Earlier this year Palmer Luckey, co-founder of the American autonomous weapons systems company Anduril, appeared on a podcast called The Way I Heard it with Mike Rowe. In it, he discussed his ideas on, among other things, energy and climate. Luckey has long been a controversial figure for his hard-right political views. He became famous in his late teens for developing the Oculus VR headset and selling it to Meta (then Facebook) for $2 billion in 2014; two years later, he left the company amid controversy over the revelation that he had donated money to a pro-Trump political action group.
In the years that followed he became a leading innovator in the weapons tech space, developing AI, robotics and surveillance technologies for US defence department contracts. And during this period, of course, Silicon Valley came around to his formerly controversial political position.
On the podcast, Luckey began by talking about how, in a globalised economy in which American companies were competing against foreign companies for market share, the question of energy cost was a crucial one. Low energy price, he said, would ensure that American companies were extremely competitive internationally, and able to afford the cost of skilled labour at home.
This calculation led, naturally enough, to the question of energy consumption and climate change. The kind of AI-led economy that Luckey and people like him are building is, famously, intensely energy hungry, and is driving huge surges in the consumption of fossil fuels and water.
Unlike many of his fellow Republicans, Luckey is not a climate change denier, as such. What he believes is that climate change is happening, that it’s not necessarily such a bad thing, and that in any case there are numerous technological means by which the climate can be manipulated or “fixed”.
“It’s crazy to say we can’t change the climate because we very, very easily can,” he told the podcast host. “This isn’t, like, a crazy conspiracy. There’s maybe a half-dozen very real technologies that could allow us to instantly modulate the temperature of the planet.”
He invoked, by way of example, something called “cloud brightening”, whereby gigantic pumps would be used to shoot seawater back into the sky, creating the sort of white clouds that reflect more sunlight than darker clouds. “It would take a handful of nuclear-powered ships,” he explained, “to lower the earth’s temperature by two or three degrees using cloud brightening.”
The interview is an intriguing and unnerving insight into a particular way of thinking about the world that, because it is so prevalent among the nerd elite of Silicon Valley, has become a presiding ideology of our time. Luckey is well aware, for instance, that the kind of geoengineering technologies – large-scale human interventions in the world’s weather systems – he talks about would likely cause severe climate disruptions, putting extreme stress on already impoverished regions in the global south. But to argue against their use on this basis, he suggests, is to be wilfully ignorant of a world in which there are, naturally, winners and losers. (“We can fight it out in the UN,” he says. “That African nation can come and make their case. Maybe we pay them off.”)
[ The good and the bad of climate change policyOpens in new window ]
With his mullet and soul patch, his penchant for Hawaiian shirts and cargo shorts and flip flops, Luckey might present as an eccentric, but he’s an influential figure in the tech world, and a wholly lucid communicator of a Hobbesian worldview that has become increasingly prevalent within it.
Writing about Luckey’s comments in a recent essay, the writer Eric Tegethoff put it as follows: “That the owner of a defence company making autonomous weapons doesn’t care about the lives of people on other continents – except for Europe, of course – isn’t surprising. But it is a helpful insight into how the Right’s tech billionaire class perceives the cost-benefit analysis of planetary climate hacking.”
[ Peter Thiel-backed AI company Cognition establishes Irish presenceOpens in new window ]
Palantir co-founder Peter Thiel, another far-right tech entrepreneur who has made billions from the nexus of military hardware, surveillance and artificial intelligence, is similarly bullish on increasing fossil fuel consumption now and finding technological solutions to the consequences later. Thiel, as Tegethoff points out, is an investor in Rainmaker, a so-called cloud-seeding technology that uses autonomous drones to inject chemicals into clouds so that they produce more precipitation.
Sam Altman, the OpenAI chief executive, has also spoken of the need for such technological interventions, given the enormous energy requirements of the AI sector. “We do need way more energy in the world than I think we thought we needed before,” he said in a 2024 interview with Bloomberg. “I still expect, unfortunately, the world is on a path where we’re going to have to do something dramatic with climate, like geoengineering, as a Band-Aid, as a stopgap.”
Whether these technologies would work in any kind of meaningful way to allay the worst effects of climate change – and the evidence for their efficacy is extremely patchy – is almost beside the point. Their value consists largely in their capacity to distract from the reality that what is actually needed is a reduction in fossil fuel consumption.
Such a shift away from carbon-intensive fuel would, after all, mean draining the energy out of the AI boom, and jeopardising the further enrichment and empowerment of the tech elite. And why would we ever want to do that, when we can just rely on that same tech elite, those visionary geniuses, to come up with radical technological innovations to save the day? In this way, technology itself can always absolve us in advance of the consequences of our over-investment in it.
And in this thinking can be glimpsed the shadow of an old idea, the Christian notion of providentialism: the belief that all that takes place in this world is a result of God’s plan, and that whatever happens does so for the greater good. Never fear: the Lord will provide. Just as with its older Christian counterpart, this technological providentialism lays itself in the path of any attempt to effect radical change in the present, in the real world where real people live and struggle.
Source: The Irish Times · Mark O’Connell
At a glance
- Topic
- Climate
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira