, it's unbudgeted, unbilled. They kind of do cancel each other out from us on the Selwyn District Council side of things and is historical. The billing coming out of Selwyn Water is true and accurate now," she said.

In terms of the 809 meters that could not be matched to a billing account and the potential revenue associated with them, Gliddon said the council expected to have a clearer picture before the end of the financial year.

"[Selwyn Water is] quantifying all that information and that's exactly why we asked for a one-year water services strategy so that they could look at quantifying all that information, looking at what the actual revenue take should be before they even work on a 10-year outlook," she said.

Selwyn mayor Lydia Gliddon.

Selwyn mayor Lydia Gliddon.

RNZ / ANNA SAREGNT

The review also found 70 trade waste consent holders could not be linked to current trade waste billing records, while 340 businesses in industries commonly associated with trade waste were not clearly represented in the consent or billing records. PwC could not quantify any potential missing revenue because the required historical information was unavailable.

Gibling said the council had fixed what it considered to be the core systems problem.

"Our team have run a couple of tests already to make sure we have plugged the gap and we have fixed the core problem and the results are coming back really good. That's the sort of reporting we will be providing to council and our water and risk committee on a regular basis," he said.

However, the council said about 115 of the roughly 1300 missing or incorrect billing records remained unresolved as of 16 November, while about 500 restricted-supply properties were still under review. It expected every record and account to be corrected by 1 July 2027.

All 2200 late billing records had been checked and were now included in billing, the council said.

Last month, thousands of people called for the district's pricing system to be reviewed.

An 18 percent water bill hike took effect in July when council-owned organisation Selwyn Water issued its first invoices.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira