The mayor of New Plymouth has found himself out of step with the majority of his councillors over a move to retain voting rights for non-elected committee members.
Council has agreed to ask the Local Government Minister exceptions to changes in the Local Government (System Improvements) Amendment Act 2026 for appointees to its finance, audit and risk, and iwi liaison committees.
Councillors believed the non-elected members had specialist knowledge and should retain voting rights when new rules come into place in March.
But that didn't sit right with Mayor Max Brough.
"Unfortunately, I belong to a generation that believes in democracy and being voted in to do the job," said Brough who was also New Zealand First's local electorate chair.
"Part of the role that we have as elected members is to make the tough calls and be accountable for that.
"I remain committed to democracy. Therefore, I cannot, in good conscience, with my values support non-elected members having voting rights. I'm sorry."
Brough said that did not mean he wouldn't take advice from non-elected committee members.
"That doesn't mean the advice is ignored through that process anywhere. If we truly come to this table with an open heart and an open mind to listen to advice we're receiving, we will get good advice."
Councillors voted 12-3 in favour of sending the letter with veteran councillor Murray Chong - who was last on New Zealand First's list at the general election - and ACT Party aligned councillor Damon Fox joining Brough in voting against the move.
Murray Chong.
RNZ/Robin Martin
The extra ordinary meeting began with a deputation from Puketapu hapū kaumatua Peter Moeahu.
He told councillors having non-elected appointees on iwi liaison committee, Te Huinga Taumatua, was a small concession to Māori in a district upon whose stolen land the region had built its prosperity.
"Te Huinga representatives bring knowledge, experience, whakapapa connections, and perspectives of their whānau, hapū, and iwi.
"Te Huinga provides a structured opportunity for these perspectives to be heard and considered. Their mandate may be different from that of elected councillors, but their contribution can be just as meaningful and legitimate."
Moeahu said the committee was one cog in the democratic wheel and it functioned well.
"As you know, Te Huinga may only recommend options to council. Council may choose to accept, reject, or amend those Recommendations. Therefore, the democratic mandate of the mayor and councillors remains intact.
"Since its establishment almost 10 years ago, iwi reps have voted, and the world has not come to an end."
Peter Moeahu.
RNZ / Robin Martin
A council officer's report noted that council had external appointees on its Finance, Audit and Risk Committee (or its predecessor the Audit and Risk Committee) since 2017 and the current triennium was the first to have an independent chairperson.
"The Office of the Auditor General recommends having an independent chairperson to promote free and frank debate during committee meetings ... and notes that independence on an Audit and Risk Committee 'gives councillors confidence, knowing that they are receiving objective advice and assurance'."
Brough told councillors his view on non-elected members voting rights applied equally to the Finance, Audit and Risk Committee.
Councillor John Woodward saw it differently.
"For me, this is fundamentally about good governance, this is fiscal responsibility, risk mitigation, which is what we're all about.
"I absolutely support it, and with it being to do with Finance, Audit, and Risk, or Te Hiunga Tamatua.
"Being an elected member on council doesn't make us a subject matter expert. So, why would we not bring the subject matter experts in around the table?"
John Woodward.
Supplied
Councillor Damon Fox, however, had the mayor's back.
"I will not be supporting this motion because I believe it strikes at the very foundation of our democracy and the way that our society functions ... I think we sometimes forget just how precious and how fragile that democracy really is."
The deadline for submitting an application for exceptions to the new voting rules was 18 November.
Council officers had drafted a letter expressing the NPDC's desire to seek exceptions for the Finance, Audit, and Risk, or Te Hiunga Tamatua committees ahead of the meeting.
It was forwarded at the conclusion of the meeting.
Councils around the country expected to hear if such applications have been successful in early 2027, if unsuccessful councils would need revise committee arrangements to apply with the law by 19 March 2027.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira