A complaint over an alleged slap at an Auckland school has raised questions about when teachers are legally allowed to make physical contact with students.
Corporal punishment is banned in New Zealand schools under the Education and Training Act 2020.
However, teachers and other authorised school staff may use physical restraint in limited circumstances to prevent imminent harm to a student or another person.
So where does the law draw the line, and what can parents do if they believe a teacher has gone too far?
Alleged incident
A mother is calling for the immediate suspension of a teacher who allegedly slapped her 7-year-old daughter's hand during a school rehearsal.
The alleged incident occurred on 5 November at Tōtara Point School, a state-funded charter school in Epsom, Auckland.
The mother, Amanda Chang, claimed a teacher slapped her daughter's hand while she was holding another student's hand during the rehearsal.
Chang said her daughter had been afraid to attend the teacher's classes since the alleged incident. She contacted the school immediately and requested an investigation.
According to the school's findings shared with RNZ by Chang, the school concluded the teacher had made physical contact with the two students to separate them while they were holding hands.
However, it described the contact as brief and said it was not intended as discipline or punishment.
The teacher would receive a verbal warning, a record of the incident would be kept on the teacher's file, and the school board had been informed, according to the findings.
The school's leadership team would also work closely with the teacher, who had been asked to complete refresher training on classroom management and physical restraint policies, it said.
Chang disputed the school's findings and had since lodged complaints with the school board, the Teaching Council, New Zealand Police, the Ministry of Education and the Charter School Agency.
She has also called for the teacher's immediate suspension.
"There is a significant difference between gently separating two children's hands and slapping a child's hand with an open palm while visibly angry," Chang said.
The school declined to comment publicly to RNZ, citing the interests of the children involved.
The dispute highlights a broader question about the boundaries of physical contact between teachers and students, and when such contact may cross the line.
Can teachers use force as a form of physical punishment or correction?
The short answer is no.
Section 98 of the Education and Training Act 2020 explicitly prohibits corporal punishment and seclusion in registered schools.
Helen Hurst, group general manager of operational standards and support at the Ministry of Education, said all teachers were expected to maintain professional boundaries and follow the Teaching Council's Code of Professional Responsibility and Standards for the Teaching Profession.
Can teachers make physical contact with students?
Hurst said teachers and other school staff sometimes needed to make physical contact with students as part of ordinary school life, such as careful contact to guide a younger child, helping with an activity, providing comfort to a distressed student or administering first aid.
The ministry considered physical contact appropriate when it was for the student's benefit, the student was willing to be touched and the contact was limited to appropriate areas of the body, generally the shoulders, arms, hands and upper back.
The Education and Training Act 2020 sets strict conditions on the use of physical restraint.
Under Part 3, Subpart 3 of the Act, teachers and authorised staff members may use physical restraint only when necessary to prevent imminent harm to a student's or another person's health, safety or wellbeing, and when they reasonably believe there is no other option available.
Any restraint used must also be reasonable and proportionate to the circumstances.
These provisions apply to schools, including charter schools, while early childhood education services are subject to a separate regulatory framework.
The act also maintains the ban on seclusion.
Sean Teddy, chief executive of Charter School Agency
Supplied
Where can parents make a complaint?
Sean Teddy, chief executive of the Charter School Agency, which oversees charter school contracts, funding and performance monitoring, said any parent who has a concern about their child should complain to the school in the first instance.
"If they are unhappy with the response, they can get in touch with us," Teddy said.
"We will support them to refer their concerns to the appropriate regulator, for example the Teaching Council or the police."
Teddy said charter school sponsors were required to sign legally binding contracts that included a complaints policy with a process for independent review.
Sponsors were also required to comply with all relevant legislation, including the Education Act, which required schools to provide a safe physical and emotional environment for students and staff, he said.
"We regularly monitor charter school sponsors against the requirements of their contract," Teddy said.
"If a sponsor fails to comply, [the] Charter School Authorisation Board will step in."
He said possible actions included requiring a corrective action plan, conducting a special review, replacing the sponsor or terminating its contract to operate the school.
Hurst said schools were responsible for responding to concerns about staff conduct and could refer matters to police, Oranga Tamariki or the Teaching Council where appropriate.
Patrick Walsh, chair of the Teaching Council
Supplied
What does the Teaching Council consider when assessing complaints?
Patrick Walsh, chair of the Teaching Council, said the regulatory body could not comment on individual cases that might be subject to disciplinary proceedings.
He said employers were required to report cases where there was reason to believe a teacher had engaged in serious misconduct.
Parents, families and members of the public could also raise concerns directly with the council, he said.
"Each matter is assessed on the available information and its individual circumstances," Walsh said.
"We work with complainants to ensure that they are kept informed of the process and outcome."
Walsh said the safety and wellbeing of children and young people was paramount, and any allegation that a student had been harmed or made to feel unsafe would be carefully considered.
He said expectations for teachers' behaviour were laid out in the Code of Professional Responsibility and included promoting students' wellbeing and protecting them from harm.
Serious misconduct was also defined under the Education and Training Act and the Teaching Council Rules.
"All matters considered by the Teaching Council and its disciplinary bodies are assessed against both the code and the test for serious misconduct," Walsh said.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira