There has been a mixed response from public health specialists to Papua New Guinea's government announcing a policy to encourage a limit on the number of children families have.

Prime Minister James Marape announced this month that [https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/2463213/marape-unveils-no-more-than-three-children-policy-to-manage-png-s-high-birth-rate the government will soon introduce a national

family planning policy] designed to lower PNG's high birth rate by encouraging families to limit childbirth to a maximum of three children.

Marape said the policy intends to curb uncontrolled demographic expansion and reduce economic burdens on households.

A professor of obstetrics and gynaecology, and the head of reproductive health at the University of PNG, Professor Glen Mola, welcomed the government's announcement, while also stressing the need for urgent and thorough action.

"We should have done what the prime minister is proposing a generation ago because now the age structure of our population is such that nothing can cope," he told RNZ Pacific.

PNG's 2024 census put the population at 10.18 million - although some reports estimate it is higher; meanwhile, according to the latest World Bank figures, PNG's birth rate is approximately 2.4 percent annually.

Citing National Statistics Office figures of annual population growth at a rate of 2.6 percent, with 180,000 more people each year, Marape said a huge strain was being placed on public infrastructure, education and health services.

Dr Mola described it as an emergency that had been building for decades.

"Society can't cope. The government can't cope. The health service can't cope. The education systems can't cope. Nothing can cope because 50 percent of our population is under the age of 18. Half of our population are children.

Coastal village of Hanuabada, adjacent to the CDB, in Papua New Guinea's capital Port Moresby.

Coastal village of Hanuabada, adjacent to the CDB, in Papua New Guinea's capital Port Moresby.

RNZ/Johnny Blades

"It really is an emergency, and it's been a developing emergency for the last 30, 40 years. And if we don't do something about it, we're going to be in a much worse state for our grandkids."

Mola said a national consultation on the issue was required, while warning that without an implementation plan, the policy is just words.

He noted that there was a lack of political discourse on it from MPs - "everyone's been quite silent".

"Lots of the politicians have more than one wife. Lots of them have five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten children. So I suppose they find it a bit of a challenge."

"But you have to look to the future," he said, adding that generational change was possible.

Family planning work

A social anthropologist and research fellow at PNG's Institute of Medical Research, Dr Nalisa Neuendorf, said more family planning work was needed first.

"In a country like PNG, I think it is also really important to remember that our different provincial settings also create an opportunity for a mixed approach.

"So, really understanding at a provincial level what can be done might be a better way forward rather than looking this objectively just from a kind of a one size fits all approach."

Given the huge diversity of cultural settings across PNG, it is difficult to pinpoint the social norms around family size in order for it to be tackled as a standard, national issue.

"I think that's something that also needs to be better understood. And that's where more research needs to be done as well," Dr Neuendorf said.

She acknowledged the high unintended pregnancy rate amongst young people," Dr Neuendorf told RNZ Pacific, adding that work was ongoing around adolescent pregnancy and family planning pathways.

"We also are involving young people in the research process to better gauge what is their experience, what do they feel is appropriate for them in terms of family planning pathways, and what is needed for them to then be able to engage and access these pathways, so that they can make informed and autonomous decisions about their own lives.

"There's some really important foundational work I think we need to do first, to then start to consider how this has an impact on future generations."

Destructive

Glen Mola warned that allowing population growth to run rampant could destroy PNG.

"Urban areas are being flooded by mostly young men, which is one of the reasons why there's so much sexual violence," he said.

"And then some rural areas are being denuded of young people because they don't want to just hang around the drudgery of village life and being told what to do by their parents and their uncles and everybody.

"We really are heading in the wrong direction, and so it's a good thing the prime minister has decided that to come out and make a statement."

While national programmes to limit the number of children families could have had mixed success in Asian countries including China and Vietnam, Dr Mola said PNG should look to how Indonesia achieved stabilisation of its population though use of the two-child policy in the 1970s.

"We're certainly in the sort of boat that the Indonesians found themselves in the 70s, and that's what we need to do.

"First of all, there needs to be a national consultation to explain the issue, and then set up our version, the way we should do it in PNG."

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
Health
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira