A review has found that a teenager died in a suspected suicide, shortly after the child and family agency Tusla deemed that no further action was required in the case.
The National Review Panel (NRP) examined the circumstances surrounding the death of Mark, who was a 17-year-old member of the Traveller community.
He and his family had been known to Tusla for a number of years, following reports of domestic violence and alcohol misuse.
During his lifetime, approximately 50 referrals were made concerning the family.
Mark, who had a mild learning disability, was described as "quiet and pleasant".
He was receiving treatment for depression and anxiety through his GP.
In the final years of the teenager's life, there were increasing concerns about his frequent absences from home, substance misuse and involvement in criminal activity.
Tusla's involvement remained inconsistent, until Mark was around 16, when his mother reported that she could no longer cope with his behaviour.
The social work team referred him to a youth service and began an initial assessment through a project worker with the service.
Shortly afterwards, gardaí obtained an emergency care order after finding the teenager intoxicated when his family were unable to collect him.
A referral to Tusla social workers was made by the out-of-hours social work service, which highlighted Mark's need for support to manage his mental health.
The referral was screened and it was determined that no further action was required.
Mark was found dead shortly afterwards.
Teenager's cultural background not considered
The review found that social work intervention throughout the family's history had largely been reactive, responding to concerns raised by professionals - such as gardaí and medical personnel - rather than through proactive engagement.
It found the classification of the case as a child welfare matter did not reflect the level of risk facing Mark.
The only assessment that took place, when Mark was 17, indicated that he was not at risk when directly in his parent's care.
However, the report said that cumulative or hidden harm factors - such as poor housing, criminality, parental substance misuse, parental mental health and domestic abuse - were not considered.
The assessment did not consider the fact that Mark's parents were unable to keep him at home, despite their best efforts, which was a risk factor, according to the report.
"Mark had a learning disability but the implications of this were not evident in the assessment.
"There appeared to be no analysis of Mark's behaviour and whilst outlining a safety goal, the assessment did not provide a realistic plan on how to achieve it," it said.
The review noted good "informal information sharing" between agencies, such as Tusla's Social Work Department, Tusla's Prevention, Partnership and Family Support, gardaí and the youth support service.
However, it also found that, despite the concerns of gardaí about the family's ability to adequately care for their children over time, "this did not become a matter for serious consideration for the SWD (Social Work Department)".
The NRP said that Mark's cultural background as a Traveller had not been considered in his assessment, which it said potentially limited understanding of the additional vulnerabilities that he faced.
It highlighted the importance of culturally sensitive practice, including awareness of the social disadvantages experienced by Traveller families and the elevated suicide risk among Traveller men.
It also emphasised the need for professionals to build trusting relationships with young people and ensure their voices are heard when decisions about their welfare are being made.
Tusla not immediately informed about baby's death, NRP finds
The NRP also examined the circumstances surrounding the case of 11-week-old Niall, who died from natural causes.
His mother had a history of mental health difficulties, alcohol use and domestic violence in a previous relationship, which resulted in several referrals to Tusla before and after his birth.
When the baby was a few weeks old, his mother was admitted to hospital following alcohol misuse and self-harm linked to distress over her housing situation.
The review found there was limited information about Niall's father in Tusla's records and no evidence of an attempt to engage with him.
A social worker was allocated to the family and agreed a safety plan with the mother.
The plan involved extended family members providing support and ensuring the children were not exposed to substance misuse, while Niall's mother continued to engage with addiction services.
However, the social worker experienced difficulties contacting some members of the safety network, which meant that no home visit took place.
An opportunity for meeting the family and gaining first-hand information was missed, according to the NRP.
There was also no permanent public health nurse covering the area, which limited the level of contact available to the family.
Niall died unexpectedly from natural causes shortly after the safety plan was put in place.
His death occurred during a holiday period and Tusla's Social Work Department was not informed by the hospital until several weeks later.
The NRP found that the initial response to concerns about the family was largely appropriate.
However, it noted the failure of other members of the safety network to notify social work services promptly about Niall's death.
The report recommended that future safety plans should include clear contact arrangements for unexpected events, including the death of a child, parent, or member of the safety network.
"It is very important for Tusla to be made aware of such events to assist in planning supportive intervention for the family," it said.
The NRP reviews instances where children in care, in aftercare, or who are receiving supports from child protection services, die or experience serious incidents.
Source: RTÉ News · Ailbhe Conneely
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira