A New Zealand climate scientist says many countries are losing faith in the UN's annual climate summits, with the deal at COP31 teetering on collapse.

He said Pacific Island nations were among those who were deeply frustrated with this year's summit, as they face an "existential threat" of 1.5 degrees of global warming.

Fraught negotiations at COP31 in Türkiye have run more than a day over deadline, with international publications reporting a major deadlock overnight.

Talks stalled when a draft of the deal contained no reference to transitioning away from fossil fuels, The Guardian reported.

EU, Pacific Island and African states were pushing for the wording, while Saudi Arabia was among those understood to be pushing against it.

Then, at a late-night session, COP31 presidents Australia and Türkiye announced a new package aimed at achieving consensus.

President Murat Kurum said he believed concerns around fossil fuel wording had been solved, as had those around providing funding developing countries' climate change adaptation programmes.

"I truly remain hopeful, I still believe that we can arrive at some excellent decisions here in this hall, here in Antalya.

A man dressed in a skeleton outfit, next to someone dressed up as a dinosaur, hands over a certificate to climate activist Bianca Ranson during an awards ceremony. A Jurassic Park-themed banner announcing 'Fossil of the Day' is behind them.

Climate activist Bianca Ranson receives the 'Fossil of the Day' award on behalf of New Zealand on the opening day of the COP31 annual climate conference.

Supplied / Climate Action Network International

"The gap between us is narrowing, and the political will required to build a bridge exists right here in this room," he told the BBC.

A third draft of the deal has been sent to delegates in the early hours of the morning.

COP31 had been dubbed the "Implementation COP", with a focus on action for climate change financing and adaptation, Victoria University's Professor of Earth Sciences Tim Naish, who attended the summit as Chair of the World Climate Research Programme, said.

Instead, it had been one of the least productive ever and would be a failure if no deal was reached.

"It was a given that we would continue this so-called roadmap of transitioning away from fossil fuels that people thought wouldn't be controversial.

"What can happen at this COP is, essentially it's a flop, and we don't get any traction on the core goals that were set going into this process."

Naish said even if a deal was reached, he did not expect it to be transformative as the summit had "backslid" on major issues. Meanwhile, the world was getting closer to the Paris Agreement target of 1.5C degrees of warming, he added.

He said Pacific Island nations, who had a very strong voice at COP, were especially frustrated.

Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown addresses leaders at PRECOP31 discussions in Fiji.

Cook Islands Prime Minister Mark Brown addresses leaders at PRECOP31 discussions in Fiji.

Supplied / Cook Islands Office of the Prime Minister

"This is why they are at the COP, 1.5 degrees is existential for them."

One of the world's biggest polluters, the United States, was not there, and climate change was getting less public attention amidst other major geopolitical issues and a general sense the 1.5 degrees target couldn't be reached.

"Bottom line is I think people are losing faith in the process, they are not seeing the process working, but I think the majority would be very loathe to leave it, because it's all we've got at the moment."

Karan Titus, a researcher in renewable energy engineering at the University of Canterbury who also attended COP31, said lack of pathways for climate adaptation finance had been a big weakness in the negotiations up till now.

Titus said he thought carbon capture and storage was being used as a way to solve the fossil fuel wording deadlock, but in his view this technology risked lock-in of fossil fuel projects for many years.

Transitioning away from fossil fuels was the "crucial foundation" to any real climate action, Titus said.

"If it is to be the implementation COP, and these items are not implemented, then I think it will have failed in its mission.

"This is bad, as it follows last year's ICJ ruling that parties must adhere to 1.5, and this year's UNEP report that we are on track to overshoot 1.5."

Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa

At a glance

Topic
Climate
Country
🇳🇿 NZ
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira