You Can See Everything

    

Director: Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim

Cert: 15A

Starring: Nathan Fielder, Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans, Amanda Seyfried

Running Time: 2 hrs 54 mins

It’s only a matter of weeks since the world first puzzled over a weird teaser trailer in which a blank-faced man and an apparently zonked-out woman engaged, eyeball to eyeball, with their mutual-trust issues.

“You’re being real right now?” Nathan Fielder, documentarian and satirist, asks. “I’m always being real,” Elizabeth Holmes, convicted fraudster, replies.

The clip is filmed in tense close-ups. The viewers feel they are imposing on intimacy.

This is not how you would launch a superhero franchise, but, bolstered by ecstatic reviews from the United States, You Can See Everything has already become a box-office sensation on this side of the Atlantic.

That clip, short as it is, gives some sense of how the nearly three-hour documentary plays out. In 2023, Fielder, the unknowable Canadian behind TV series such as The Rehearsal and The Curse, found himself recording Holmes’s experiences as, sequestered in a luxurious San Diego beach home, she counted the days before beginning an 11-year prison term.

Once a celebrated figure in US media, Holmes, founder of a company called Theranos, attracted attention when she claimed to have invented a device that could test for a myriad of conditions from a minute sample of blood. It eventually transpired that the unit could not do what she claimed.

Or could it? Significant sections of the film’s opening half find Fielder troubling over one of Holmes’s disputed assertions. She said the device “can” carry out all these tests. Holmes seems to have meant – if I follow her – that the box had the potential to carry out these tests, even if it could not do so at that point.

Get the problem? Holmes seems not to. As a way of illustrating her slippery semantics, Fielder shows her vintage US comic duo Abbott and Costello’s famous “Who’s on first?” sketch. She finds it funny, but she doesn’t seem to understand the central conceit.

Codirected by Lance Oppenheim, who recently gave us the fine Primetime, You Can See Everything looks and sounds like an art-house drama. There are more cuts between close-ups than you get in the average fly-on-the-wall documentary. Ari Balouzian’s excellent score throbs with melodic menace. Fielder is usually part of the conversation, but sometimes he lurks around corners like a guilty eavesdropper.

You Can See Everything is therefore ideal entertainment (if that is the word) for a generation that, baked in decades of online unreliability, looks to have resigned itself to uncertainty. There are similarities between Fielder’s approach and that of Louis Theroux – both hand subjects enough rope – but the Canadian is colder, less connected, more indistinct.

Fielder’s icy strategies are principally directed at figuring out the extent to which Holmes believes herself to have been wrongly convicted. The best argument for her sincerity is, perhaps, her willingness to have this director potter about the family home for day after day. As things work out, however, it is Billy Evans, Holmes’ wealthy romantic partner, who ends up taking over the film-makers’ attention.

[ What is the reason for the enduring public fascination with Elizabeth Holmes?Opens in new window ]

You Can See Everything is very much a film of two halves. When the subject enters prison, Fielder and Oppenheim find themselves at a loss about how to continue covering the story. Their solution, which we shan’t spoil, drags the film into self-conscious play that has already aggrieved one or two documentary purists.

Still, if Joshua Oppenheimer’s (quite different) The Act of Killing remained within the genre, then so does this eerie, ingenious, ultimately unrevealing oddity. It is certainly an indulgence. The film is as much about Fielder as it is about Holmes. Oppenheim’s alienating aesthetic bullies much life out of the early sections in San Diego. But You Can See Everything remains an undeniable signifier of the era. None more 2026.

In cinemas from Friday, November 20th

Source: The Irish Times · Donald Clarke

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira