The Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI) has said it will leave “no stone unturned” in recouping €2.7 million in unreturned overpayments to car dealerships.
Legal letters have been issued to several dealership groups, some of which have not engaged on the overpayments made under a scheme to encourage a switch to electric vehicles (EV), the Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee (PAC) heard on Thursday
It was revealed in September SEAI overpaid car dealerships by €3.9 million in grants for EV demonstration models, typically used for test drives and displays before being sold, with just €109,400 being recouped.
Some 15 dealership groups were identified as being overpaid, eight of which have either repaid in full or entered a payment plan since.
To date, €1.3 million had been repaid by dealers, with a further €430,000 agreed through payment plans, the PAC heard, leaving €2.7 million outstanding.
A potential compliance issue was first spotted in February last year by SEAI during payment checks.
The estimated overall amount in overpayments has risen to €4.3 million after SEAI discovered other dealers that were part of a group, committee members heard, while the overall figure could “go up or down”.
“We are in legal correspondence and are making arrangements for legal proceedings to issue if necessary,” said SEAI chief executive William Walsh on the outstanding €2.7 million across seven dealership groups.
“We’re confident and we’ll leave no stone unturned in ensuring we get that money back,” he said, accepting it was “a lot of money”.
Some €9.9 million of the €66.5 million paid in EV grants were for demonstration vehicles last year, while €35.1 million has been paid since 2020.
As the grants amount to State aid to private enterprises under European Union rules, regulations prohibit payments totalling more than €300,000 during any rolling three-year-period.
However, the threshold applies to a single undertaking, rather than to each individual entity, and SEAI ultimately identified 80 individual dealers linked to 15 car dealership groups with cumulative aid exceeding the threshold.
Although there was ongoing engagement with dealership groups on the unpaid €2.7 million, Declan Meally, SEAI’s director of business, said a “small number” have not engaged.
“That’s why we’re going through a staged process. The current stage that we’re in now is just saying that we’ve issued letters from solicitors to move into the legal process for those that are outstanding,” he said.
In its report, the Comptroller and Auditor General said a key part of SEAI’s compliance with state-aid rules was self-declaration by car dealerships as to their linked status.
“This process did not result in full identification of all such groups,” it said.
A formal declaration process for new dealers joining the scheme was not in place until February 2025, though dealers were required to confirm they had not exceeded the applicable thresholds.
Source: The Irish Times · Jack White
At a glance
- Topic
- World
- Country
- 🇮🇪 IE
- Publisher language
- EN
- Added to Allnira