The great screenwriter William Goldman became aware, long before his death in 2018, that obituaries would lead with a famous quote from his 1983 book Adventures in the Screen Trade.
“Nobody knows anything.”
The maxim applies to every corner of the film business, but it’s most useful when expressing surprise at box-office performance, whether great success or failure. Nothing has better confirmed the wisdom of that assertion than advance sales for Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s hybrid documentary You Can See Everything.
A week before its release in Ireland, David Kelly of the Light House Cinema in Dublin says that the film, a study of the fraudster Elizabeth Holmes, has already broken the venue’s record for sales on an opening weekend.
“Beating Oppenheimer, The Odyssey, all the rest of them,” he says. “It’s just incredible what’s happening with it. For a three-hour documentary as well. We have eight screenings on the Saturday, which initially just had three. It’s going to be wall to wall for the opening weekend. For the opening two weeks, actually.”
Across the Liffey at the Irish Film Institute, the advance bookings are similarly strong.
“Audience anticipation for this film has been phenomenal, with most of our opening-week screenings long sold out,” David O’Mahony says. “From a programmer’s perspective, it’s hugely gratifying to witness such enthusiasm for a three-hour documentary.”
It’s not just that You Can See Everything is a documentary. It’s not just that it lasts three hours. It concerns a true story that had much less penetration here than it did in the United States. The most recognisable face in the picture is that of Fielder, a Canadian satirist whose TV shows come at life from the most oblique of angles.
One more thing. There was next to no public information about the film (though you will find some gossip on X) until a surprise screening at Telluride Film Festival, in Colorado, in early September. A24, the picture’s influential indie distributor, has played this with great skill.
“We were told by A24 that it’s going to be coming out within the next few months – and now it’s outselling Barbie pretty much,” Kelly says.
How on earth did this happen?
Many Irish viewers will know the Elizabeth Holmes story via the Disney+ series The Dropout, which features Amanda Seyfried as the American businesswoman who, with her company Theranos, claimed, somewhat overoptimistically, to have invented a device that could test for a myriad of diseases via only a few drops of blood.
[ The Dropout: Rise and fall of a Silicon Valley darling told with riveting verveOpens in new window ]
A grand jury indicted Holmes and Ramesh (Sunny) Balwani, her professional partner, on fraud charges in June 2018. In 2022 Holmes was convicted of defrauding investors, but she was acquitted of defrauding patients. She was sentenced to a little over 11 years in federal prison.
It was a grand fall. The media initially hailed Holmes, who is from a well-off background, as a heroine for the age. Despite dropping out of college, she was appointed a member of Harvard Medical School’s board of fellows. Time magazine identified her as one of its “100 most influential people” in 2015. Barack Obama, as US president, named her a presidential ambassador for global entrepreneurship.
Little of this appears in Fielder and Oppenheim’s documentary. But the establishment’s eagerness to identify her as an icon is a vital part of the Holmes mythos. If someone presents an attractive face – and talks a good game – the world, without pausing long to consider the supposed achievement, will rush to shower empty accolades on that personality. It happens a lot in the United States. But it is not unknown in Ireland.
While all that was playing out, Fielder, a dry ironist, was working his own way towards inclusion on the Time “most influential” list for 2023. His 2013 show Nathan for You saw him – or a version of him – offer often eccentric advice to individuals and companies.
Those ideas were expanded in the insanely eccentric comedy-doc series The Rehearsal, which premiered on HBO in 2022, and The Curse, a satirical drama from 2023.
There is throughout a sense of Fielder as acutely intelligent debunker. The Curse, starring Emma Stone as a hypocritical faux-philanthropist, revealed his philosophies with particular efficiency.
Oppenheim – whose Primetime, story of the controversial To Catch a Predator TV show, premiered at Venice International Film Festival just a day before You Can See Anything had its Telluride screening – made a name with highly acclaimed documentaries such as Some Kind of Heaven, about the world’s largest retirement community, and Spermworld, on unregulated sperm donation.
Neither film-maker seemed like an obvious contender for Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans, to invite into their San Diego home in the weeks before Holmes turned herself in for her prison term.
On the evidence of the 174 minutes that have made it to the big screen, Fielder, constantly lurking around corners, spent much time chewing away at Holmes’ peculiar relationship with truth. An already famous sequence sees him introduce her to Abbott and Costello’s famous “Who’s on first?” sketch as a way of revealing how thinly she grasps (or pretends to grasp) the slipperiness of language.
Nor did either man seem likely to take everything he was told at face value. The briefest glance at Fielder’s work would confirm his creative scepticism.
Oppenheim believes the project was Holmes’ idea. “She was looking for someone to document her life, and she had reached out to A24. Which I thought was strange for a few reasons,” he told Vanity Fair recently.
In a long interview with Wired, Fielder still seemed puzzled about how the project came to pass.
“Why is she wanting to speak and have her life documented and do it in this way?” he said. “And even after I met her, if I didn’t know what I knew, I would just think I was talking with a very affable, soft-spoken, kind person. But then I kept having this thing where I was tracking my thoughts about how honest she was being, or if I was being manipulated in some way.”
You Can See Anything looks nothing like the average fly-on-the-wall documentary.
“We started with two cameras, and we eventually got to three cameras, and we had one that was on a 12-millimetre-wide lens that could get the whole main area of the house,” Fielder told Wired. “And then we had two other cameras that were on 25- to 250 [millimetre] zoom lenses, so they could go wide, but they could also go really tight.”
What this meant was that he and Oppenheim could deliver a finished version that looked very much like a dramatic feature. We cut from close-up to close-up as the conversations gain an uncomfortable intimacy. The film has a narrative flow that is unusual in this medium. A tight 4:3 aspect ratio heightens the sense of emotional claustrophobia.
Holmes’ contribution is every bit as puzzling as viewers of The Dropout might suspect. (If anything, the real being is weirder than Seyfried’s creation.) But, as the project moves forward, our attention is increasingly taken with the puzzling, domineering contribution from Billy Evans. Early on we see him pluck a bowl from Holmes’ hand as she – ineffectually by his measure – is beating eggs for a meal.
That and other subtle moments hint at where the film might be going in the second half, but few of those at the Telluride screening guessed precisely how oddly You Can See Everything would end up. Though the film went on US theatrical release a month ago, there is still, among publicists, some caution about revealing Fielder’s strategy after Holmes goes to prison. (This article will obligingly tread carefully in that area.)
That secrecy has almost certainly contributed to the pre-release furore. A24, the studio behind such critical hits as Moonlight, Hereditary, The Brutalist and Everything Everywhere All at Once, knows what it’s up to. This writer, then in Venice, 9,000km from Telluride, was one of many blindsided by the news that Oppenheim had a second film ready to screen right after the Lido premiere of Primetime.
That Robert Pattinson project received strong reviews, but by the end of the week You Can See Everything had rendered it “the other Lance Oppenheim film”.
Not only did many not guess what they were about to see at Telluride, but some were unaware that the documentary even existed. This despite the fact the film-makers had begun shooting more than three years earlier.
“I think, firstly, it was a concern on the subjects’ part,” Fielder said of the secrecy. “No one knew where they were at first. But while we were shooting there, paparazzi started surrounding the location and all that. So one of the understandings was, we needed to keep it secret because it could affect things with them, and we didn’t want to do anything where our involvement would be a news story or change things with them.”
At any rate, the result was, in the age of endless media hype, a first screening like no other. We are used to word emerging of, say, the new Martin Scorsese film three years before delivery. Then casting. Then location. Then a first image. Then news of festival debut. By the time the film arrives the waiting world feels as if it has grown old with the project.
The press from Telluride reacted as if they’d been given the biggest birthday surprise. This was news.
“What the f**k did I just watch?” Matt Neglia of the influential awards site Next Best Picture said on X. “One of the best documentaries I’ve ever seen.”
Tomris Laffly at RogerEbert.com did admit that some on the ground had deduced what they were about to watch, but she still remained breathlessly excited. “Like no other film I’ve ever experienced,” she wrote.
It looks as if You Can See Everything is likely – a surprising statistic, this – to become the first documentary to get an Oscar nomination for best picture. Some eccentric prognosticators are even suggesting one acting nomination might come its way, but that seems a bit fanciful.
At any rate, the already phenomenal box-office performance confirms that cultural cinema can still register significant numbers. “It’s fantastic. It proves again that there’s a different kind of audience coming to the cinema,” Clare Binns of the UK Picturehouse Cinemas chain, told The Guardian. “They came to see Backrooms, they came to see Obsession, they came to see Naza.”
In Ireland, David Kelly of the Light House agrees that audiences are keener than ever on catching cinema from outside the mainstream groove.
“It feels like the winds have been blowing that way over the last few years,” he says. “It’s been going that way with younger audiences. They are gravitating towards things that are just fresher, more original.”
A rare good-news story.
You Can See Everything is in cinemas from Friday, November 20th
Source: The Irish Times · Donald Clarke
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira