There is little incentive for self-employed New Zealanders to be part of KiwiSaver, and both the Government and KiwiSaver providers could do something to help, the Retirement Commissioner says.
The commission has conducted research that shows lower KiwiSaver participation rates among self-employed people are not because of a lack of motivation, but because of how the system is designed.
There are about 420,000 self-employed people in New Zealand, or about 15 percent of the workforce.
It found that while about half were "persistent non-savers", about 40 percent were saving at least occasionally, often outside KiwiSaver.
The commission's earlier research had shown that only about 44 percent of self-employed people contributed to KiwiSaver. Data from accounting provider Hnry showed self-employed people were contributing 2.6 percent of their income on average, compared with 6.6 percent for employees when employer contributions were counted.
Commissioner David Boyle said there were few incentives for self-employed people to be part of KiwiSaver because they did not have the benefit of employer contributions. The government contribution has reduced to the point that some providers say members no longer feel it is worth contributing for.
But research also showed that there were higher levels of net wealth among some people who were self-employed.
Boyle said the research showed there was no single solution that was likely to help all self-employed people. But he said it was a good time for political parties to work together to help make retirement savings more flexible and easier for those who worked for themselves.
"A common assumption is that self-employed just aren't saving enough. The research shows the picture is more complicated than that. Many are saving and investing in different ways, but they don't benefit from the same support structures that make retirement saving easy for employees."
He said providers had a key role to play. They could integrate savings mechanisms into workflows that currently existed, so that the self-employed could more easily automate savings. They could design products that complemented KiwiSaver rather than modified it. Providers could also recognise that self-employed people were a large, underserved market and that incentives, such as fees, bonuses and bundled benefits, could enhance participation but were insufficient as sole drivers.
Providers would also have to accept that a solution would have to offer financial value to self-employed people, practical flexibility and predictable access rules, as well as autonomy and control.
Retirement Commissioner David Boyle.
Supplied / Retirement Commission
The Government would need to protect confidence in KiwiSaver by keeping the scheme simple, consistent and focused on long-term retirement saving, while enabling complementary solutions.
That would mean supporting innovation, providing regulatory clarity, maintaining credible incentives, ensuring consumer protections kept pace with new products, allowing regulatory settings that let providers develop products which sat alongside KiwiSaver rather than replacing it, and which supported the needs of self-employed people.
Boyle said it was clear from the research that self-employed people were more concerned about locking money away, as KiwiSaver generally requires them to do.
"For many self-employed, having savings they can access at any time to cover business costs or shocks is hugely important. A hybrid approach that combines accessible emergency savings with retirement savings could offer a potential solution," he said.
Retirement Commission research lead Jo Gamble, who carried out the research, said the problem was less about persuading the self-employed to save for retirement and more about creating arrangements that worked with the way they earned, saved and managed risk.
"There's no silver bullet, but platform-embedded retirement saving, combined with accessible savings and open-banking automation could make saving feel as effortless for the self-employed as PAYE does for everyone else," she said.
"Banks, accounting and invoicing platforms, fintechs and KiwiSaver providers could all help make saving easier without forcing everyone into an employee-shaped model."
Boyle said it should be part of a broader approach to the retirement income policy conversation.
He said self-employed New Zealanders were a diverse group that had so far not been sufficiently considered as part of KiwiSaver or other long-term savings options.
Boyle said he had also put a call out to KiwiSaver providers, fund managers and banks to ask what options they could supply and support that would help meet the needs of self-employed New Zealanders.
"We know KiwiSaver is working for who it was designed for, which are those that are earning a reasonable income via PAYE. They're getting an employer contribution and, in some cases, a government contribution. For non-PAYE New Zealanders, the incentive is quite low relative to paid employees."
He said other elements had been identified that would be shared with the industry and politicians to continue the discussion.
"Bringing it as part of the voice that needs to be represented if we're going to look at retirement income policy holistically...it's so important that we do rather than these silos of trying to tinker with KiwiSaver when we know that doesn't quite work for self-employed today. So what could it be? But what other alternatives? And sidecar savings… technology may actually help a lot, you know, and take those barriers of accessibility away that may have been there in the past, to make it easy. That's got to be a good thing."
Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make and spend money
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira