The Attorney General, Rossa Fanning, has made a notable contribution to the debate on the effectiveness of EU regulation. Speaking at a law conference in Dublin last Friday, he said there was a need to consider whether European law “helps Europe to innovate and compete, or whether its volume and complexity have begun to stand in the way”.

“That is not an argument against European action. But the union can become its own worst enemy if, in seeking to legislate for every legitimate objective, it weakens its practical capacity to attain them.”

There is mounting pressure on the EU to improve its economic performance in the face of Donald Trump’s economic nationalism. The Draghi report set out a comprehensive roadmap for improving EU competitiveness, with a leaner regulatory framework at its core. But progress has been uneven.

Fanning’s most significant point is that member states themselves must engage critically with these questions. Ireland, which has done well from membership and is now a net contributor to the EU budget, is well placed to ask whether European rules are achieving what they set out to do. That kind of candour from national governments is overdue.

He is less persuasive in suggesting EU regulation helps explain the slow pace of infrastructure delivery. Other member states operate under the same rules yet build metros, water plants and grid connections far more quickly and cheaply.

The Government’s own infrastructure plan concedes that Irish environmental assessments are disproportionate compared with elsewhere in Europe. Ireland has often transposed directives at the most demanding standard available, and its failure to implement the Habitats Directive properly leaves projects legally exposed.

The Attorney General might look a little closer to home, at Irish legal culture and the way European rules are written into Irish law by his own department. His intervention is timely. But the case for better regulation should start at home.

Source: The Irish Times · Wed Nov 18 2026 - 20:00 • 2 MIN READ

At a glance

Topic
World
Country
🇮🇪 IE
Publisher language
EN
Added to Allnira