For more than a decade, Chinese farmer Jun Niu spent periods living at a market garden in Levin performing certain tasks.

Niu claimed he was working, but the owners of the property said they were helping him out by providing shelter, food and, sometimes, money.

The conflicting accounts became the centre of an employment dispute after Niu claimed he had been underpaid by more than $140,000.

The Employment Relations Authority recently found that Niu failed to establish an employment relationship and, as a result, didn't investigate his other claims.

Niu and his advocate have since challenged the decision at the Employment Court, which isn't expected to be heard until next year.

Paid employment claim

Niu, who has spent most of his life in rural China working as a farmer growing vegetable crops, claimed that he was employed by the Levin farm for intermittent periods between 2012 until 2024.

He first came to New Zealand from China to help his daughter, Sunny, and her young child after her husband passed away earlier in 2012.

Not long after, he met Mei Hao Deng Su and Wei Cheng Su, owners of a vegetable market in Levin, and discussed possible farm work.

Niu claimed the terms were made clear to him, including working from 8am to 8pm, sometimes from 9am to 9pm, seven days per week.

He also said the farm would provide food and accommodation and pay of $450 per week paid in cash every Monday.

However, the farm owners denied any employment was ever offered.

Mei Hao Deng Su said she told Niu the farm had enough staff but claimed Niu still wanted to have a look at their farm, which the owners agreed to.

Both parties accepted that Niu's daughter drove him to the farm and left her father there.

Niu claimed that over the years the pay increased slightly each time but that the work was typically six or seven days per week for sometimes 13 or 14 hours per day including on public holidays and during the Covid-19 pandemic.

'Cultural good will'

The farm owners claimed no employment relationship ever existed between the two parties, and Niu was not expected to undertake any work.

They said the relationship between the two parties was "one of cultural good will", according to the authority's ruling.

The owners said the Chinese community typically followed cultural values of support and protecting older individuals.

As Niu was without shelter or support, the farm owners said they took him in as a fellow Chinese national in need in a foreign country and provided him with food, shelter and some money in support of such cultural values.

They also allowed Niu to stay on their farm until his daughter secured him permanent housing.

The farm owners accepted that they gave Niu accommodation, food and, sometimes, money when Niu indicated that he required assistance to buy additional food or sundries but said that "this was a gift of support and not for any work expectations".

All payments were made in cash, and no records of the payments were available from either Niu or the respondents.

The owners said Niu would come and go as he pleased.

He would visit the farm and would sometimes offer help in accordance with their shared cultural values, they said.

Niu came to the farm because "he wanted to and felt comfortable in the rural environment where he would walk around the property, feeding animals and generally observing what the farm was doing", the farm owners said.

In 2023, the farm owner's daughter-in-law, employed by the farm, did ask Niu for help for a few days and Niu was paid informally in cash for about 30 hours, but the farm owners said this was an isolated occurrence.

In early 2024, Niu developed a hernia and required surgery for which he intended to travel to China to undertake and asked the owners for compensation after purported years of heavy work.

Employment claim not upheld

In the decision, ERA member Alyn Higgins said that he wasn't convinced that there was ever any mutual intention between the parties to enter an employment relationship.

Higgins said Niu never responded to an employment vacancy at the farm, and there was no evidence the farm was looking for an employee at the time when they met.

Even if they were, they would have done so through an accounting firm that had been assisting the farm owners with employment matters for more than 20 years.

Niu provided text and voice messages between Su and his daughter as evidence, but Higgins didn't consider that they showed a concluded employment relationship between Niu and the farm owners.

Higgins said Niu also didn't convince him on the level of control by the farm owners that might indicate an employment relationship as he made a number of visits to China.

Niu also didn't provide evidence about instructions being given on how the alleged work must be undertaken, Higgins said.

Higgins also questioned why Niu didn't raise concern during the alleged working relationship if his hernia was a result of alleged heavy work.

There was also no evidence that the business relied in any way on Niu, Higgins said in the decision.

The 30-hour paid work in 2023 was mostly likely to have been a casually agreed engagement and didn't support the overall claim to a long-running employment relationship for the time period claimed, Higgins said.

Higgins also pointed out that Niu never at any time applied for a visa to legally carry out paid employment in New Zealand or even made any such enquires.

Taking all factors into overall consideration, Niu had not persuaded Higgins that he had an employment relationship with the farm owners for the time periods claimed, he said.

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira