Early childhood teachers say children's safety is compromised by confusion about the teacher to child ratios that govern their sector.
They say some early learning services misunderstand the rules and leave groups of children with too few teachers while staff take breaks.
They warned the problem causes stress for teachers and is not safe for children.
The ratios set out the minimum number of adults required for different ages and numbers of children - broadly one teacher to every five under-twos and every 10 children over that age.
Zane McCarthy from teacher union the NZEI Te Riu Roa said teachers often struggled to keep within the ratio.
"I have worked in a centre where we had two teachers in an over-twos environment and 20 children and there was not cover for things such as nappy changes," he said.
"While one teacher was changing nappies the other would have to be basically straddling the door between inside and outside in order to keep an eye on 19 other children."
McCarthy said he was not sure if that way of working was legal, but it was definitely not best-practice or safe.
He said government agencies needed to be clearer.
"From my knowledge there hasn't been clear direction in the legislation on how it actually is put in practice and because of that employers are finding those grey areas and wiggle room and the impact is on tamariki and on staff," he said.
A teacher who spoke to RNZ on condition of anonymity said parents did not understand what happened inside early childhood services once the doors were shut.
She said the working ratio of teachers to children was often not what parents were led to believe.
She said some centres she had worked in included teachers in the ratio calculation even when they were taking a lunch break, and in some centres teachers were required to stay on the premises during their break.
"This is the best centre I have worked in, and I have worked in quite a few, and there still isn't any cover for breaks," she said.
The teacher said the regulations should be much more explicit, but services also needed more funding so they could hire sufficient teachers.
She said teachers should only be counted in ratio when they were able to respond immediately to the children they were responsible for.
The regulations say ratios must be maintained at all times and if staff take breaks, someone else has to step in.
The Education Review Office is responsible for reviewing early learning centres.
It confirmed that adults on breaks or involved in duties away from children were not counted for ratio purposes.
"Adults cannot be counted in ratio while undertaking food preparation or serving, carrying out administrative or maintenance duties, taking a lunch break or rest break, or during non-contact time," it said.
But it told RNZ teachers were counted if they were changing nappies or helping children in the bathroom.
"This takes place in the licensed area, so it is included in ratio considerations," it said.
"The adult-to-child ratio is a minimum requirement that licensed early learning services must meet throughout the time children are present. However, meeting the minimum adult to child ratio does not necessarily mean adequate supervision of all children. Ratio and supervision have to be looked at together to ensure children's safety at all times."
Early years advocate Susan Bates said teachers who left a room to change nappies or perform other duties were not able to respond quickly to help children.
She said they should not be counted in the ratios.
Bates said a survey of 400 teachers in a social media group she ran indicated only 40 percent of services were maintaining ratios at all times.
The rest might have enough teachers under the roof, but in some rooms they were under ratio.
"A lot of teachers believed it wasn't necessary to have one teacher to six children, they could be with 25 children outside for instance, as long as they had enough teachers under the roof so to speak," she said.
"This has left a lot of teachers over the years getting more and more anxious and upset with what they're expected to do."
Bates said it was not fair on the children or the teachers.
"Teachers are distraught basically. They've been telling me for a long time that they just cannot care for children under these circumstances," she said.
"It's getting harder and harder to do, more and more children with more and more behavioural problems under less and less supervision is really putting too much stress on everybody," she said.
Te Rito Maioha Early Childhood New Zealand represents several hundred early education services. General manager Nikki Parsons said the ratios were complex and there was definitely misunderstanding.
She said the rules did allow centres to count the total number of staff and children at a centre rather than room by room but that needed to change.
"If you've got 10 under-two with two staff members, one of them goes to change a nappy, they're leaving one staff member then with nine children so in theory you're meeting the regulatory requirements but you're not meeting quality care for our tamariki at all," she said.
Parson said the ratios were drawn up in 1960 and were well overdue for a review because many more children attended early learning and for more hours.
"When they [the ratios] first came in they were just there for three hours a day, now they're in there for up to 10 hours a day. You have infants and toddlers in there right up to five or six-year-old children. Traditionally it was only three and four-year-olds. They haven't adjusted to the needs of the communities and whanau," she said.
Parsons said there should be a one to four ratio for under-threes, and one to eight for children aged 3-5-years.
"We strongly believe that they need to be reduced and we strongly believe that they need to funded properly because they are not currently," she said.
Source: RNZ · RNZ | Te Reo Irirangi o Aotearoa
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇳🇿 NZ
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira