Dublin GP Dr Naomi Smith knows all about pregnant women suffering severe sickness and vomiting who find themselves being turned away by hospital emergency departments on a technicality.
She was that soldier.
For two pregnancies, Smith suffered with hyperemesis gravidarum (HG), a condition far more serious and debilitating than typical pregnancy sickness. On occasion she found it was no good protesting, “I haven’t been able to keep down water for three days”; if her urine did not pass a ketone test for severity of dehydration, it did not tick the box for hospital admission.
New national clinical guidelines for HG make it clear that using this test to identify dehydration is wrong. Ketones, which indicate the body is using fat for energy instead of glucose, are not a measure of hydration. This detail is contained among 40 new recommendations in revised practice guidelines published by the HSE’s National Women and Infants Health Programme.
“I think the great thing is that there’ll be fewer barriers for patients to get access to treatment, patients who are really unwell,” says Smith, who was involved in the revision process as a patient voice, through her role as a trustee of Hyperemesis Ireland.
“The big thing for me as a GP and as someone who’s gone through it, is that they’ve clearly spelled out that ketones in the urine are not to be looked at as a measure of dehydration. That there’s other ways to look at dehydration, like clinically assessing someone.” Another screening tool is testing urine for specific gravity, which is easily done on a dipstick.
She also welcomes the expansion of medication options, with more data now on their safe use for these patients. In times past, “they just toughed it out – or died.”
When Dr Brian Cleary, pharmacy executive manager at the Rotunda Hospital in Dublin, started his career 25 years ago, there was significant reluctance to prescribe medicines to pregnant women. “It was the assumption that not treating conditions was safer than treating them, which is wrong. It can get very serious.”
Deaths are rare, but they have occurred where women’s vitamin levels have become very depleted due to HG, or the ailment has caused complications in pre-existing conditions such as diabetes or epilepsy.
[ Extreme pregnancy sickness hyperemesis gravidarum: What you need to knowOpens in new window ]
From the patient perspective, the revised guidelines should reassure women that there are safe and effective medicines that can be used to treat severe nausea and vomiting, says Cleary. For the prescriber, they offer up-to-date, evidence-based information around the safety of these medicines in pregnancy, and what order to use them in.
“We have a range of treatment options. It might require some work to find the combination that works for the patient,” he explains. New information on some medicines also enables them to be used earlier in treatment.
“What we want to achieve with the guidelines is to get consistent implementation across all 19 maternity units in the country and in a primary care setting as well.”
Smith says there is also clear guidance on inpatient treatment, use of IV fluids, the linking in with a multidisciplinary team to cover dietetic and mental health aspects, and criteria for discharge. “The quicker you treat people, the fewer complications you are going to end up with for mother and baby, because, by and large, it’s treatable,” she says. The condition affects 1 to 3 per cent of pregnant women, which is about 500 cases a year here, resulting in an estimated 3,000 hospital admissions.
“I think it is the second most common reason for [hospital] admission in pregnancy,” says Smith, who was in and out herself during both her pregnancies, in 2020 and 2021, two or three nights at a time. The first time around, she was so delighted to be pregnant, it took her a while, even as a doctor, to realise the sickness she was experiencing was not normal and that she had lost 5kg.
One of the biggest risks is developing clots, due to chronic dehydration and an inability to get up and move around, she explains. Issues with electrolytes are also common, which is something she struggled with.
“It puts you at a risk of cardiac abnormalities, and I would have been vomiting up blood a lot and had tears in my oesophagus.”
People tend to think, she suggests, that it’s just a bit of nausea and vomiting, as about 80 per cent of women typically experience during early pregnancy. “But it’s different when it’s persistent and intractable. Your poor body can’t cope.”
Caoileann Appleby, chair of Hyperemesis Ireland, who also suffered with HG on both her pregnancies, says “While it’s rare for the individual, it’s not rare for the system.” For her, the number-one improvement these guidelines bring from the patient perspective is more clarity around diagnosis, which no longer requires the loss of a certain percentage of weight. Previously, women would be left for weeks or months without treatment because they had not lost enough weight. This, she suggests, should particularly help GPs, who are the first port of call.
She too is glad to see the ketones fallacy being highlighted. “That happened to me personally as well. You go in, barely produce urine. You’re clearly clinically dehydrated. and then you’re told, ‘Oh no, sorry, the dipstick says no’.
“There’s a lot in there about mental health, which is really important, and something that comes up a lot in our patient support group,” Appleby continues. The sense of isolation if women feel they are not being believed “can be very traumatic for women, especially when it happens repeatedly”.
The patient support charity hopes these new guidelines will help to change the culture around HG by informing midwives, nurses and doctors in all maternity units about standardised, updated practices. Women should not have to contemplate driving for hours to seek better care than what is available locally, she adds.
[ ‘I was induced early because I was so exhausted from vomiting’Opens in new window ]
Even in Dublin, where Smith works in a Palmerstown GP surgery, “we see a real postcode lottery, depending on which hospital you go to. You could get excellent access to day wards and drips; in other hospitals there is none of that.” There is “gold standard” treatment for women with HG at the Iris (IV fluids, Rest, Insight and Support) clinic in the National Maternity Hospital.
Treatment can also vary within a hospital, depending on the individual health staff member you encounter, Smith observes. “Sometimes you just knew you were in a great, safe, pair of hands.”
Other times, not so much.
One midwife asked her how often she had vomited that day. “I said, 30 to 40 times, because it’s non-stop.”
Her response was, “no you haven’t”, and she wrote down four times.
Another time, a nurse in the emergency department reluctantly took her blood pressure, which proved to be extremely low, and she only then conceded, “maybe there’s something going on”.
Yet, after receiving just one bag of IV fluid, Smith was told, “you’ve no ketones, you are good to go”.
‘I just felt like a huge inconvenience, yet there was nothing I could do’
— Emily Carr on her experience of HG
Even with having every advantage going – “I was medical; I was a private patient; I’m local, Irish, and I can speak English” – she struggled at times to get the treatment she needed. This clearer policy should, she adds, help bring improvements for all.
One of the lowest points during Emily Carr’s nine months suffering HG was when a hospital staff member suggested her extreme level of vomiting could be because she did not really want the baby.
“Like I’m causing the sickness – that really upset me.”
She was only six weeks into the pregnancy when she needed the first of 15 hospital admissions for the debilitating effects of the condition. Ultimately, it was only when she returned to her native England that she received the treatment she believes saved her and the baby.
Carr wants to share her experiences to raise awareness of the revised clinical guidelines on HG issued by the HSE’s National Women and Infants Health Programme. While her GP in Co Donegal was “absolutely brilliant” and she appreciates everything hospital staff here tried to do for her, she believes they were working under outdated guidance. The big difference in England was that hospital staff were prepared to try her on more than one medication at once.
“It was that combination, which was like hitting the jackpot. There was still nausea and vomiting there, but it just took the edge off it so I could keep food and water down.”
[ Breda O’Brien: I can’t remember labour but I’ll never forget the vomitingOpens in new window ]
It didn’t help that Carr’s pregnancy came during the first year of the Covid pandemic in 2020, which was extremely challenging for the healthcare service and all using it. She had gone on anti-anxiety medication due to feeling “a bit panicky” about that uncertain time and, during her first hospital admission, was abruptly taken off it.
During the weeks of vomiting that followed, she had to make many trips to Letterkenny Hospital, an hour’s drive from where she and her husband Joshua Bishop live in Dunkineely. On a few occasions she tried, during particularly severe episodes, to be admitted for IV fluids before she reached the stage of vomiting blood, but was turned away because there were no ketones in her urine – the gatekeeping test that is abolished by the new guidelines.
“They wouldn’t accept me until I was at the worst point,” she says. “I was just one of those people that was annoying, I suppose, coming in and out.”
On a ward one night, a nurse, she says, asked her to keep the noise down because her vomiting was disturbing other patients. “I just felt like a huge inconvenience, yet there was nothing I could do.”
At 22 weeks, Carr believed she could take no more. “I phoned my Mum, it was a Thursday night,” she says, becoming emotional at the memory that although she and Joshua wanted the baby, “I said, ‘I want an abortion...’ I could not see how I was going to get through it.”
Her parents came over from England and brought her back to their home in West Midlands. She went into A&E immediately for stabilisation, and it was on a second admission to Walsall Manor Hospital that she was put on three medications.
“They didn’t stop me vomiting, but they stopped me needing to go into hospital.”
She stayed in England until after the birth because the medications were all licensed and free over there, whereas in Ireland they would have been very costly. After all she had been through, Carr says, “I didn’t know how I was going to give birth to [a child] that looked normal.”
But their “miracle baby” Susie arrived safe and sound, although weighing just 4lb 9oz (2.06kg), after being delivered by emergency Caesarean section following induction at 37 weeks.
With their daughter aged five, it is only now that Carr (38) says she has the courage to consider trying for another child. There is the likelihood that she would experience HG again; her sister also had it, which would suggest a genetic predisposition.
However, her increased knowledge and the new guidelines give her more confidence, and she says she would not hesitate to go back to Letterkenny Hospital.
Source: The Irish Times · Sheila Wayman
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira